Transcript 0:00 Welcome back to Weekend Thoughts. My name is Nate Antotomaso. 0:04 This week, uh, if you are a fan of hip-hop or music in general, you've probably heard of what's going on with YSL, Young Slime Life down in Atlanta, rappers Young Thug and Gunna. 0:18 Um, a lot of legal stuff there, which we're just gonna talk about a little bit, but what I have been thinking about is the fact that art and the creative outlet of these rappers is on trial, and I think there's a lot of implications to that. 0:34 Let's go. Middle Tech is presented by KY Innovation, the Kentucky Cabinet for Economic Development's entrepreneurship and innovation partner. 0:42 KY Innovation exists to support and develop Kentucky's startup ecosystem, and we are proud to work alongside an organization whose mission aligns so closely with ours. 0:51 If you're a founder building in Kentucky, you need to check out the resources that KY Innovation has to offer. You can find more information at kyinnovation.com. We are also sponsored by Bolt Marketing. 1:03 As a business owner, you're forced to wear multiple hats, but you should be focused on growing your business while you let somebody else handle your marketing. 1:11 Our friends over at Bolt offer a full suite of services, from websites to branding, that will help you transform your marketing and grow your business. 1:21 To learn more about how Bolt can help you with your business goals, you can check them out at buildwithbolt.com. Again, that's buildwithbolt.com. 1:32 All right, so before we jump into this, I want to say that I am not a legal expert by any means. I am definitely not a hip-hop expert, although just a fan of the genre in general. 1:45 Uh, definitely not a RICO or a racketeering expert. Um, but what I am is a creator, and I empower other creators through Middle Tech, through this company, through the networks that we've created. 1:58 So the output of content is something that I am very familiar with, um, and that's kind of the lens that I'm approaching this issue with. 2:08 To go over the basics here, a couple weeks ago, there was an 88-page indictment filed in Georgia's Fulton County that alleges that rappers Young Thug and Gunna, along with others, are involved in a street gang affiliated with the Bloods. 2:23 Uh, that street gang is YSL, Young Slime Life. Uh, that's also the name of their, uh, their label as well. 2:31 Um, so there's a lot of, you know, kind of overlap between their official music business and then this alleged gang, YSL. Uh, the indictment, like I said, is 88 pages. 2:41 It outlines 181 acts that prosecutors say were committed starting in 2013 as part of an alleged RICO conspiracy to further the interests of the gang. 2:54 What is especially interesting here is that the indictment itself cites music videos and lyrics within songs as evidence to strengthen the argument that this is a gang that commits illegal acts. 3:07 The indictment cited that as evidence, and a judge then quickly passed that off and said that's fine, that can be allowed to be used as evidence in the courtroom. So there's some specific examples here. 3:19 Uh, there's a lyric in a Young Thug song where he says, uh, he's never killed anybody, but he has something to do with the body, implying murder there. 3:27 Uh, and then countless references to possessions of drugs and firearms. 3:34 So first off, I wanna say, obviously, I don't know if these 181 or any number of them, if these acts were committed, if those two or any of the other members of the gang could do criminal activity. 3:47 If that's the case, they should be punished. But I wanna approach this, uh, from the lens of art. Rap and the lyrics and the music and the poetry, in some cases, of rap, I would argue is artistic expression. 4:03 Of course, there's limits on what you can and, and can't say in artistic expression, but simply mentioning violence or drugs or even mentioning a crime in an abstract sense falls within the limits of what you're able to do. 4:16 Rappers put on personas. We all know this. 4:19 I'm not sure if, if Young Thug having something to do with a murder is a persona, but I guarantee you that there's rappers who have said that they've done things and say things about their lifestyle and what they do every day that simply is not true. 4:34 It's a character. It's a persona. And if that's the case, is all rap subject to scrutiny now? Is all music subject to scrutiny? All art in general? This is a very, very dangerous precedent to be set. 4:48 Not only could it embolden prosecutors to proactively comb through rap and other arts that are already released to see where they can, can say gotcha on an artist, but it also could scare creators before they put something out in the first place and could limit the art that is put out into the world. 5:07 If we don't have one more rap song about drugs or about guns, that's not that big of a deal, but it's obviously the first step down a very, very slippery slope about what people feel safe releasing, what content people feel like they can put out. 5:23 I do wanna take a step back here and say that Young Thug and Gunna are not the first rappers to have lyrics used against them. Tekashi 6ix9ine was a recent example in that trial that happened a few years ago. 5:34 But previous proposed legis- legislation in New York around the same time was, was, uh, proposed to try to disallow using lyrics in the courtroom because of the understanding that it is art and it is protected speech. 5:49 But again, this goes beyond rap. I think about, in a much more subtle and much less serious way, Middle Tech. What if in an episode of this podcast we give bad advice about a startup or about cryptocurrency? 6:04 You know, obviously we're, we're not telling you to, to make an investment or to do something, and we don't give official financial advice, but what if we say we like something and then it crashes? 6:14 Are we liable for that? What if we say something about a company that is incorrect without our knowledge? We say something about a founder, about a situation, it's wrong. 6:25 Could we be at risk if what we said was wrong and painted a negative light that actually wasn't the case? 6:31 We do our best to be truthful and, and to give our true opinions, but when we put content out there, we're invariably going to say something that won't come true or may not be true in the time. 6:43 And if, if that content is our art, these are our opinions, this is our creation out into the world, is that gonna be used in court against us? 6:51 The members of YSL should be punished, of course, if they committed criminal acts, but they should not be punished because of song lyrics, and those song lyrics should not take the place of concrete evidence in court. 7:04 Content, opinions, words in an art form, whatever that art form may be, should not be concrete evidence in court. No matter what form of art it is, it should be recognized and appreciated as an expression of the creator. 7:20 Again, this is me from my creator lens. If you have more of a legal take on this or you have a little bit more context on why specifically these lyrics are being passed, please let me know. Hit me up on social. 7:31 I wanna know. I wanna learn here. 7:34 I wanna make sure that, that we can empower people in this age of, of increased creativity to continue to be increased in their creative, to continue to feel free to put their creativity out there.