Transcript 0:00 All right. Good morning, everyone. Welcome to MetalTech's Friday update on this beautiful Friday morning. Hope everyone is up and at it and ready to attack the day. 0:08 Uh, we've got some awesome stories to cover, uh, from this past week. 0:11 So a few that you guys have probably heard about as you've been on social media, obviously the Elon Musk story, uh, him offering, uh, I think it was 43 billion for Twitter, somewhere around there. 0:22 Uh, Meta charging some wild fees for the metaverse, and then we also have this new battery plant going into Bowling Green. So lots of exciting stuff to talk about. 0:31 Let's get Evan and Nathan in here, and we'll get started. What's up, Evan? What's up, Nate? Hey. Good morning. Morning. Hey. Well, we've got a good this week in tech history that I need to go over real quick. 0:42 So in 1961, Yuri Gargian... Gagarin, Gagarin, I'm gonna go with that, becomes the first man to go to space at the age of 27. 0:52 And in the 61 years since then, do you guys wanna guess how many people have been to space in the 61 years since Yuri? I saw the document, so I can't guess. Um... That's ridiculous. That is a terrible guess. 57. 1:05 It's over 600. [laughs] To be honest though- What? [laughs]... if, if I saw... If I hadn't seen the answer, I would've guessed 200 maybe. Yeah. 600 seems like a ton. Yeah. 1:19 I guess it does when you think about it, but that's globally, so. Yeah. So yeah, whatever. Is Yuri Russian? He is, yeah. Oh. I was gonna leave that part out. Oh, okay. [laughs] Well, I guess I called it out. 1:29 [laughs] Yeah. Hey, we, we were the first to the moon. That's what matters. That's right. That's right. Um, Evan, you wanna go over our sponsors real quick before we get, uh, things started here? Yeah, for sure. 1:38 So as usual, we've got our presenting sponsor, KY Innovation. They're doing amazing things for the state of Kentucky along the lines of technology and innovation and startups and entrepreneurship. 1:49 Uh, so again, all kinds of great programs that support entrepreneurs like ourselves, so we encourage you to check out their resources. Uh, we've also got Render Capital. 1:59 So Render Capital, uh, is a venture capital firm out of Louisville, Kentucky, that operates primarily out of Indiana and Louisville. 2:08 Uh, they have a competition called the Render Competition that I participated and was a winner of, uh, last year. Uh, they've got open applications right now, so we encourage you to go check that out. 2:18 The Render team is amazing, uh, to work with, and the Render Competition is a great way to kick off your- Absolutely... fundraising journey. So check them out. Render- Render.capital... no, it's render.com/competition. 2:31 They got the whole thing in that URL. Render.capital/competition. Yeah, you almost had it. You almost had it. Well, cool. Let's, uh, let's dive into some of the breaking news coming out of Kentucky. 2:40 Uh, so anybody in the state should definitely be excited for, uh, what's shaping up to be another record year in terms of economic development for the state. 2:48 [clears throat] Um, so there is another battery plant, this time coming to Bowling Green. Uh, it's gonna be a $2 billion investment. 2:55 So Evan, you wanna give us the lowdown on, you know, the significance of this and what this means for the state? Yeah. 3:01 I mean, this is coming off the news of the, uh, Ford, uh, SK Innovation, uh, announcement in, uh, Glendale, and that was a $6 billion project, so it's basically two gigafactories there. 3:16 It's, uh, gonna be the largest battery factory, I think, in the world. Um, it's gonna be 5,000 jobs. So this is just adding to, uh, the battery facilities here in Kentucky. 3:27 And if you look at what they describe as, like, the corridor, which is I-65 and, like, this region, uh, it's now the battery capital of the entire world, uh, which is very cool. 3:39 Uh, so there's gonna be about 2,000 jobs, uh, su- supported by this new factory. Uh, and this, this factory is gonna support several car manufacturers with, uh, with battery manufacturing. So very exciting for Kentucky. 3:52 Um, I was just with a friend, uh, my co-founder, Ryan Harris, the other day. 3:56 His dad, uh, does development in Elizabethtown and kind of that area, and there was a study done on how many jobs, uh, will be brought by the Glendale facility. 4:07 So 5,000 direct jobs within the manufacturing plant, but 30,000, uh, indirect, uh, jobs will be created. And so what that means for the community is there's gonna need to be a lot more housing. 4:20 There's gonna be a lot more businesses started and a lot more just economic development within that community. And so the same thing's gonna be happening around Bowling Green and Nashville and that whole I-65 corridor. 4:30 Uh, so very exciting, uh, for Kentucky. This is a huge deal. Uh, this is not gonna be the last one. Uh, Kentucky's gonna get several more of these, uh, and so it's just gonna continue to happen. 4:39 We're right in the middle of the United States. We got I-65. A lot of the big motorcar manufacturers are along I-65, so this is a great place to be. Yeah. Yeah. 4:48 It seems like this has been a, a very concerted effort, um, on the part of the government to, to make Kentucky this battery capital of the United States. 4:56 So I think that's, uh, been a great path for them to go down, and I'm excited to see these projects kind of pan out. Yeah. I think it'll be really interesting to see what other companies this attracts. 5:05 I mean, to have- Mm-hmm... these types of factories, uh, in Kentucky and, um, you know, in that specific area of Kentucky. 5:13 The economic impact, kinda like what Evan mentioned, the follow-on jobs and the other jobs that are- Yeah... gonna come from this. I mean, we've got... 5:18 I think the total would be around 7,000 or 8,000 direct jobs that are gonna come from these factories, but it's hard telling how much economic development's gonna be spurred by this. 5:26 So big kudos to Kentucky State government, to Andy Beshear's administration for, for making this happen. Uh, just exciting stuff. Exciting time to be a Kentuckian. 5:34 So, um, we'll continue to keep you guys updated as we hear more about that. But, uh, it's always good to be highlighting something Kentucky's doing right on these Friday updates. 5:43 So let's, [laughs] uh, let's move on to this next story, uh, Meta and Web3 and virtual fees. Um, Nate, I want you to kind of give us the rundown on what's going on. 5:52 I know you're, out of all of us probably, uh, you and Danny are probably the Web3 guys that are diving into it the deepest. So talk about what the hell's Meta doing in Web3 right now. 6:02 Yeah, so I think there's a couple different facets to this story. 6:05 Um, some of our, our listeners and, and watchers of this may have seen yesterday some headlines that said Meta, again, previously Facebook, uh, is going to take 50% of, uh, a 50% fee of sales through their new basically metaverse ecosystem, and I think it's important to break that down, um, a little bit. 6:25 So Meta has, uh, the Horizon, um, and then the Oculus, like Oculus is the physical headset, Horizons is that, the actual metaverse that they've created so far. 6:37 Um, so there's a 47.5% fee, which is how people round it up to 50%, but that even breaks down into two pieces. 6:45 Any type of software sales through the Quest store, so if you're buying the game or if you're buying an app basically on the Quest store, there's gonna be a 30% fee on that. 6:56 Once you're in a game or if you're in Horizon Worlds, the piece that, that Meta built itself, and you buy an item in the virtual world, that's a 17.5% fee. So theoretically, those could be stacked, um, for a developer. 7:11 If you buy their app and then you buy an item in the app, that's how you get to the 47.5% fee. Uh, people were really freaking out about this yesterday for two reasons. 7:22 One is because, uh, Zuckerberg specifically has been very, very negative about Apple charging a 30% fee on their App Store. Um, but I also think it's important we put that in context. 7:35 Uh, that's for all charges on the App Store, so that could be both app purchases and in-app purchases, which if we're using the stacking methodology here, what is that, 60%? 7:46 Um, so that it, it does kind of line up more there, but the fact that Zuckerberg kept saying like, "Apple is so predatory," and was part... 7:55 one of the big voices that started making Apple rethink that 30%, it's interesting that they're now charging high prices as well. 8:02 It's also interesting because the whole idea of the metaverse and Web3 decentralization in general is power back to the creator. Um, you know, how can people get paid adequately for their work? 8:14 And if we're centralizing the metaverse and we're charging close to 50%, that goes against that whole ethos, and it also is not competitive when you look at other platforms, um, such as like OpenSea, where you can sell digital items right now. 8:27 I think they have a 2.5% fee. 8:29 Um, so just magnitudes different, um, business model there, and understandably, creators are upset because they expected something very different from Meta after what Zuckerberg has been saying over the past couple years. 8:42 Yeah, Evan, what do you think? Uh, I think these are, you know, pretty normal fees. Um, you know, Apple has a similar fee for the App Store. So for instance, if, uh, somebody does- Yeah... 8:51 in-app payments, you know, we'd have to pay 30%. Eventually, uh, once we hit a million dollars in revenue, you start paying that 30%. So I mean, that's not out of question. Uh, it's, it's aligned with Apple. 9:03 Um, you know, like, like, uh, like Nate said, you know, it is unfortunate, uh, that they were talking, um, against Apple on that fee and now they're just kind of copying them, so kind of hypocritical there. 9:16 But beyond that, I don't have a whole lot else to say. 9:18 Um, I think that, you know, when you provide a new platform, uh, you should be able to monetize it in the way that you wish, uh, and the market will determine, uh, whether or not that fee's in a good spot, because if that fee's too high, people won't come onto the platform and they'll have to lower it. 9:33 So- That is-... the market will speak for itself... the most Evan McMullin-esque argument that you could have possibly said. [laughs] Um, but I agree partially. Uh, I think that it's just very anti-metaverse, anti-Web3. 9:43 Um, I mean, Web3 Twitter, at least the part of it that I follow, was kind of rejoicing at this. They were like, "This is literally helping us out by them doing this because the fees are so high." 9:51 Like, "This is so anti-Web3-" That's interesting... that it's gonna push people further towards Web3," just because there's already a sentiment of people not liking Meta as is. 9:59 So especially with these headlines of saying, "Oh, they're charging 50%," maybe it drives more people to look into Web3 and the, the benefits of that. 10:06 Um, but yeah, there's still a lot to be done in terms of developing the metaverse and where all this will go, so I'm sure there'll be some evolutions of all this as well. Mm-hmm. Yeah. 10:15 Um, much more, real quick, much more of a philosophical debate around this, but I mean, if, if Horizon Worlds is Facebook's metaverse, and then, you know, there'll be other entrants into whatever the metaverse is, whether it's from other companies or, you know, from more decentralized organizations, like fa- everyone has a Facebook. 10:34 Everyone's mom has a Facebook, so they're just positioned to be able to like create this large metaverse if they make the onboarding easy, and 10:44 I think because of that, they can command these fees, where if it's kind of an upstart metaverse from some decentralized org, they, they can't command that same revenue split. 10:53 So I think we're gonna see a dichotomy in, in what people experience when they think of like a decentralized internet. Yeah. That's just interesting to me. Yeah. I like that a lot. Yeah, it's a good point. 11:05 Um, all right, well let's move on to this final story, and that is the one that, uh, you probably cannot escape this past week, and that is Elon Musk, uh, making an offer to purchase Twitter. 11:16 Um, so at the, at the front here, there's been, um, some different like finance terms thrown around that I just want to establish before digging into this any deeper. 11:23 So we've got a hostile takeo- takeover that I just wanted to define. 11:27 That's just ess- essentially when a company or a person, person in this case, attempts to take over another company against the wishes of the target company's management. 11:35 That can be done through a tender offer, uh, which is essentially what Elon Musk has done by offering above market rates, uh, for the shares to the shareholders. 11:43 And now another term I want to define is poison pill, which is likely what Twitter is, is considering in some form or fashion. 11:49 That's just essentially when they can issue new shares at a discount to existing shareholders, dilute, uh, the ownership stake of that person who's trying to acquire them, uh, to where they don't... 12:01 it would be a lot more expensive essentially, and disincentivize that person from taking them over. 12:05 So- Wanted to establish that because I've seen those words kinda thrown around a lot, and just wanted to make sure everyone understood what was going on here. 12:13 But Evan, our go-to in-house finance guy, uh, why don't you- And Elon Musk guy... kick us off by... And Elon Musk guy. Big Elon Musk fan. 12:21 Uh, kick us off by talking what your thoughts are on this whole, um, arrangement going down, and any other thoughts that you have on the whole situation. Yeah. 12:31 I think the only way this isn't gonna go through is if the SEC finds some reason to block it. 12:36 Uh, other than that, I think it's gonna have to go through because, uh, Twitter shareholders are, uh, given an offer here that is pretty ridiculous. 12:44 I mean, Elon Musk is just coming in and saying, "Hey, I'm gonna buy this way above market value." Um, which is, you know, you rarely see that, uh, at this magnitude of a... 12:55 You know, he's the richest person on earth so, you know, he has the money. He doesn't care about the economics. He said that himself. He does not care. He just wants to buy it. 13:03 Um, so if, if the board doesn't allow this to go through, then they'll be going directly against, you know, shareholders, and there's really no question about that. 13:11 Uh, if you're a shareholder, you want the best and highest monetary value possible for those shares. 13:16 Uh, nobody's ever, uh, come close to this kind of offer, uh, so this is, this is quite the offer that, uh, you know, is not gonna be able to be turned down. 13:24 Again, I think the only way that this doesn't go through is the SEC turns it down. Um, and as far as what he wants to do with Twitter, uh, that's unknown. 13:32 Uh, but I think he wants to make some big changes, uh, along the lines of censorship, uh, and start to kinda push back on, uh, censorship in, in a big way, um, which, you know, can be dangerous. You know, he... 13:47 I, I trust that he uses logic in his decisions versus politics. 13:51 Uh, he's, you know, the greatest problem solver we've ever seen, so this is a problem that he wants to try to tackle as well, which is, you know, how do you, uh, maintain free speech on the internet, uh, while also keeping people safe? 14:04 I think he has something in mind for that, or else he wouldn't be buying Twitter. Uh, so I think it's gonna be interesting what he does afterwards. 14:10 As far as, you know, the finance side of this, I mean, it's a, it's a great offer. I mean, Twitter, uh, is probably years away from being able to produce that kind of value in their sh- in their shares. 14:21 Uh, and so, you know, shareholders would much rather take that now. I mean, he, he pushed the price up, um, from I think like 30-something dollars to now it's, uh, 50-something dollars. 14:31 I haven't looked at the share price this morning. Uh- Mm... so it's, he pushed it up- Nate, what's your take?... if not more. I mean, I, I agree with everything you say there. 14:38 I know that a lot of large shareholders of Twitter, um, have come out, or maybe a lot's an exaggeration. 14:45 A few have come out, um, [laughs] on Twitter and saying they, they reject the offer and, you know, the, what Twitter can become. 14:53 And it's, it's, you know, the fact that it can be owned by many people as a public company, like the long-term value of it would be much greater than what they think Elon Musk could even buy today at $54 a share. 15:06 Is there any consideration there when you think of fiduciary duty, or is it just today this is a good deal, it would, we have to take it as a fiduciary of the company? No, you take it, you take it today. I mean, you... 15:18 There's no way that they're gonna be able to produce, you know, 30 or 40%, uh, alpha on top of where they were this, this quickly. Um, they hadn't shown any signs of being able to do that. 15:29 Uh, their management team just turned over. Yeah. Uh, he's never run a company of this magnitude. He's never run a media company. So it, you know, Twitter's just not in a good spot. 15:39 It's just- Twitter's such an interesting, uh, company when we think of, you know, tech companies and specifically social media. 15:46 Like, I feel like it's in- the influence it has is really outsized of the size of company that it is in Silicon Valley. Um, and I think that puts it in a unique spot for Elon to be able to do this- Yeah... 15:56 which is super interesting. But I also understand, and I don't know how much of a consideration this should be, but I understand, um, it being off-putting to some people. 16:05 Like, should the richest person in the world just be able to buy a massive media company that has a global reach and just own it? Like- Mm-hmm... that, that can be scary. 16:14 Yeah, I get that for sure, and I actually put a poll on my Instagram story trying to just gauge the sentiment of the people that follow me on how do they feel about this. Is this a good thing in their eyes? 16:24 Is this a bad thing? And overwhelmingly, people were saying that they like this. Mm-hmm. And I think it's very situational. 16:30 I think if you just say, "Oh, the world's richest man is now buying basically the virtual town square that we all use to communicate," that sounds awful, and I get that, and I agree with that. 16:40 But, and this is where there's gonna be some division in this, because it's Elon Musk, I think that makes it, that makes it better than [laughs] just the world's richest person. 16:49 Like, if this were to be anybody else besides Musk, I could see this being an absolute disaster. Um, that being said, I think there are still a lot of pros and cons to this. One of the major cons that I see 17:01 is honestly distracting Elon from Tesla and from SpaceX. I mean, he's already running two massive companies with massive lofty goals, and now he's gonna take over Twitter, and I mean, that's just, that's a lot. 17:13 [laughs] That's a lot even for Elon Musk. So that's one of my main concerns with it. Um, I do think it could possibly set a bad precedent. 17:20 That's something that, uh, Brandon, who I think is, is on this live right now, him and I were DM'ing back and forth about it. 17:26 It's just like where, where do we draw the line in terms of what amount of, uh, large amounts of wealth are actually able to do? Like, can we just allow- Yeah... 17:35 any mega wealthy person to make kinda any massive purchase as long as it is, you know, okay by the SEC as long as it's not breaking any laws? I think that's an interesting question. Again, I think it's very situational. 17:46 So I think it's kinda one of those things that you have to pick apart, uh, with the details that you have and not try to apply one broad, uh- Yeah... sort of solution to the whole thing. 17:55 But I, I do think it's important to understand, like, why Elon is doing this because I see a lot of false narratives kinda circulating around social media right now. 18:02 Um, I see the narrative, you know, it's the world's richest person taking basically a s- talking about free speech and wanting to take it private. 18:10 I get that side of it, but I d- I really do believe Elon's intentions are he wants to preserve free speech, and he knows the importance of free speech in a democracy. 18:18 And like Evan said, he's one of the greatest problem-solvers that our generation has seen. And, you know, if you don't agree with that, I, I don't know what to tell you at this point, honestly. 18:27 So that aspect of it, knowing that somebody like that is gonna have an influence on Twitter, that's what gets me excited. Um, but obviously I don't wanna just say it's all good, it's all roses. 18:36 There's a lot to be considered here. Um, so I don't know if you guys have any other, other thoughts to that, but, uh- Yeah... it's something that, that's gonna... 18:43 Keep the popcorn out, 'cause it's gonna continue to get more and more interesting. I mean, I wanna ask you guys a question. Do you guys think Elon Musk is political? 18:52 Like, in his decisions, in the way that he runs his companies, do you think it's from a place of- I don't think-... politics or a place of logic?... 19:00 it would be, um, reasonable to say that there's not some amount of politics that play into it. But pri- uh, primarily- Yeah... I think Elon is motivated by making the world a better place. 19:10 Um, I don't think politics play a massive role into it. I think he leans politically towards free speech, more freedoms, more individual freedoms type of thing. Um, Nate, what do you think? 19:22 No, I would agree with that, but I would also say that you can't predict someone's future actions based on their past actions. Sure. Abs- yeah, that's actually an, an excellent point as well. 19:31 Um, so yeah, like I said, keep the popcorn out. This is only gonna continue to develop- Yeah... and get wilder and wilder throughout the next couple weeks as this goes down. Um- Yeah... 19:40 another- He said he had a, a plan B, uh- Yeah... yesterday when he did it- That's-... a TED Talk, so there's another way to try to take it over if they don't accept the bid, I guess. I was just about to mention that. 19:49 If you wanna just hear it, I would recommend going and listening to that TED Talk, and hear it from the man himself. 19:54 Don't read an article that has a journalistic spin on it, trying to push a narrative about what's going on. Go listen to Elon talk about why he wants to do this and some of his plans for it. 20:02 Like Evan said, he wants to really increase free speech, increase transparency. He wants the algorithm to be transparent if it's taking down a tre- a tweet or altering it in any way. 20:11 All things that I think we can get behind, but go listen to it from the man himself. It's a good interview. Um, a lot of good stuff is covered in it, so I think that would be... 20:18 If you're interested in keeping up with this, learning more about it, I would recommend trying to supplement your media intake with something directly from the source, which is, which is Elon. Cool. Okay. 20:30 Well, let's transition over to what we've got coming up. Um, Nate, real quick before we transition into that, you are swagged out today. Yeah. Talk about that. 20:39 Not, not just wearing the logo 'cause I, I like the look of it, although I do. Uh, but we launched a new merch store, so these are two items that are available. 20:48 Uh, we also got these with the, the nice orange logo, and we got some DevelopLex merch as well. Middletechstore.com, super easy URL. Uh, go snag yourself some branded merch. 21:00 Yeah, and on that note, we just launched our new website, Middletech.com. Mm. We feel so legit. [laughs] We're, we're really proud of it. Finally got that domain. That's right. That's right. 21:09 Yeah, we were chasing after that for a while. Um, what kind of Week In Thoughts do we have coming out? Is it, is it the one I just recorded? It's yours, yeah. Why don't you talk about it? Okay. Yeah. 21:17 So this one, I was a little worried it was gonna be kinda out there, um, with, with the topic I, I covered. 21:23 So I've been reading a lot of blogs by a guy named Tim Urban, who I consider just a really great thinker and great writer, and I read this blog by Tim about Neuralink- Oh, good... and the significance of Neuralink. 21:34 And in this blog, Tim talks about this idea of the human colossus, and it's essentially describing, uh, the human species, humanity as a whole, as kind of one functioning organism, which is a really weird way to think of, of humanity. 21:48 Um, but it just, the interconnectedness of, of humanity, and when you look at it from a really broad scale and you look at all the different ways we're connected, um, Tim refers to that as the human colossus, and I take that... 21:58 Well, Tim took that a step further, and it's really been fascinating to me. And then he also talks about the computer colossus. So, you know, now we have this network of interconnected computers called the internet. 22:09 Uh, and then, you know, this whole blog about Neuralink dives into the thought of what happens when you connect the human colossus to the computer colossus in a seamless, um, in a seamless way to where there's no delay in communication. 22:22 That is, you know, what Neuralink is essentially aiming to do. So it's just a really interesting topic that I wanted to dive into on this Week In Thoughts. So if you get a chance this weekend, check it out. 22:30 Um, let me know what you think. It was a good one. Sweet. And then on Monday, we've got an episode coming out, um, with our Endeavor friend, uh, Rochelle Smalls. 22:42 So this is a conversation that we've been having a lot lately, just all around access to capital in this region specifically. Um, so they've just launched a new platform called Endeavor Edge. 22:51 We dive into that, all the implications of it, why this region needs that. Um, it was a great conversation. We're excited for that one to come out on Monday. Other than that, we've got a beautiful Friday ahead of us. 23:02 I hope everyone has an awesome day, and we'll see you next week. See you guys. See ya.