Transcript 0:01 What's going on everybody? You got Evan Knowles here. This week we've got Patrick Ulrich and Dan Carman on the episode to talk about their Lexington Bitcoin Consulting company. 0:12 So Bitcoin has been a term and a technology that's been thrown around for several years now, uh, and it continues to get more and more popular, uh, in the media and in the technology space. 0:26 Uh, and there's a lot to understand, so it's a pretty complex, uh, concept, but it's really important to understand because a lot of people, including myself, believe it's gonna be an important part of the future. 0:37 Uh, cryptocurrency of some kind will be an important part of the future, and if it's not cryptocurrency, then it's digital currencies. 0:43 So I think understanding what's going on here is really important, and, and Dan and, and Patrick are working hard to inform people here, uh, in the Commonwealth, uh, about it. 0:53 So if you wanna learn more, this is gonna be an awesome episode. I really encourage you to listen, uh, 'cause again, I think it's something that's important to understand. Uh, so let's go ahead and get into it. 1:03 [upbeat music] What's going on everybody? 1:28 You got Evan here. We're sitting here with Patrick Ulrich and Dan Carman from Lexington Bitcoin Consulting. Um, so they are working hard here in the Commonwealth, and specifically Lexington, to advocate for Bitcoin. 1:42 So we'll get into, I'm sure many of you have heard what Bitcoin is so many times. I'm sure some of you might know what it, what's going on, I'm sure some of you might not. 1:51 Uh, but there are a lot of amazing things going on in the cryptocurrency space, the blockchain space. 1:56 We'll touch on, you know, all of these different aspects of, on this whole space that has really been talked about over the last several years, but we've been yet to really see, um, it come to fruition in very apparent ways. 2:10 Um, but I believe it's gonna happen, so we're gonna talk about that. Um, so Dan, Patrick, thanks for joining us, man. Thanks for having us. Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. Thanks for, thanks for having us on. For sure. 2:20 Let's just jump, you know, into your all's background. Talk about where you're from, and then my follow-up question to that will be how you got into the crypto space. Go ahead, Patrick. Awesome. 2:30 So I'm actually from Eastern Kentucky, um, an area called Jackson County, so it's a little small, middle-of-nowhere place. But came up to, uh, Lexington for college, just kinda stuck around ever since. 2:41 Um, my background with Bitcoin actually started in around two thousand twelve, two thousand thirteen, that timeframe, um, just got really enamored with the concept that there was a money that was outside of the control of anyone. 2:54 It was just community-fed value that there was just one source of it that way, um, which led to me buying my first Bitcoin ATM. 3:04 So I actually had Bitcoin ATMs here in Lexington, um, and Louisville, that you could just walk up to, put in $5, and get $5 worth of Bitcoin back out. And that led into meeting Dan, and now we're here 3:19 working to advocate together. Yeah. Dan, what about you? Where are you from? I grew up in Lexington, uh, not too far from here where we sit. Um, uh, you know, at, at the age of 18, uh, decided to go away 3:36 and do various things for, I don't know, several years. Uh, came back to Lexington, uh, in my 30s. And, um, uh, you know, um, concerning Bitcoin, when, uh... 3:53 So in my, uh, in another part of my life, I'm a, I'm a lawyer. Round about two thousand twelve, um, uh, I had this guy come in and talk to me about where he got some kind of designer dope. I started asking him questions. 4:11 Of course, this is eight years ago. Designer dope. Yeah, designer dope, you know, like some kind of drugs- Okay [laughs]... that were evading the, uh, purview of the DEA and the, and the- Yeah... 4:21 and the statutes and this kind of thing. And, um, and, and so I started asking him questions 'cause, 'cause I'm an attorney, right? Gotta ask questions. And, uh, and, and he started telling me how he got this dope, 4:35 and I said, "Well, that's really interesting." You know? And of course, I knew, you know, from my, my case, my cases and my work, I knew, you know, the... I knew how, I knew these guys. 4:45 I knew the DA agents, you know, I knew how the feds worked, and the state authorities. I was thinking to myself, "They have no idea what's going on right now." 4:52 At least not, you know, at least not out here locally at that time, at least it didn't seem. And started talking to him. I said, "Hey, so how do you buy this stuff?" You know? 5:02 He's like, "Well, you gotta buy it with Bitcoin." I was like, "What?" Yeah. [laughs] "What's a Bitcoin?" And I was like, "Where do you..." He's like, "Well, you know, you just buy it online." 5:09 I was like, "Where do you, where do you get it? I mean, what, how do you get it?" You know? Of course, looking back on it, we know that he was talking about, uh, get- getting something on Silk Road. 5:17 That's just back, back in the old days. This is two thousand twelve, thirteen, whatever. Um, and he's like, "Well, I just go to, go to, I go to Rite Aid, and I buy, I, I buy Bitcoin." 5:27 Well, that's not exactly how it works, right? You don't go to Rite Aid to buy Bitcoin. What apparently he was doing, looking back on it, he was going to Rite Aid, Western Union, wiring money to, like- Char-... 5:40 Charlie Shrem's, like- BitInstant... Mount BitInstant or, like, Mt. Gox replacement in Asia or something. Anyways, he, it's like, you know, the janky way you used to be able to, you know, try to get Bitcoin back then. 5:53 But anyways, that, that's, that's a little bit of an aside, but that's, that's how, uh, I first learned of Bitcoin, and I thought it was really interesting. 6:02 Not because, uh, it was used for, uh, you know, facilitating some kind of purchase of, of some kind of unlawful substance, but because, um, uh, it was, it was extrajudicial and powerful in that sense. 6:17 And it, it kind of got me interested. So, you know, I did a little, you know, a little, uh, a little careful Googling, you know, about this kind of thing. 6:26 Got interested, um, ended up buying some Bitcoin in, I don't know, 2012 or '13 or something. 6:32 Uh, kind of got a peek down the proverbial rabbit hole, as we all talk about, and, um, didn't, you know, didn't quite dive all the way down it, but maybe, maybe put my, put my toe, put my foot in it. 6:47 Bought some Bitcoin, held onto it. This was on, I don't know, Bitport- BitPay or Coinbase. This was back then, you know. And, uh, a- a- and it, it seems... 6:57 Didn't quite understand it as, as well as I, I should have or as well as a lot. You know, as we know, the n- with Bitcoin, the narrative changes over time. Yeah. You know? 7:07 You know, I remember kind of talking or I was trying to, like, shill Bitcoin to my friends back in, like, 2013. I remember sitting at a restaurant talking to them like, you know... 7:16 And back then, '14, '14, '15, whenever, it was, it was like, "Payments, man. I mean, this is, like, payments. It's a slick way to do payments." Yeah. 7:24 You can send money to South Korea or North Korea for, you know, pennies, you know. And it was like that was the greatest thing. But, and I didn't fully understand what I was talking about apparently. 7:35 And, um, but kind of kept, kept a little bit of an eye on it. And then, and then I'd say right around 2016 or so, got, got back interested in it in, in earnest, shall we say. 7:48 And then '16, '17, um, uh, fortunately, I guess, a little bit before the big crazy- Mm-hmm... hype of, uh, late 2017, which was nuts, um, 7:59 got, got, got pretty, pretty fully intellectually, emotionally, uh, uh, professionally invested in it. And then, um, you know, dealt with Patrick right around '17, 2016, '17. Right before the build-up probably. 8:13 Yeah, that's right. And we, uh, then, you know, early '18, I think we, we cemented our, uh... You know, we did, we did the, the thing where you, you cut your finger and you shake- [laughs] 8:24 And, uh, and you know, you lick your finger or you cut your finger and you do a blood, blood handshake kind of thing. And we said we're, we're partners for life or something like that. So, you know, 8:34 and, um, since then it's been great, and we're, we're just doing our thing concerning, uh, concerning, uh, Bitcoin and Bitcoin consulting. Yeah. 8:42 So let's, um, kind of level set here and make sure everybody has a full understanding before we go any further into what Bitcoin is. 8:49 Just give, uh, the most simple explanation that you can of Bitcoin to somebody that, uh, has no idea what it is. Bitcoin can be described many ways. Um, Bitcoin is code. It's free speech. 9:06 Uh, Bitcoin is a growth currency. And, and, and this is, [laughs] this is not particularly responsive, but this is probably the truth. Yeah. Um, Bitcoin is, uh, is, is, is a growth currency. 9:19 Uh, Bitcoin can be considered an investment. One very significant thesis of Bitcoin is that it is digital gold. Right. And so, um, it's sound money. Um, it's, it's, it's a way 9:35 that, um, humans now can have, uh, sound money, um, in, in a digital world, you know? It- There's only so much of it. That's why it's- 21 million. Yeah. 21 million. That's why it's considered like gold, right? 9:50 Well, yes, in the sense that, um... But, but, but, you know, soon enough it will be, uh, more scarce than gold, in fact. Yeah. 9:59 Um, and so, um, because it is, it is harder to produce it, than anything, any other commodity, any other monetary good, uh, it's, it's considered, uh, at least we consider it the hardest money that humanity's ever, ever had. 10:14 So that's, uh, that, that's why it's valuable. Yeah. And it's built on a technology called blockchain. You could say that. Yeah. You could say that. 10:25 You know, a blockchain, you know, uh, uh, Satoshi Nakamoto, this synonymous, uh, coder, uh, uh, who, um, you know, uh, 10:41 you know, let Bitcoin out into the wild, um, blessed be his name, um, he, he... I don't know that he ever referred to it as a blockchain. He, he did refer to it as a time chain- Time chain. Yeah... at some point. 10:56 Block- the, the word blockchain has taken on this, you know- It's like, uh, the dotcom bubble. It's- Everybody, everybody's trying to, you know, talk about it and- Yeah. Everybody's trying to get a... 11:08 Yeah, everybody's trying to get, get some money for their, their department and a raise and, uh, and you know, try to, try to keep up with the, uh, their competitor company and stuff with their blockchain initiative. 11:19 But of course, I don't know if Patrick would agree with me, but we submit to you that, um, you know, blockchain in, in as such is, is, is... 11:29 There, there's really not m- much of an important blockchain or public blockchain except for Bitcoin, 'cause it really, really doesn't have much use except for money. Mm. So. Yeah. 11:40 But that's, that might be our position, and that's, that's a pretty typical Bitcoin maximalist position. Yeah. Um, so how is Lexington Bitcoin, how is your consulting dealing with this in, in the city? 11:51 What is y'all's role for the city of Lexington related to Bitcoin? Well, um, 12:00 there's a book, uh, that was written and I think was published in about 1996 maybe, I don't know, some- somewhere along there, called The Sovereign Individual. 12:09 And if you, if you haven't, if you haven't taken a look at it, you should. Some very prescient, um, observations and predictions. And [clears throat] but i- if, in The Sovereign Individual, um, 12:24 among other observations, you know, these, these very, uh, uh, insightful, uh, authors of this book, 12:33 uh, predicted that, um, eventually due to, um, you know, the advent of internet technology and our move into the digital age, right? 12:44 We may have started out as hunter-gatherers, then we became an agricultural society, then an industrial society, and now we have this turning. We're now a digital society, right? [clears throat] And but because of this, 12:56 and, and in a sense, we, uh, um, we're becoming, uh, a little bit, a little bit less nation-state oriented. 13:04 And I think they'll probably ultimately, maybe not in our immediate lifetimes, maybe my children or grandchildren's lifetimes, maybe a little bit more, uh, local oriented. 13:15 And so in that sense, um, we, uh, are at least, you know, I think Patrick and I are committed to making sure to the greatest extent we possibly can that our community, Lexington, Fayette County, Central Kentucky, right, 13:32 is, um, is a part of, of what is happening, is a part of this, this, uh, opportunity, this development and what, um, a guy named Trace Mayer calls a, a once in a species event. 13:48 And so, um, that's why it's important for us, I think, in Lexington to, um, be able to, uh, facilitate this kind of stuff here and make sure that, um, that Bitcoin is, uh, 14:02 you know, is understood to the greatest extent possible, and frankly, is owned by people around here in our community. 14:10 Because as a, as a guy named Max Keiser has said, you know, he, he who, uh, owns the Bitcoin makes the rules. What's been, what's been your experience? 14:18 'Cause I know this area is typically thought of as not as technologically advanced as maybe the West Coast or even the East Coast. 14:26 [clears throat] What's been your guys' experience going around into the community and trying to educate people about this new form of technology and payments? 14:34 Have people adopted it quicker than you thought or not as quickly as you thought? I'll personally say that I would s- lean more to not as quick as I thought. 14:44 Um, I've kind of leaned into the technologist view of- Mm-hmm... always thinking what's gonna be the thing 10 years down the road, and kind of me jumping into it personally that way. 14:53 So whenever I go to speak with people, I expect others to just share that same mindset, and often I don't find it. Right. Um, but that being said, people are still seem receptive. 15:01 They understand the core values of, um, of scarcity. Mm-hmm. 15:06 And that's what Bitcoin provides, is a way that they can hold their value without fear that the government's gonna go and print more money or do anything like that that's gonna deflate their value. 15:16 So those, those same principles still resonate. Even if the idea of Bitcoin itself may not be for what drives everybody in, but the principles of understanding, um, sound value resonates in the area. 15:30 So it's, it just kinda depends on how people look at it, whether it be the technology or understanding what just true sound money is. Mm-hmm. Yeah. And yeah, I think that's right. 15:40 I'd also say that, um, Lexington and, and sort of, you know, its environ... You know, Central Kentucky is, you know, it's, it's a little bit old-fashioned if you're comparing it to the coast- For sure. Yeah... 15:52 you know, the coasts and things like that. But, um, I think that the, the principles that, uh, undergird, um, the need for sound money, 16:06 uh, as opposed to easy, fast money and, and fiat type mal-investment and things like that- Mm-hmm... those principles are pretty firmly aligned with, um, the principles and values of people here in this community. And, 16:20 um, you know, Lexington, you know, and if you travel the world, you, you, you eventually figure this out, and I, I would, I, I'll, I'd take anybody on in this argument. Lexington is a highly civilized place, you know? 16:36 And, um, you know, 16:40 that kind of culture is very much in line with the culture of low time preference, sound money, um, and, uh, building for, uh, not just, you know, in, in, in expending energy, time, money, effort, not just for what feels good today- Mm-hmm 16:58 ... but what is good for your children and your children and your children's children and their children. Yeah. On down seven generations. Yeah. Yeah. That, that, that culture is definitely here. It's, you know... 17:09 Would you say conservative is another way to say that? When you say civilized. [clears throat] Um, I'd say civilized. Civilized. Okay. Yeah. It, it, it's a, you know, um, this isn't... 17:24 Lexington's not a fast money, easy money place necessarily. Yeah. I mean, look, we got fast horses. [laughs] Beautiful women or- Yeah. [laughs]... something like that, whatever, you know. But, but it, it's, 17:33 it, it's, it's a place where people, uh, you know, understand the value of, uh, of what's important- Yeah... I think, and, and we're, you know, we're committed to it. 17:41 I want my community to, to, to grow and thrive and, uh, you know, and be a part of what, what I think is a, is a very, very big development in, um, in, in history, and, and what may be, 17:54 uh, the greatest wealth transfer in, in the history of the world. Yeah. Yeah. I definitely can see that, that potential in, in Bitcoin. 18:03 Um, you know, one of the things about Bitcoin that I've, that I've studied is that, you know, the larger the network, the more value, valuable it becomes because there's, you know, scarcity. 18:12 The more people that are using this, um, the more people that, you know, basically can exchange this, the value of it goes up. Um, so I definitely get, get the potential of where Bitcoin could head. 18:23 Um, you know, beyond educating, you know, the city of Lexington and, and the people here, w- do you guys provide other services? Sure. Yeah, talk about some of those other services beyond, you know, just education. 18:35 Well, um, you know, what we do, we assist, um, in a variety of ways, uh, people that contact us and, and would, would appreciate our assistance. 18:47 Not only d- you know, not only education and, and doing things locally but, um, you know, we, you know, we receive calls from people elsewhere in the United States and elsewhere in the world who just need some, some technical, uh, and, and business-oriented assistance 19:06 in, uh, just Bitcoin matters, whether that be sto- uh, purchases, you know, uh, on- private onboarding, um, uh, you know, purchasing Bitcoin, uh, OTC desk, uh, connections. 19:21 OTC desk for your listeners is like over-the-counter type desk, like basically private Bitcoin brokerages as opposed to just, you know, g- going online, you know, on an app and buying just a little bit of Bitcoin. Um, 19:35 you know, um, so we assist a variety of different kinds of people and, um, it's, uh, it's, you know... Our focus is on Lexington, Central Kentucky, but, you know, it's, um, it's something that we are, uh, 19:49 we're privileged to have the opportunity to help people elsewhere as well. Yeah. And, um, that's okay. Yeah, and we're, we're happy to do that. It's, it's, it's fun for us, so. Yeah. 19:57 Um, so we've kind of talked about some of the pros of Bitcoin. Um, you know, it holds value, it's supposed to over time 'cause it's, you know, a limited amount. Um, it's, can go across borders, uh, easily exchanged. Um, 20:12 fast, fast exchange. Um, talk about some of the, the negatives that people might associate, you know, with Bitcoin. And a- another pro is, you know, it's anonymous. I think that's definitely a pro. 20:23 Some people look at that as, as a, as a positive, so I look at that as a positive. 20:26 Some people, they associate the negatives that come along with, with Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies with the fact that it's anonymous 'cause it leads to, you know, criminal activity. 20:34 Yeah, so- So talk about some of the negatives that people associate. Yeah, so let me hit on that real quick- Yeah... and then I may pass them on to Patrick, but let me hit on that. 20:40 It's actually the least anonymous thing you can imagine, and if I may- Yeah, go ahead... explain, right? Um, yeah. So, 20:46 and I, I know this e- from, from other, from your parts of my professional life, but, you know, understand, you know, 20:53 this ledger, the Bitcoin ledger or the blockchain or the time chain or whatever you call it, that is a public ledger. Mm-hmm. Right? 20:59 It's supposed to be, right, and it's a public ledger that's shared with everybody who's running the code on a node throughout the world, right? Thousands and thousands of people have this ledger. And 21:09 if a, if and a transaction is, is done on the, on chain, right, on the, on the Bitcoin, uh, blockchain as it were, that, that transaction is not anonymous and then, uh, through some, 21:25 I don't wanna say trivial because it does take a little bit of expertise to do it, but, you know, through some, uh, chain analysis it can, it can fairly easily be determined, you know, 21:37 plus maybe a little bit of just basic old-fashioned forensic work, it can be determined, you know, uh, what happened, who did it, um, you know, how much was purchased, how much was transacted, where the UTXOs went, and so forth and so on. 21:51 And so it's actually alm- it's, it's actually the opposite of anonymous. Mm, okay. It's, it's actually quite a public thing. Um, now I will say that there are, and this, I'm, I'm devi- I'm kind of 22:04 moving a little bit away from your question, but- No worries... there is a concern, if you think about, 22:11 and, and I'm not the first person to kinda provide this paradigm, but there are kinda two fronts on the, in the war, right? There's the, there's the s- if you think... 22:20 And the, the rough analogy would be, like, you know, in the Second World War you had like the European front and like the Pacific, right? Okay. If, if you think about it this way, 22:31 y- you know, on the one hand we have the front of, of, uh, of sound monetary policy, right? Uh, we're doing pretty well on that front. In other words, we got, we got the 21 million. 22:41 The social consensus is, is coalesce there. You know, uh, the, the, the forks of Bitcoin have become, I don't know, uh, basically, you know, they're just not, not particularly relevant anymore. 22:57 I remember when that happened, yeah. Yeah, I mean, BCash, Be everything, Be Pizza, whatever. Yeah. [laughs] They've become kind of silly and just kind of not, not particularly relevant. And so 23:07 we, we, you know, the s- the showing point, the social consensus around, is around this 21 million, and I don't wanna say we've achieved it because it's a daily thing, right? I mean, it's just an ongoing thing. 23:17 But, but the, there's this, the, the front of m- of sound monetary policy is in fairly good shape, and we're, we're, we're thankful for that, and I think most Bitcoiners and... 23:30 would, would say that that's the most important thing. The other front is the privacy and fungibility front, right? And, you know, we've got, um, because Bitcoin isn't, is not anonymous, 23:46 and because it is a public ledger, there are concerns about whether you can have a good money that is not fungible, completely fungible, right? 23:56 So in other words, if it can be shown on the ledger that a Bit- that some Bitcoins went through some, like, quote-unquote, "bad guy's wallet," right, a terrorist or a, some person on like an OFAC list or you name it, you know, if, if then those UTXOs are, you know, if then those Bitcoins, so-called, are, or those Satoshis are moved- To somebody else's wallet, or if there's some kind of link or chain or chain of custody, so to speak, of those tainted coins, right? 24:25 And so that become- that privacy fungibility becomes an issue- Mm... 24:30 when we're talking about the future of Bitcoin and whether it's gonna be a, you know, truly, uh, fulfill what we tend to believe is its destiny as, you know, a store value, then ultimately a medium of exchange, and then also u- ultimately a global unit of account. 24:46 So, um, it's, it's not anonymous, which is a good thing and a bad thing. Yeah. Yeah. 24:52 It, but, but, but there are concerns about actually to, to kind of do a little judo and flip your question on its head a little bit, there are actually some concerns about whether it's not anonymous enough- Mm... 25:03 so to speak, you know, um, and it in, which i- in a sense it's a better catch than- So it's not anonymous because, because you have that public ledger, you can track those past transactions and recognize and track who that is based on 25:19 connecting certain data points and knowing that those transactions happened at that time. Exactly. So for example- Yeah... say you go on to one of the more popular things like Coinbase- Yeah... and you buy $20. 25:30 Coinbase has a record on their centralized database showing that you purchased $20 now from your bank account- Mm... linking the two together. With your name. Yeah. Exactly. Okay. 25:39 So at any point, whenever you withdraw your Bitcoin, Coinbase also knows what address they've withdrawn to. 25:46 So those data points now link any addresses along that chain of transactions back to your initial funding source. So you can see that 25:55 not only did you buy $20 from Coinbase, but you can see how it's processed over to whatever people you pay. Yeah, exactly. And that's, and that's, and that's actually a KYC AML example, right? I mean, there are some... 26:08 But even with some forensic work, you can even, even if you, you, if even if hypothetically you did not pro- like buy your Bitcoin through an exchange that required know your customer, any model, an anti-money, anti-money laundering, uh, 26:25 you know, procedures, with some chain analysis and, and then some forensics- Mm... it still may be able to be determined who you are. But in any event, Patrick's exactly right. I mean- Yeah... most, most Bitcoins bought, 26:37 I th- I, I would venture to say that most Bitcoin is bought, uh, with KYC AML right now, and it's, it's a fairly trivial matter for those who really wanna know to determine who- Yeah... who has it, who bought it. Yeah. 26:48 That's a totally new learning for me. I totally thought it was anonymous. 26:52 Um, so talk about, you know, one of the big things being talked about right now in the crypto space is, you know, some of these other players entering the space. Facebook, uh, Libra, you know, talk about this whole... 27:04 What, what your all's opinion on this is. Personally, I don't, I, I don't view them as entering the same space. Um- Okay... 27:11 when I view Bitcoin, I view it as more the battle with the dollar, the battle with state issued currencies. Okay. 27:18 While Libra would be more a battle with PayPal as another way to move the same traditional assets on a different payment rail, while Bitcoin itself is more competing to be sound value. Okay. 27:31 Um, so it's kind of a different comparison- Yeah, I g-... I think. Yeah. I, I agree with that. I don't mean to interrupt you, but I, I totally agree with Patrick. I mean, look, you know, you know, these... 27:43 A- a- and look, when you're talking about Facebook, Visa, PayPal entering the space, it, that's not the space. They're just, they're just, just, you know, look, Li- Libra was interesting, right? 27:54 Because Libra w- I, I, I, in some ways I think we appreciated the Libra, um, hubbub in Congress and all that, right? Mm-hmm. 'Cause all of a sudden you got Donald Trump tweeting about Bitcoin and other stuff like that. 28:09 You've got Congress, you've got comments about Bitcoins and- Yeah... SH- SHITcoins in the Congressional Record, and, you know, 28:18 I, so I appreciate the Libra, um, the, I, I appreciated that solution being like dropped into the, into the, the, the- Social consensus... 28:27 in the p- into the public dialogue i- in- in order to, um, you know, that, that drop of liquid in other, in, in order to sort of stimulate some debate. But no, it, that has nothing... 28:40 That, I mean, I don't say nothing to the Bitcoin. By the way, I mean, I don't think Libra was even, I mean, that's not a blockchain even really. It's a pro- Yeah. It's debatable. Yeah. It's debatable- Yeah. 28:47 I mean, look... whether or not it's blockchain. Yeah. Right. Right. I mean, I mean, look, it's a payment rail. You know, Bit- Bitcoin, the purpose of Bitcoin is not payments. It's not a payment rail, you know? 28:56 It's, it's sound money, and it's i- in a pithy sense, it's digital gold or synthetic, synthetic gold. I mean, look, you know, the, all this stuff, 29:06 you know, i- if you look at the future of, uh, currencies, and I don't, I don't know what Patrick's opinion is, and I'm happy to have him, uh, you know, jump on the mic here in just a second. 29:14 I'd, I'd love to hear his opinion, but, you know, you can imagine a future, 29:19 you know, I don't know how far down the, the, the, the, uh, timeline we are toward something that's a bit more Orwellian, but you're looking at... I think it makes sense that, that, you know, 29:32 some of the major, uh, uh, you know, currencies will become, um, tokenized, so to speak, in the future just because of the liquidity opportunities, including the dollar, right? Mm-hmm. 29:44 So you can imagine a future where we have FedCoin, Yuan, RMB, like ChinaCoin, LibraCoin, which is like a corporate coin, and then Bitcoin. 29:57 You can imagine a future where those are the big, you c- those are kind of the big, the big, uh- Yeah... currencies. And, but, but nothing, nothing is like Bitcoin because Bitcoin is the only one that is decentralized, 30:09 uh, seizure-resistant, censorship resistant, uh, trust minimized, and, um, you know, one that nobody controls. You mentioned, so you mentioned these, these altcoins, these shitcoins as [laughs] you referred to them as. 30:23 Mm-hmm. So my biggest thing with Bitcoin and these other altcoins One, it, it throws a lot of confusion into the ring with cryptocurrency and, and the way people perceive Bitcoin. 30:34 But in my head, I always wanted to look at it as, as a, a better alternative, 'cause it's iterations on it. So I'd like to hear your guys' uh, rebuttal to that. 30:42 As, as the way I view it, the way I view it is one of these forks or, like, Litecoin or someone that's basically taken the code from Bitcoin and improved on it, made it quicker, uh, made the block sizes bigger, um, provided more, more privacy, like Monero I know I'm pretty sure is more private than Bitcoin. 31:00 So why, why is Bitcoin the end-all be-all when you could arguably say that some of these altcoins have improved little, little pieces of Bitcoin along the way? You can take it. Topic near and dear to my heart. 31:17 Um- [laughs] Yeah, I'm, I'm interested to hear the answer on this one, really. Um, where do I begin? So, uh, first, um, Bitcoin has the network effects. Mm-hmm. For sure. 31:33 Um, that, uh, that, that will, that will just in a sort of synergistic fashion essentially disallow, just through market forces, disallow any other, um... 31:46 I, I hate to even call them competitors, 'cause that's probably a compliment, but, uh, any, any, any other sort of public blockchains or cryptocurrencies from entering the space in a truly meaningful way. 31:59 Uh, network effects, uh, including but not limited to, uh, speculators, miners, uh, developers, uh, uh, financial products, financialization. Um, all these things work together. 32:11 Um, and there are others, but all these things work together to give Bitcoin, um, just, just too much, too much sway. Um, Bitc- that's the first. Second. Mm-hmm. 32:21 Bitcoin has what we would call the immaculate conception, right? There are no founders. Right, yeah. I mean, there's Satoshi. No one controlling it. 32:27 And he's, there's Satoshi, and he or she or it or they is a- Or Elon Musk... is a... [laughs] There's no Elon Musk. [laughs] There's no, there's no, there, there's nobody. It's, it's a ghost. Yeah. 32:40 And it's gone, and there's no, there's nobody to control, there's nobo- nobody to subpoena. 32:44 If the government wanted to shut down Ethereum, for whatever reason, I'm not saying they do, but if they ever did, you know, they could, they could subpoena, 32:53 or they could cer- you know, do some kind of service of process of some kind of documents on approximately five people, and Ethereum would be in big, have big problems. And that's about it, right? Mm-hmm. Okay? 33:04 And, and, and, um, uh, this isn't a podcast about Ethereum's problems, but that's, you know, that's just an example. So bec- so, so again, secondly, Bitcoin has the immaculate conception. It was conceived in a way 33:20 that, um, in a proper way, in the way when, where s- in, in which Satoshi knew that this could have happened. Uh, he or she or whomever went dark in 2010, I believe, and that was that. 33:34 So there's n- there's no centralized party. There's nobody to subpoena. There's nobody to shut down. Mm-hmm. 33:40 It's just completely, uh, decentralized, and this is, and this is part of the, uh, the, uh, the sturdiness of, of the Bitcoin network. Number three. Um, the, 33:58 the concept, what Bitcoin has done for the world, the world has g- it has given us the concept of digital scarcity. Mm-hmm. Okay, now think about ever since the sort of, 34:14 you know, the internet has become a thing, right? 34:16 I mean, we're talking about the 1970s, the '80s, the '90s with ARPANET and all this stuff, and, you know, e- you know, ever since the, the, the digital age, the digital age has almost been, um, 34:29 uh, almost synonymous with replicability, the ability to replicate data and, and copy and paste a file and so forth. Okay? Bitcoin has given us digital scarcity, okay? And it's almost, it almost defeats, 34:48 uh, the concept to say, well, well s- and, and by the way, scarcity is most important, uh, for money, which by the way is as fundamental to humanity as language. Yeah, absolutely. 35:00 And, and, okay, and, and, and may have, may have, may have come about, about the same time as language, uh, in, in prehistory. But 35:07 so if the concept of digital scarcity, and Bitcoin gave us this, to say that there is another non-trivial monetary good 35:20 outside of that 21 million or past that 21 million, it defeats the purpose of digital scarcity. In other words, if another one is to be suc- is to succeed, 35:30 then that defeats the whole purpose of, of the whole concept of digital scarcity. Yeah. In, in fact, the whole purpose of digital currency. By the way, we already have digital currency, right? 35:37 90% of the US dollar is in circulation digital. Mm-hmm. Right? Yeah. I mean, it, it, it- That, that's a good way to explain it. So in other words, it's 21 million, and that's that. Yeah. That's freaking that, you know? 35:49 Yeah. And if, and if you, and if, and if, if Monero or, or Litecoin or PizzaCoin or whatever, uh, is to come along, it's just, uh, 36:00 it, it defeats the whole purpose of, of the, of, of the, of really the phenomenon, the movement, if you will. Yeah. Lastly, I'd say, um, that, uh, you know... Well, I'll tell you what. 36:13 I'll let Patrick jump in, and then I might make a point. Well, I guess- Jeopardizing my queue... 36:17 I guess my point to the technical side would even be that when you look at, at Bitcoin, it, it's almost the base layer, and you can use second layers to do anything that's cool as far as the payment technology or- Mm... 36:30 the mixing. Um, so there's things like Lightning as far as- Sending value. Um, Bitcoin has a traditional 10-minute block time, as a lot of people know, if you know a little bit about Bitcoin. 36:41 But there's ways that you can actually work those transactions into a network called the Lightning Network, where you can send funds instantly that are cryptographically sound and locked that are just as fast as anything else, faster than any three-second blockchains and such like that. 36:58 Um, even beyond that, you can have second layers that add fungibility. That's some of the different things that are being addressed now as ways to add that fungibility that Dan talked about. 37:07 So there's, there is a lot of cool tech that's looked at inside of these, but at the same time, that tech isn't what the value proposition of digital currencies or blockchain is. And, and, and Bitcoin will suck it up. 37:18 I mean, look, if there's, if there's a g- if there's a good innovation, Bitcoin will suck it up. Now Bitcoin, Bitcoin development, and I'm not a core developer and, and I'm not a... I don't have a, 37:28 much of a technical background, which is probably an understatement, but, um, Bitcoin will suck it up. If there's a great- If there's a, if there's a truly groundbreaking, 37:36 uh, privacy or other related technical, technical development, uh, you know, you better believe that Bitcoin, uh, can and will absorb it if it's appropriate. 37:48 Um, but it's, you know, these alt- these, these so-called altcoins are, are interesting test nets or experiments, I guess. And I'm, and, and I also, I, I will say as an aside that I appreciate, 38:00 you know, the fact that they just sort of add to the hype of the whole- Yeah... the whole, the whole sort of quote unquote cryptocurrency world. Let me say one or two other points on that, then we'll move on. Yeah. 38:11 Understand that these projects, man, all these other projects, right? If you understand, like if you understand the concept of a cargo cult, right? 38:18 The proverbial cargo cult, and I'm gonna, I'm gonna butcher the, the, uh, the proverb here. But basically, you know, a ship flies in, you know... 38:28 or excuse me, an airplane flies in, flies into an island dropping off supplies, you know. And the population of this island, and I'm gonna try to describe this in a culturally 38:38 neutral sensitive way, but, you know, the airplane flies in, and then, and the inhabit- inhabitants of the island receive these supplies, and this happens once a month. 38:47 It happens once a month for, say, 12 months in a row. Month 13, there's no airplane. Month 14, there's no airplane. Month 15, the islanders say to themselves, "You know, 38:59 w- we need these goods," and they, they construct an airplane that looks like the airplane that used to fly in to deliver these goods, right? You know? They like, they like make it out of like, you know- [laughs] Yeah... 39:12 like palm trunks and stuff, right? To simulate the ef- to, to try to, to try to conjure the effects of this airplane coming in, right? It's like a cargo cult. This is, this is the- Yeah... this is the point. 39:25 And so the point is a lot of these projects are aping, and this was classic, you know, sort of 2017 hype and stuff. You know, these projects ape the Bitcoin because of the, the 39:41 profound success and, and potential of Bitcoin. And that's, that's essentially what we're looking at, you know, is, is, is, is the aping a lot of the characteristics of what is actually a truly great project, so. Yeah. 39:55 That, that makes a lot of sense as well. That's a great explanation. 39:58 What are some of the catalysts, you know, world events, cultural events, um, monetary events in the world that will be a catalyst for Bitcoin going forward? 40:08 You know, I think, you know, we can say that, uh, is it gonna grow really slowly, or there'll be events that happen in the world that make us realize, "Oh, shoot." Number go up. Say it again. Number go up. It... 40:20 I'm, I'm kidding. But at the same- Patrick, you want, you wanna take this one? At the same time, you're not. Um, the, the biggest thing that I think that's gonna be- Non-correlated. Go ahead. 40:29 [laughs] Is that Bitcoin itself, um, has a halving, so every four years you see the supply of Bitcoin that are being introduced to the market being cut in half. 40:40 So that means that every four years, as long as supply for this asset stays equal, that means that by supply and demand, the price is gonna have to go up. Mm-hmm. 40:52 And as Dan keeps alluding to, the number's gonna keep going up, which is just gonna keep driving more demand- Listen... on a limited supply. World, world event... 41:00 Listen, I think that what Patrick may be saying, and correct me if I'm wrong, but 41:06 world events, you know, which schmuck is elected president, um, you know, uh, you know, Russia, you know, the Chinese, the latest Chinese virus, all this stuff, doesn't matter for the most part. 41:21 These things can cause tiny little blips in the day-to-day price action of Bitcoin. 41:27 What we're talking about here, and I'll, I'll try to keep it short, but what we're talking about here is, uh, and Satoshi was, was quite eloquent in his code in basically instituting this. 41:41 What we're talking about here is stock-to-flow ratio, right? Okay? Basically, every four years there's a halvening. Okay? The next halvening is happening in early May 2020. Okay? And the next one will be in, 41:55 you know, sometime in the spring of 2024, we believe. Although it's not based on the time, like a, whatever, like a Julian or Gregorian calendar. A calendar, yeah. 42:03 It's based on actually like, like the, the, the, the, the, uh- The block times... the block times, right? So, so basically what happens is these halvenings occur. 42:14 And what happens is this halvening, the rate of issuance of new Bitcoins gets cut in half, right? So right now we've got ab- approximately, what is it, 12 and a half new Bitcoins are issued to the miners, 42:26 uh- Every 10 minutes... every, uh, every approximate 10 minutes. Roughly. Right? Okay. At a n- 42:32 At, at a s- at all of a sudden- On approximately May 8th, 2020, although it may be plus or minus a couple days, we're kind of still trying to figure it out, that rate of issuance of new supply gets cut in half, okay? 42:46 That happens again roughly four years later, okay? And what, what history has shown, and this is, this is actually emergent and proxy. This, this is a description of what has emerged as human behavior. 42:59 This is praxeological, okay? This is descriptive. What you see, and this has now been studied, and you see not only a correlation but a co-integration that price tracks the stock-to-flow ratio 43:13 in an absolutely uncanny fashion. And so what happens is there's a halvening or a halving, as it were, every four years. Approximately a year and a half after the halving, you have the peak of the hype cycle. 43:29 So you had the, the spring 2016 halving. What happened in like 2017? It was bonkers, right? Price went up to nineteen thousand. You have the May 2020 halving. 43:41 What could, and I'm, I don't have a crystal ball, and I'm not God, I don't know what's gonna happen, but what's, what could happen in November, December 2021? Bonkers. Price action, okay? 43:52 And, and we, we, we have this, and this price correlation has occurred. You, you can track it back, not only correlation but co-integration like a rubber band. 44:02 The price and the stock-to-flow ratio don't ever get too far away from one another. And this goes back to Bitcoin's early days from 2011 and so forth, even before. So, you know, this is, this is how we... 44:15 And, and by the way, the R2, and I'm not a statistician, but the R2 of basically the price versus stock-to-flow ratio, the stock being what exists 44:25 out there currently now as far as the supply of Bitcoin versus the flow, which is the, the issuance of new Bitcoins every year, okay? 44:33 The R2 of the, of the stock-to-flow versus the price, okay, in Bitcoin's case is like something like ninety-two, ninety-three percent. With gold, it's like ninety-eight, ninety-nine percent, right? Yeah. 44:45 Like this is real stuff, so- So just, just to clarify what you're saying here, you're saying that they're very, very closely correlated. Like they move together very, very closely. They, they, they do. They actually do. 44:55 And um, so this is what, uh, I would sus- And if I can speak for Patrick as well for a moment, this is what we think will essentially... 45:03 I mean, if you had to, you know, I can't predict the future, and I don't claim to be able to do so, and I'm not gonna make an absolute price prediction. 45:08 But if you put a gun to my head and said, you know, "Tell me about what you think the Bitcoin price will probably be at a certain date and time," 45:16 you know, I, I look at, I look at the stock-to-flow, and that's just kinda how it works. Yeah. You know? It's the way a commodity works. I can explain why that is, but, you know, I don't wanna take up too much time. 45:27 Yeah. Yeah. No, we gotta, you know, for the sake of, you know, the audience- Okay... we gotta keep it, uh, as high level, you know, as we can. Um, but let's, we always like to end on a couple questions. 45:39 One is the future of Bitcoin in Lexington, where do y'all see that going? You know, you guys talked about how you're helping the city begin to adopt this more, begin to become more educated on this. 45:53 But you know, looking forward, do you guys see m- more of the same, or do you guys see anything changing in the city of Lexington as far as, you know, Bitcoin goes? 46:02 I think my utopian dream would be to say that you see Bitcoin become just as commonly used here as, as money. Yeah. That you view money as no different of a thing that, that you do Bitcoin. 46:14 Um, that being said, that, I do realize that's gonna be a longer-term dream. Um, so I, I still see lots of the same. 46:21 I see that as interest peaks, we're gonna see waves of new entrants into the thing that will s- say, "Hey, I would love to begin accepting Bitcoin in my shop. Um, tell me how." Yeah. 46:31 All the way to whatever those services may be. I just think it's gonna be a time as people, as, as the community finds the value to it, um, which work every day to try to help them see that. Yep. Um, so, 46:48 uh, future of Bitcoin in Lexington. I think that, um, Lexington is a very prudent place, and I think that there will come a time, okay? And listen, it's gradually then suddenly. Yeah. Okay? 47:01 Just like if you look at the tall S curve even- of adoption of any new technology. Yeah. It's gradually then suddenly. 47:06 There will come a time, and it will be gradually and then all of a sudden, when it will become imprudent not to, not to have any Bitcoin. And I say Bitcoin, but what I actually mean is Satoshis. Because by that time, 47:21 and the time is approaching, most people won't be able to, uh, afford to own a whole Bitcoin. Yeah, right. Okay? And so it will become imprudent. 47:32 It will be like insurance, like, I don't know, like home insurance or something like- Yeah. What do you mean? You don't have, like, homeowner's insurance? What are you, crazy? 47:39 [laughs] Like what if your house burns down, right? Yeah. So it will become, like we, we always think h- you know, I think one of the, one of the signs or markers of hyperBitcoinization will be when it becomes imprudent 47:51 not to, not to have any. I think, I think that's, that's Jameson Lopp's idea, by the way. That's, I don't take credit for that. And so, um, and, and I think Lexington is a very prudent place. Um, and I think that, um, 48:05 you know, I think Lexington, uh, there's a, there's an opportunity for us to, uh, be in- be involved and see the future, uh, not be blind and, um, try to take, take advantage of our opportunities. 48:19 I, I don't have a, an enormous amount of confidence in, uh, the long term of the economy maybe in some sense, right? I mean, I think, I think the final crackup boom is coming. We don't know when. 48:38 Um, if you're an Austrian economist, that's, that's kind of what, you know, is going to happen. And so, uh, I want, I want Lexington to be prepared for that. I want people here, my loved ones to be prepared for that. 48:48 And so that's what we intend to intend to do. You know, Patrick and I wish to facilitate, um, 48:55 um, you know, Bitcoin, uh, not only adoption as a store of value, but also as Patrick, you know, this is his, I know what goes through his head, you know, sugar plums and fairies and, and, uh, Bitcoin as a medium of exchange. 49:09 Uh, and, and, and I think eventually we'll get there. And so, uh, I look forward to that, that day as well. I think that, uh, it's very likely that Bitcoin will, um, 49:20 will do a lot of things for people in Lexington and elsewhere. Um, you know, money is such a, uh, an unbelievably almost unconscious part of our, part of our lives. You know, half of every transaction is money. 49:33 And, and, um, whether, whether we're talking about lower our lowering our time preference because of scarce asset or, um, you know, being, 49:45 you know, being more guarded against malinvestment because of, uh, we won't, we won't be so concerned about easy money because easy money will, you know, collapse or dried up. So I don't know. So we're, we're excited. 49:57 Uh, it's a, it's quite a time to be alive, um, from this perspective. Um, and so no, no, I just, uh, you know, I'm fortunate to have, uh, Patrick as my partner in, uh, in this endeavor and, you know, I look forward. 50:12 I think the next few years are going to be a lot of fun. Yeah. Awesome. Well, thank you guys for coming on. 50:16 I hope that, you know, the audience was able to come away with this learning things just like I did, you know, uh, I learned a lot there in the middle of the episode and go ahead. Yeah. 50:25 I just want to give you a shout out to your podcast. I think it's great. 50:28 Um, you've had a lot of great guests on and I just want to, um, and I know some of them personally, and I just want to encourage you guys to keep doing what you're doing. It's an awesome podcast.