Transcript 0:01 All right, you're listening to Evan Knowles with the Middle Tech Podcast, and today we're going to discuss why real estate has been slower to adopt technology than many other industries. The answer is simple, 0:11 uh, in that it is very complex. Uh, so it's kind of, uh, an oxymoron there, but this complexity is actually what got me so interested in the industry and so passionate about it. 0:22 Complexity is throughout every aspect of the industry. 0:25 One simple example is the ability for someone to fall in love with one home's backyard compared to hating another home's backyard, or an investor getting outsized returns because of a property's location and the right time in the market. 0:41 All the way through to there's complexity involved in the database that creates the marketplace within the industry. So let's talk about that complexity and why it's slowed down innovation. Let's get into it. 0:55 Middle Tech is presented by KY Innovation, the Kentucky Cabinet for Economic Development's Entrepreneurship and Innovation partner. 1:02 KY Innovation exists to support and develop Kentucky's startup ecosystem, and we are proud to work alongside an organization whose mission aligns so closely with ours. 1:11 If you're a founder building in Kentucky, you need to check out the resources that KY Innovation has to offer. You can find more information at KYInnovation.com. We are also sponsored by Bolt Marketing. 1:23 As a business owner, you're forced to wear multiple hats, but you should be focused on growing your business while you let somebody else handle your marketing. 1:31 Our friends over at Bolt offer a full suite of services from websites to branding that will help you transform your marketing and grow your business. 1:41 To learn more about how Bolt can help you with your business goals, you can check them out at BuildWithBolt.com. Again, that's BuildWithBolt.com. So buying and selling a home is a huge transaction. 1:55 It's the biggest transaction consumers will make in their entire life. So, uh, I just want to walk you through some of the steps and kind of paint the picture of why this is so complex. 2:05 So when buying a home, uh, consumers would typically go through all of these steps, uh, at least some of them, the majority of them. 2:13 Uh, they go through a major life event, like they move to a new city, uh, they have children, they get a divorce, they get a new job, or they might be retiring. 2:22 Uh, after they have that life event, uh, they might need a new home. So they start looking for a real estate agent. Uh, they have to go look at homes that attract them, uh, with that real estate agent. 2:32 And that real estate agent finds homes to show that consumer, uh, on the MLS. Uh, they then have to find a home they like and begin submitting offers and bid against other consumers that might want that home as well. 2:45 They also have to get pre-approved to get a mortgage. And then when that offer goes down, they have to negotiate with the bank, uh, their interest rate and terms on that mortgage. 2:58 They then have to work with the title company to get a title to the home. They have to get an inspection to make sure that the quality is what they expected when they put the offer down. 3:07 And then they have to renegotiate if that inspection comes back and there's results in it that warrant, uh, a renegotiation. And then finally, to finalize the deal, uh, they've got to figure out how to pay the mortgage. 3:19 They've got to figure out all of the contractors and vendors needed to help them move in. Then they got to pay the real estate agent and a lot of the other closing items that come along with buying a home. 3:31 So the real estate transaction is very, very complicated and consumers need a real estate agent to do this. So right there, uh, there's complexity. 3:40 And it takes a special professional to take and walk a consumer through this transaction because of how complex it is. So 90% of consumers work with real estate agents when buying or selling a home. 3:51 Uh, that's important to understand. And because of the many stakeholders involved in a real estate transaction, consumers have never really had a seamless way to buy a home. 4:00 That transaction has always been very fragmented and that fragmentation prevents innovation. So, uh, that's kind of the consumer's perspective. 4:08 Now I want to look at it from a kind of deep dive into the space and into the industry and what's kind of going on behind the scenes that actually causes this fragmentation for the consumer and for anybody else involved in the space. 4:21 Uh, there's three kind of things I want to touch on. Number one is regulation. Number two is the local nature of the industry. And number three is the average age of participants in the industry. 4:32 So let's start with, uh, regulation. So the primary regulating body for the real estate industry is the National Association of Realtors. 4:41 Uh, they are an American trade organization that basically self-regulates the entire real estate market. So they're a very important entity. 4:48 Now, the major decisions are made by NAR and this middleman in the market means that things can move, uh, slowly. Uh, they can't really move that fast, uh, in a space where there is this governing body. 5:01 You know, we see that in the government, uh, within the United States, a big, a big bureaucracy. Uh, they're there for a reason. They're there to protect people. 5:08 Uh, but that middleman regulating the market does slow things down. However, a lot of what they do is very, very important. So let's walk through some of that. 5:19 Uh, here's where regulation becomes a problem for innovation. So regulation prevents a lot of the industry players like mortgages, mortgage providers, title companies, and insurance agents. 5:31 Uh, they prevent these, uh, different parties from, uh, having financial incentives that work against consumers. 5:39 So they're literally fragmenting the transaction of buying a home and these different vendors on purpose because once you start to get financial incentives misaligned with consumers, then the housing industry becomes really dangerous. 5:53 Uh, and I think we're starting to see some of that with corporatism and some of these new innovative models and it penetrating the market and bringing, you know, unknown, uh, results and consequences that we've never seen before. 6:06 So we're starting to see some of that and regulation is starting to come down on those businesses. 6:10 And so it's been very difficult for a business, a single business to scale vertically and become vertically integrated and have real estate agents and have mortgage brokers and have title company and have all of these things in one company that hasn't been possible due to that fragmentation. 6:25 So that prevents a seamless transaction for consumers and it prevents a lot of innovation, but that does protect consumers from having financial incentives and collusion work against them. 6:37 So let's talk about data fragmentation. So one of the important things that NAR does is it regulates the what's called multiple listing service or MLS for short. 6:47 This is essentially the database that contains the entire real estate market and all the history and activity related to it. 6:53 So it's actually one of the most valuable databases in the United States that nobody really thinks about very often. So despite it being such an important database, it's a complete fragmented mess. Why is that? 7:06 Well, real estate is a very local industry. Each market controls and manages its own MLS database. So there's not one single MLS across the United States that works and syncs across the entire country. 7:21 This is purposeful though. Think about the fact of this has evolved over time. 7:27 This actually evolved from physical books with every real estate listing being put in them and every month the new book or every quarter would be brought to a brokerage office and then consumers would look through the book and find homes in the market. 7:40 But as the MLS developed and the internet penetrated the market, each MLS and each market began to develop their own database and their own technology or licensed technology. 7:53 And so this meant that Kentucky's MLS and Indiana's MLS were never connected. They were never the same technology. They were never able to talk to each other. 8:06 And so there was no way for a consumer in Kentucky to see what was in Indiana unless they worked with an Indiana agent. So it was just complete fragmented and there's no standard or data layer or API to this database. 8:21 And that's beginning to change and we're starting to see some innovation due to that. But this fragmentation of the database has been another reason the industry has been very fragmented. 8:31 So for years, this has been a huge barrier for innovation because tech companies have a hard time scaling across the United States and across different geographies if they can't get access to that data and reach a wide audience of agents and consumers delivering technology solutions. 8:47 So this might sound like a no-brainer to fix, but it really isn't that easy. 8:51 This fragmentation and this regulation around this database is actually the thing holding the industry together and protecting consumers from a poor buying and selling experience. 9:02 If the MLS didn't exist or it wasn't regulated so closely, the market would be complete chaos. Real estate transactions would be substantially more difficult. 9:11 And so imagine you're buying a home and you had to visit five to 10 different sites to look for available homes and one home is not on another website. 9:22 And so each website would have its own listings and that's just not feasible for a consumer to actually have a good buying experience and get a complete picture of the market unless that MLS is protected. 9:34 Because for a home to hit the market and for an agent to market that home, it has to go on the MLS. 9:40 And so within every region and every market that an MLS covers, every home listing, unless it's for sale by owner, is on that MLS. 9:48 And so as a consumer, you can go to one place, aka a real estate agent, to find all of the homes within that given market without having to go have this very fragmented experience across all these websites. 10:01 So it's kind of counterintuitive where fragmentation of the MLS across the nation leads to a better experience on a local level. And so that's another reason that innovation has been slow to enter the space. 10:15 And then finally, I want to talk about the average age of a participant. So those that are professionals within the real estate industry, on average, they're 55 years old. 10:25 And so with that demographic comes people that don't lean so heavily on technology like younger generations. This has created lagging demand for innovation. So new agents, they have higher standards for 10:39 real estate technology. Consumers have higher standards for technology in general. 10:44 And so technology is beginning to catch up, but we've got to realize that the average age of a person that is a professional in the real estate industry is 55 years old. And so 10:54 this is another reason that innovation has been slow to enter the space. And here's how to paint that picture is a lot of agents still use pen and paper to track their business. 11:03 So when was the last time you walked into a small business or worked with a professional and their business was run from a notebook? You can find that very frequently within the real estate industry. 11:14 And this will change with time. We're already seeing innovation start to accelerate. 11:18 But most innovative and successful companies in the property technology space and real estate space are companies like Zillow or Redfin. Zillow is the most notable. 11:30 And what they did was they basically created the Google of real estate. So their journey was far from easy. It took them a very long time to navigate this fragmentation and regulation, but they did it. 11:41 And a few companies since Zillow have entered the space and really changed it a whole lot. 11:46 MLS providers are now starting to, again, like I said earlier, begin to create a data standard and a standard across all of the different demographics and regions and build an API architecture. 11:59 And this is going to allow new companies to enter the space. And another thing to watch is FinTech. FinTech is beginning to enter the space very rapidly. 12:08 Financial transaction the size of a home warrants better financial technology. So you're starting to see that as well. So as data becomes more available to leverage new products and consumers, 12:19 or rather new products for consumers and industry professionals will enter the space. For us consumers, we have something to look forward to, which is an ever improving home buying experience. 12:31 Although it might be slower than other industries are progressing, the future is looking a lot better because of this new data layer that is becoming a standard and because expectations are rising as agents get younger and more agents are entering the space that are used to better technology. 12:47 Now, will there ever be a one button click home buying experience? That is very unlikely to happen anytime soon, but we're getting closer.