Transcript 0:00 All right. Good morning, and welcome to the first Friday update of Season 5 for the Middle Tech Podcast. Uh, we've got all sorts of new stuff going on, as I'm sure you guys have seen from our social channels. 0:11 Um, we wanna make sure that we still remember how to do these. This break has been nice, uh, but we're definitely excited to be back. We already got Brandon popping in here. We'll get Nate joining. 0:20 Um, one of the first things that we want to do, though, before jumping in here is we actually got some new sponsors for Season 5, uh, and we're very, very excited about those sponsors. 0:30 So what we wanna do is just take a second to recognize them because one of the reasons we're so proud about those sponsors is... What's up, Nate? Just telling them about our sponsors for Season 5. What up? Yeah. 0:40 Um, so what I was saying is, uh, one of the reasons we're so proud about the sponsors that we got is because they align so closely with our mission. 0:46 Um, so our sponsors, not only are they, uh, running awesome businesses in Kentucky, but they're also pursuing the same type of mission that Middle Tech is. 0:54 Um, so those two sponsors that are sponsoring the Friday update are gonna be KY Innovation, 1:00 um, so that is the Kentucky Chamber for Economic Development's, uh, innovation and entrepreneurship partner, so they're down in Frankfurt doing some awesome work. 1:08 Uh, and then we've also got Render Capital, uh, which is a VC firm, uh, based out of Louisville. Um, and they are... Uh, Evan's worked with them. 1:16 They do some awesome work in the community as well, so big thanks to those two sponsors for making Season 5 possible. We're really excited about it. Yeah. And let's see. Big thanks to them this year. 1:27 Let me get Evan invited here. I've, I've, I've forgotten how to invite people. [laughs] Like... I know, it's... I was thinking about that. I think it's been, like, four or five weeks since we've done one. 1:38 [laughs] I know. Here we go. Get- getting up at, uh, early this morning w- was kind of- I think I got it... but you guys are s- struggling even b- even more with the time. Look what, Render Capital. Yeah. 1:50 Right there with, uh- The sponsor integration in the- Yes. Yes. Integrated media. Yeah, Ev- Evan and I are both on, on West Coast time right now, so it's [laughs] it's, like, 5:00 in the morning for us. 2:04 Um, that's how dedicated we are to this. But cool. Well, let's, uh, let's go ahead and kick it off here. Um, I wanna talk about our, our... what we got going on this week in tech history. 2:13 So this week in tech history, yesterday, uh, the 13th of January, 1910, the first ever radio broadcast went out, uh, broadcasting an opera performance from New York's Metropolitan Opera House. 2:25 So crazy how far radio has come and, you know, how, how long is that? Uh, 120 years? Um, 110 years? So- And here we are- Thought that was a pretty interesting tech fact... live with microphones. Yeah. 2:40 [laughs] New age radio. Yeah. New age radio. All right. Well, cool. Well, we got some good stories to talk about. We got some stuff, uh, involving space. 2:48 We've got some stuff involving this new viral app, Wordle, that you'll s- you're seeing all over, uh, all over Twitter as people post the results. 2:56 Uh, and then we got our friend Evan down, uh, doing some, uh, some visiting in the San Francisco ecosystem. So let's dive into it. 3:03 Let's start talking about, uh, this new James Webb telescope that's got the science community really excited, the space community really excited. 3:11 Um, so Nate, do you wanna just give us the, the rundown on what's going on up there in space with this new telescope? Yeah, for sure. I, I think, I think you should give this, Logan. 3:20 I feel like this is your area that you follow the most. Okay. Thank you. Yeah, of course. I would love to. I'd love to. 3:26 Well, so what's going on here is we've got a new space telescope that's replacing the Hubble Space Telescope that we're all familiar with. 3:33 Uh, and this is probably, you know, the most impressive telescope that, that we've ever managed to actually get up into space, and it was a pretty big risk getting it up there. Had a lot of moving parts. 3:43 It cost $10 billion to build. Um, we're placing it about a, a million miles away from Earth to start, uh, taking observations. 3:51 Uh, so there's just, like, so much that could go wrong with this launch, with, uh, expanding its, uh, its mirrors. 3:57 So it had, like, all these different pulley systems and things that needed to be expanded once it actually got up into space, and everything went e- exactly according to plan. 4:05 Um, so big congratulations to the team who actually worked on building this new telescope. 4:10 Uh, and now it's actually gonna be out trying to take observations, and this sounds crazy, uh, of the origination of the universe 13.5, or 13.8 billion years ago. 4:21 So it's gonna be cooling itself down, uh, even colder than 4:26 the Hubble Space Telescope to ensure that it's not emitting any infrared light so that it can absorb any infrared light that came from the Big Bang that many years ago. So it's just... 4:35 it's crazy to think about that, uh, this type of technological innovation is going on, especially [laughs] when just 110 years ago, the first ever radio broadcast went out. Yeah. 4:44 So it's a, it's pretty stark contrast that you got there. I'm pretty excited, 'cause if there's aliens, we're gonna find them. [laughs] Yeah. 4:52 If there's anything else going on, on out there we wanna know about, we're gonna know, and we're probably gonna find some things that we don't want the answer to either. Uh, we'll see. Yeah. 5:02 The, the concept of looking back into the past, obviously just by looking so far in the distance and the, the idea of, you know, that it takes time for light to travel is just so interesting to me, and I, I think, like, this is kind of theoretical, but, like, if we can see so far into the past and then we have enough time to process this information, like, are we gonna be able to, like, understand, 5:24 you know, what's happening around us before it catches up to us? And that's just a really- Mm... cool concept to me. Yeah. I mean, when you think about... 5:33 If you, like, go and Google some of the images that the Hubble Space Tele- Telescope got for us, and then you consider that this telescope is 100 times more powerful than that, I mean, there's no way that we don't just find some absolutely wild stuff, uh, with this new telescope, and 5:48 I mean, there... I could just go on and on about how incredible of a, of a technological feat this is. 5:53 The fact that it's also gonna be a million miles away from Earth, I think that's just something that's really hard for, for people who [laughs] don't deal in large distances like that to really wrap their head around. 6:03 I mean, putting a, something manmade Uh, you know, a million miles from where everything you've ever known and everyone you've ever known has originated from. It's just really cool to me. 6:14 Um, so we'll definitely be- Do you know where that is in the solar system, like a million miles? I don't. I know it's some sort of intersection between the gravity of the sun and the gravity of the Earth. 6:23 It's, like, sitting... It'll be orbiting in that kind of- Okay... uh, I guess Goldilocks spot, but I don't know much else, uh, about it other than that. So we'll continue to kind of update on that. 6:33 As soon as they start, uh, putting out any images from it, we'll definitely be sharing those on our social. 6:37 I'm not really sure what the timeline is for starting to release some of those images, but we'll definitely keep you updated. Yeah. So let's move on to this next one, uh, Wordle. Are either of you guys playing this? 6:47 I've seen some of my coworkers playing it. I've seen lots of, lots of it on Twitter, but I haven't played it yet. So somebody that's played it- Wow... give a, give a rundown on what's going on here. 6:55 I, I get too frustrated with it each morning when I can't figure out the word. Um, but it's... I'm gonna try to... Th- it's Wardle versus Wordle is gonna be tough here. It's gonna be a little bit of a tongue twister. 7:07 [laughs] Um, but there's this developer, um, I believe he's based in, in England, um, Josh Wardle. 7:14 Um, and his wife, I guess, loves word games, and so he just developed a game, Wordle, play on words there, um, for his wife to be able to play every day, and it's pretty easy. 7:25 You, like, guess a word, and then it tells you if you have the right letter, and then you keep that letter and guess the other letters. 7:31 Um, but it's actually based on a game show from the '70s that had the same kind of game mechanics. 7:38 Um, but it hadn't been used since then, so he just put it on the internet as, like, an open source tool, um, and anybody could go to this website and play the Wordle game by Josh Wardle. It got popular. 7:50 People started posting it on Twitter. Because it's so easily accessible on the internet, it kind of started to gain a following, and then Twitter helped with that. 7:58 And then as it started to get popular, all of these other developers were just copying the game mechanics and putting it on the App Store or the Google Play Store. Hmm. 8:07 And then they were charging in-app purchases or just, uh, an upfront purchase and starting to make money off of this game that Josh Wardle popularized. So the interesting concept here is, like, what is ownership? 8:21 Is it the fact that he built it and put it on the internet? He didn't trademark the name, and he didn't come up with the original game, uh, mechanics. Or does the person who submitted it to Apple own it? 8:32 Um, it's just kind of an interesting concept of, like, as, uh, you know, as community surrounds a concept and a, and a name and a game, like, who owns the underlying IP of that game? Yeah, in my opinion, um, 8:47 I think it's on, um, the original developer. I think it's on him. It's his fault that he allowed this to happen. 8:54 You know, if he really cared enough, if he had the vision that this was gonna be, you know, a profitable game, then he should have trademarked. 9:02 And, you know, he should have built the mobile app if that's what he wanted, but that's not necessarily what he wanted. You know, he was just building this on the side for, you know, his partner. 9:11 Um, and the fact that it blew up was kind of, you know, unforeseen. Uh, but at the end of the day, it's his fault that he didn't get it trademarked, and then two, he didn't build a mobile app. 9:20 Um, while I think it makes you a bad human being to go copy this identically and then make money off it, like, uh, like the way that some of these other developers did, I think that makes you, you know, a bad human. 9:32 You should at least check or reach out. But, uh, it's also on the original developer that he didn't take the right steps to make sure that he got a piece of the pie when it came to making money with it. Yeah. 9:44 I mean, what even could Apple do about this? Like, if there's no trademark, there's no legal protection on it, what kind of measures could they even take? I don't think there are any that can really be done. 9:53 I mean, that's what trademark law is established for, is to, you know, protect developers from, and people who create things, from things exactly like this. So I don't think Apple- Yeah... 10:03 I don't think they can do anything. I don't think there's any recourse for it. 10:07 As far as- So they actually did take down some of the apps, um, and I think some of those app developers are appealing it based on the fact that there- Hmm... wasn't a trademark filed. I could see that. Yeah. 10:18 And one of the things that Google Play Store apparently does is if you, if your game is not a native app, you can still create a space for it in their app store and basically click through to the web, uh, version of it. 10:31 Apple doesn't do that. So really, like the fact that it exists on web doesn't mean it exists within Apple's ecosystem in their native app store. So, like, they don't even address it. 10:40 Uh, but Google kind of does a little bit better job of that. Hmm. That's an interesting dynamic. 10:45 I mean, you always hear about Apple's App Store being a little bit controversial just because of the take rate that they have on that. I believe it's 30%, right? Yeah. So I mean- Yeah. It depends... 10:54 of course, of course they don't... Yeah. Of course they don't wanna support something that's on the web that they're probably not getting any, any sort of- Yeah... kind of revenue. 11:01 Y- but I guess this is a free game, so it just doesn't seem like there's much incentive for Apple to be, you know, helping out in this, in this scenario. 11:09 Yeah, I mean, the original developer copied the game anyway, so, like, it's not even an original game idea. Mm-hmm. 11:13 So it's like, it's, uh, just people copying people, and at some point somebody's gotta say, "Okay, I'm gonna trademark this. I'm gonna put the right things in place for myself to make money." And so far- Yeah... 11:22 you know, the original developer that everybody's upset about didn't get any money. That's why, you know, 'cause he didn't take the right steps. You know, and he didn't even want to. 11:30 It's not like that was his objective anyway, so I think this is- Yeah... the media just kind of drumming up controversy, but it's an interesting topic because, um, I think it's worth talking about. Yeah. Yeah. All right. 11:41 Well, let- I, I think- Go ahead... 11:42 if you zoom out, like, it's just interesting that stuff like this is happening at the cross-section of when we've talked about Web3 and, like, decentralized ownership and things like that. Hmm. 11:51 And it's almost like, you know, an open source concept and a bunch of people wanting to contribute something is currently being shoehorned into this idea of, like, one person owns it on the Apple App Store, and, you know, it'll just be interesting to see how that plays out over the next couple of years as the idea of, like, more decentralized ownership becomes more popular. 12:11 For sure. All right. Um, well, let's talk about Evan's San Francisco trip here. 12:15 So Evan, talk about, you know, why you're down there in the first place, and, uh, let's dive into some of what you're learning, uh, while you're down there as compared to, to our ecosystem. Yeah. 12:25 So I'm down here visiting a buddy named Nico, who's on our team, so Nico Ferreira. Um, 12:31 and really just kind of, uh, networking here in San Francisco, uh, meeting some, some investors, people that can connect me to investors. Um, so it's kind of a... 12:41 And I've got family out here, so it's kind of a work, play, and family trip. Um, but so far I've been staying in this house where there's about 12 other entrepreneurs, uh, Nico being one of them. 12:54 So there's about, uh, two or three floors of entrepreneurs, and then the basement is a co-working area, which is where I'm at now. And so it's just this kind of like re- it's like almost, um, 13:03 like a, a, a startup front house. So [chuckles] it's, it's pretty interesting- [chuckles]... how this place is, like, constructed. Um- [laughs] I mean, it's cool. It's cool. 13:12 It's, uh, it's, it's so dense here with, uh, with talented people and people that are, you know, raising money, meeting investors or are investors. 13:21 And so the ability to grow your business out here is kind of accelerated. Um, and so a few things that I've noticed is, uh, the network effect, like I just mentioned, is so dense. 13:31 Uh, it's really easy to work your way around, um, if you have something that's interesting, uh, to not only other entrepreneurs, but investors and employees. So, um, just the density of talent. 13:44 And what that leads to is when you're sitting around so many people that are also, you know, doing the same thing as you, building companies, the feedback loop of yourself and your knowledge and your ability to adapt, uh, you know, is, is, is shorter. 13:58 Uh, 'cause everybody in this house is, you know, very early in their venture. They've raised, they've raised venture capital. 14:04 Um, and so you can bounce a lot of ideas, you know, off each other and, and they know exactly what you're talking about, or they're a step ahead of you. Um, so that's just really interesting to me. 14:13 Uh, I've noticed that the access to capital on the coast... I think we're gonna do a whole podcast episode on this, but it's, um, 14:21 I'm starting to realize it's actually kind of scary how far behind Kentucky is and kind of Middle America when it comes to these things, uh, because it's so apparent when you get out here, uh, how much it benefits entrepreneurs. 14:32 And, uh, the access to capital here is very obvious. Uh, it's, everybody talks about it. Everybody's, you know, talking about, uh, where they raised money from, "Let me intro you to this investor or this investor." 14:43 And, uh, the speed at which you get intros, the, the intro velocity is, uh, uncomparable. 14:50 You know, you talk to one person out here, and they give you three intros, and then that next person gives you three more, and then two weeks later you're seven people removed from the first person. 14:59 If, if you're in America, you've kinda gotta, you know, claw and pull for every intro. Or if you're in Middle America, you kinda gotta claw and pull for every intro. 15:07 Like, in Kentucky, it was hard getting intros and raising money, but out here it's just, you know, that's people's nature is, "How many people can I introduce you to?" You know, "Oh, I know this investor. 15:16 I live with this investor." It's just a different world. Um, and you asked me a question, Nate, um, yesterday that I thought was super interesting. 15:25 You asked me, uh, "Do you think you would very consciously be making a decision, uh, in, against your business' best interest if you didn't spend more time in San Francisco?" Uh, and I think the answer is yes. 15:38 I think if you have a company that has a lot of potential and you need capital, or you need talent, or you just need somebody to bounce ideas off of and you're not spending time in San Francisco, um, I think you're putting yourself at a disadvantage. 15:51 I'm starting to realize that now. Uh, can you build a company anywhere in the world? Yes, but, uh, this is still the mecca. Yeah. 16:00 It's an interesting dynamic that's gonna need a lot more discussion in comparison to what the Kentucky ecosystem is doing or what kinda the Middle America ecosystem is doing because these things need to be called out pretty clearly. 16:11 Um, I think it's, it's special that you're gonna have that firsthand experience of being down there and talking to people trying to raise capital. 16:18 Um, but just hearing you talk about it, it, it sounds like there's really no comparison. 16:23 And because there's no comparison, that's why Middle Tech exists, whether it's to encourage these type of intros or whether we're the ones that are trying to get to know everyone and give the intros or just totally revamp the mindset around capital here. 16:39 It's just different. It's just different. 16:40 And, you know, obviously Silicon Valley and San Francisco's had a lot more time to, uh, develop that in that ecosystem, and then it becomes kind of like a, a compounding runaway effect. So it's no surprise. 16:51 It's not something that, like, the Kentucky ecosystem or Middle America needs to feel ashamed about. 16:56 It's just something that we need to look at and take some of the attributes that are allowing it to function like that and try and put them into our ecosystem. 17:04 So I'm really glad that you're down there getting that sort of experience. Uh, just don't leave Kentucky for San Francisco, Evan. [laughs] We need you. [laughs] Yeah. I, I don't- Get another house in Asa. Yeah. Yeah. 17:14 I don't, I don't think, um, I don't think people in Kentucky should feel bad about it. Um, I just think the people in Kentucky need to realize it and do something about it. Um- Yeah... 17:23 because, you know, it's not, it's just a, it's a, it's a side effect of, uh, years and years of compounding. And, you know, San Francisco was where, you know, originally the great technology companies were born. 17:38 And when those companies exit, and there's liquidation in the market, and people are paid out via an IPO or an acquisition, they're putting that money back into the ecosystem. 17:47 And Kentucky hasn't had many exits like that. There's not as many billion-dollar exits, whereas here every couple weeks there's a billion-dollar exit, um, in, in San Francisco, maybe every week. 17:58 So it's like the velocity of capital being turned over and people leaving a startup and starting their own, you know, in San Francisco is probably over 100 years ahead of Kentucky 'cause it compounds. Yeah. 18:10 And so there's, there's, it's impossible for Kentucky to ever catch up, and we're so far behind, but we could still try to accelerate where we're at. Yeah. Yep. 18:19 What surprised me the most, um, the last few weeks talking to you about this is what seems like, you know, such a large amount of, uh, young investors, and young scouts, and young really successful founders in the SF ecosystem. 18:35 Um, where the way I thought about it beforehand was like these investors were older people who were talking to some young founders, some old founders, and it, the, you know. 18:44 But it seems like the, the money and the talent is so much more intertwined than even I was imagining. 18:51 Um, and once you get to that kind of level playing field is what sounds like is really making a difference over there. Yeah. 18:57 So if you, what I've noticed is if you're an entrepreneur and you're pretty well plugged in, uh, here in San Francisco, uh, these VCs will give you scout money, which means you go out and you look for startups. 19:09 Because you're talking with other entrepreneurs, because you're living around them, these VCs are giving entrepreneurs money to give to other entrepreneurs. 19:16 Um, and so you've got this, this cycle of talented entrepreneurs seeking out other talented entrepreneurs to try to go deploy their capital. 19:25 And by the way, when you deploy capital to another entrepreneur, you get some bit of that upside. Um, and so it's just, you know, it's interesting. 19:32 They've built, um, a system out here that encourages, you know, ecosystem building just by rewarding people for the intros and for, uh, cutting checks. It's, it's just fa- it's fascinating. Yeah. Yeah. 19:46 And like we, like we said, uh, we are gonna have a full episode diving into all this. 19:50 We're gonna have both Evan, uh, who's now had the perspective of raising in both our ecosystem as well as San Francisco, and then Nico, uh, who, same deal, who started in the Lowell ecosystem. 20:00 So be on the lookout for that. I think to tease, to tease that conversation, um, it took me four months to raise $300,000 in Kentucky/Middle America. It took me about three weeks to raise 300,000 on the coast. 20:14 Uh, so that's like that speed thing. It's the velocity. So I raised 600,000- Yeah... and, you know, half of it took four months, the other half of it took three weeks. Yeah. 20:24 And I mean, that's kind of what Nate said, like there's, you know, if you care about your business and you want it to succeed, you're gonna have to be spending some time in San Francisco. 20:32 But that's, that's why I think it's a really interesting dynamic that you're also involved with Middle Tech because you can now take what you're learning and talk about it very openly on this platform that you have with this audience that you have here in Middle America. 20:45 So I'm really excited to continue that conversation. 20:47 I think that's gonna be one of our more important themes of season five is being able to be in these other ecosystems, talk with these other ecosystem builders, and bring that back and try and apply that to what's going on here. 20:57 So exciting stuff. Um, I'm glad you're representing Kentucky and Middle America and Middle Tech down in San Francisco. 21:04 Uh, so hopefully we'll, we'll all get to d- go down there and visit and get some of our own learnings as well.