Transcript 0:00 [music] Welcome back to Weekend Thoughts. My name is Nate Antotomaso. Over the past few years, there's a new drink category that's dominated the market. That's hard seltzers. We've all had them. 0:12 There's no hard seltzer that's more widely known than White Claw, and I've been thinking how there's a lot of competing brands now, but all of these brands failed to meet the trend at its hottest, and they're paying for it. 0:27 Let's go. 0:42 [music] If you're like me, you've had your fair share of hard seltzers in the past few years. 0:59 I remember even before White Claw came out, there was the trend where you would mix LaCroix with vodka. Everybody was doing it. 1:05 Now it's everybody flockin', need a decoy Shorty mixin' up the vodka with the LaCroix, yeah The health craze popularized seltzer, and it spilled over to the social lives of my age group at the perfect time. 1:20 Just as we were growing out of frat drinks and cheap beer, White Claw was there. The world changed when White Claw came out. The minimal white, they were like skinny cans. They reflected like lives we wanted to live. 1:34 They were a statement piece. It's, it was a bit girly at first, to be honest, but all the girls were drinking them and they tasted pretty good, so of course, the guys started to do it, too. 1:46 No longer were we schlepping six-packs to the pregame. No longer was it, "Do you want a Miller Lite or a Natty?" It was, "I'll bring the Claws." 1:54 It's hard to overstate just how popular White Claw was in like 2018, 2019-ish timeframe. They were everywhere, ubiquitous, the only thing you wanted to drink. 2:08 The biggest argument wasn't if you were drinking White Claw or not, but which of the flavors you were gonna be drinking. They had a 200% growth year over year for three straight years. 2:21 All of that led up to a national shortage of White Claw in 2019. That's how popular they were during the summer. 2:28 I remember going to the grocery store that summer on a Thursday night because I knew that that's when they got their shipments in. Who does that? Like, that's ridiculous. That should not have been a priority of mine. 2:39 Uh, but it was. That's just how big they were. But of course, like all trends, things change. Things die down. 2:48 After those years of over 200% growth, the drink slowed to only 130% growth this past year, and with estimates that hard seltzer will only grow an average of 15% per year over the next five. 3:04 So from 200 to 130 to an average of 15 over five, that's quite the leveling off in growth. 3:13 So we've, we've reached this moment now in the story of hard seltzers where everyone and their mother is releasing their own brand even though that growth is slowing down. 3:24 But there's brands everywhere from Topo Chico to Bud Light to your local brewery to even TikTok influencers. Everybody has their own brand, their own version of a flavored hard seltzer drink. 3:37 Boston Beer, who creates Sam Adams, their founder, Jim Koch, argues that there have been so many seltzer brands released recently that it's led to consumer confusion, quote, unquote. 3:49 This comes at a cost for the cultural icon that is White Claw. In 2019, on-premise sales of White Claw, meaning sales at a bar, were 60% of all seltzers. Now that's down to 40%. 4:03 It's estimated that this trend is even more exaggerated in off-premise sales, meaning cans or bottles that you buy at the store. That market share has taken a hit even further in cans. 4:15 In 2020, that off-premise hard seltzer market was $4.1 billion compared to the off-premise beer market of $40 billion. I bring that up because I think this is why more brands are entering the market. 4:30 Even with all this growth, seltzer is only one-tenth of the size of beer, and if you think about beer market share, there's no single brand, no single beer that has anywhere near the market share that White Claw has. 4:43 So more brands are entering to chip away at that market share because they see how the beer market is split up, and they think that it, that seltzer is going to be similar. 4:56 But regardless of this slowing growth, nobody is saying that seltzer is going to go away, so that's why these companies are chipping away at White Claw slowly but surely. 5:07 But that's all they're doing is chipping away and spending a hell of a lot of marketing dollars to do that. So besides the fun of drinking seltzers and thinking about it, why are we talking about it? 5:21 What's the business lesson to be learned here? I think it's pretty simple. Trends happen fast, super fast. Corporate decision-making falls behind the speed of consumption these days. 5:34 Trends have been coming and going quicker and quicker. Memes now dictate what's cool or not, and things die as quickly as they come to life. 5:42 This has been happening at an ever-increasing pace over the last couple of decades, and since 2019, it's skyrocketed because of TikTok and changing consumer trends as a result of the pandemic. 5:55 Things happen, and then they stop. Shit is cool, and then it's not, like that. White Claw was cool. They saw the gap in the market. 6:05 They innovated with a new product to fill that gap, and they made sure the world knew about it, and they made a fuck ton of sales by doing that. Bud Light and Vizzy and all these other seltzer brands, they missed it. 6:17 They're making decent sales. 6:18 It, it's a good business, but they missed the moment, and they're nowhere near that, that cultural grasp that White Claw had and the money that they made because of that, and they never will be. 6:31 The innovator made its mark, and it still dominates the industry. 6:35 The laggards are chipping away, but they're all just fighting for those scraps with expensive awareness campaigns to get their logo and their flavor out there. It pays to innovate. It pays to be White Claw. 6:47 Now more than ever, it pays to move quickly. It'll be a long, long time before the two terms White Claw and seltzer don't mean the same thing to us because they are the innovator, and they won. 7:04 [outro music]