Transcript 0:00 Welcome back to the Middle Tech podcast. Nate Antotomaso and Evan Knowles here. We have an update from a great episode last year. 0:07 We talked about executives at Facebook and the string of high-profile exits that these executives of even potentially past acquisitions have had. Well, this week, two more announced that they were leaving. 0:19 What's going on? 0:20 [rock music] Welcome back to the Middle Tech podcast. 0:44 My name, as always, is Nate Antotomaso. I am joined by Evan Knowles. I'm in Chicago. Evan is in Lexington. How you doing, man? Doing well. It was a good St. Patrick's Day weekend, a lot of fun. 0:56 Yeah, we're recording on Sunday, actually St. Patrick's Day, but I think we both celebrated yesterday. Yeah. Yeah, I think most people did. Yeah. It's tough trying to go to work right after St. 1:06 Patrick's Day [laughs] if you did it on St. Patrick's Day. Yeah. I had a slow morning, that's for sure. Yeah, and then yesterday was the UK game. Unfortunately they lost to Tennessee. Just had Selection Sunday, though. 1:18 My, my mom is pissed. We were place- replacing the Midwest with, uh, UNC as our one seed, and she is, like, completely mad about that, but I think it's a pretty decent draw. Yeah, I'll take UNC over Duke for sure. 1:31 Mm-hmm. Yeah, but they... The thing is, we beat them. We, we actually beat them in Chicago. Me and my mom went to that game, uh, that was right before Christmas. 1:38 But then they turned around and beat Duke twice, and then we obviously got destroyed by Duke, so I'm a little worried. Well, Zion wasn't playing. Uh, the- Wasn't... He wasn't, right? 1:49 Uh, let's- 'Cause he got injured the first one. Yeah. And then he didn't play at all the second one. He played, like, 30 seconds in the first one. You're right. Yeah. Okay. That's a g- That makes me feel a lot better. 1:58 I didn't even think of that. That's a great point. Well, okay, so that was basketball talk with Nate and Evan. Let's get into- [laughs] Let's get into some technology stuff. We have an update, uh, this week. 2:10 Last year we recorded an episode about, um, some top executives that were leaving Facebook. We've obviously talked a ton about Facebook on this podcast just 'cause it's, it's so defining in the tech world right now. 2:23 Um, and there's been some news that, uh, that has come out this week regarding privacy, which we've talked at length about, regarding the executives leaving the company, which we've talked a little bit about. 2:31 So we, we felt it was kind of time to, to jump back into the story and then provide a little bit of an update. Yeah, a lot of stuff going on with Facebook right now. 2:40 Uh, and, and like Nate said, we, we definitely gotta keep covering Facebook because, uh, it's one of the top three co- companies in the entire world as far as, you know, having influence. 2:50 So whatever they do, the world needs to know the implications of it. So, uh, yeah. They're making some major changes. We'll walk you through those, uh, and, and how that's affecting their, uh, their executive team. Yeah. 3:03 So we'll, we'll play the, uh, the episode from last year now. We'll go ahead and just pop that in, and then we'll come back at the end and we're gonna give an update. 3:11 So here is our episode last year about executives at Facebook. So we had been talking earlier this week off air just about Instagram, uh, and then the founders leaving Facebook. 3:25 Um, so we, we realized that we wanted to dive into it and look through our, I guess, kind of history. It's almost like we did a little bit of historical research here. 3:34 And what we've realized is that over the years, Facebook has acquired all these companies. Um, and the, the idea is that they're gonna run independently. 3:43 They're gonna use the, the power of Facebook and the resources of Facebook, but they're gonna stay independent, and these founders will be able to run their own companies. 3:52 Um, but more and more over the last year, coupled with all the controversies Facebook has been going through, it also seems like they're trying to rein in everything that's going on with these subsidiaries. 4:05 And their three biggest, um, acquisitions have all led to very public exits by the founders. Um, and then the fourth one has kind of been under wraps. 4:17 Um, they haven't really talked about it much, but it seems like the founders are gone and a lot of the staff is gone too. So I think the, the era of Facebook parenting companies is completely changing right now. Yeah. 4:33 I mean, you know, on a high level, you know, we'll dive into each individual acquisition. Mm-hmm. 4:38 But at a high level what's going on is, you know, Mark Zuckerberg and Facebook are acquiring these companies under the impression that they're gonna be independent. Yeah. 4:45 And, you know, come to find out, you know, after a few years of being run independently, you know, slowly Facebook, uh, executive team and Mark Zuckerberg work their way inside and, you know, make small changes. 4:56 And eventually those small changes get bigger and bigger and, you know, it ends up frustrating the founders and they get pushed out, which is exactly what happened with Instagram. Um- Mm-hmm. 5:05 And that's what it seems- But- It seems like that with all of these, that it's kind of over time. 5:09 Like, oh, there's a little disagreement here, a little disagreement there, and then when you're running a business that has millions of users, that just can balloon so quickly. Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. 5:19 Um, but yeah, let's get into the, the examples here. Let, let's do, um, Instagram last because it's kind of the, the biggest one in the news. Let's just go back a little bit. Um, one that 5:34 really is interesting to me, um, to start off is Oculus. Um, you know, Oculus VR. You've probably heard of the Oculus Rift. That was one of their, their products. Um, Facebook acquired Oculus in 2014 for $2 billion. 5:50 Um, and there were a couple co-founders, but, but the biggest guy was Palmer Luckey. He's actually just two years older than us, Evan. He's a young dude. Yeah. Nice. Uh, he's a... 6:00 Talk about geniuses, he's, he's one of them. Um- But so Oculus got acquired by Facebook. They, they came into the Menlo Park campus. 6:09 All these companies, like, get their own little offices on the campus, which I think is really cool. 6:13 Um, it's almost like they're setting up a, a carnival of all these little companies [laughs] that are just dotted around this, this bigger campus. Um, but there was a very public exit of Palmer because of 6:30 politics, basically, and- Oh, yeah, rumored, yeah. Yeah, it was totally- Rumored to be about politics. Um, but Mark Zuckerberg said it wasn't at that congressional hearing. Yeah. I mean, who knows what it was for. 6:46 But at the end of the day, uh, you know, Palmer Luckey created, you know, a great, great product that makes sense and fits within Facebook's- Mm-hmm... long-term vision. 6:55 Um, at the time, based on what I read, you know, they had the best product in the market as far as what VR was. Oh, for sure. Um, you know- And the most accessible one too. Yeah, yeah. 7:06 And so Facebook's whole move here, whether they try to push out, you know, the founder or not, is to make VR mainstream. And I don't think anybody has the chance that Facebook does to do that. Mm-hmm. 7:18 Um, and they're rapidly throwing a lot of money into it. You know, they're launching new products. They just launched a new one, uh, supposed to be coming out in, uh, 2019. 7:29 Uh, a new, a new headset that's supposed to be, you know, no wires. You don't even have to plug it into a PC. Yeah. 7:35 Uh, so it's, it's stuff like that, that Facebook's trying to push forward and, uh, get out into the world. Mm-hmm. 7:42 Yeah, so the, the, the issue with Palmer Luckey was he, he donated to a bunch of anti-Hillary Clinton, um, super PACs and organizations and, and whatnot around the 2016 election. 7:55 Um, and that obviously in the tech community was not popular. Um, so there's a big kind of- Of helps... outcry against Oculus and against Facebook and everything. 8:05 Um, at the, when Mark Zuckerberg just testified in front of Congress a couple months ago, he said it was a personnel issue, and he didn't leave because of politics. Um, 8:15 but that definitely impacted the business of Oculus, so my theory would be there's some kind of connection there. Um, but another thing- Yeah, and I'm sure, 8:26 I'm sure there was, you know, just like with what we're gonna talk about with the other ones, there was- Yeah... 8:30 slowly, uh, you know, the, the, Mark Zuckerberg and, and Palmer were probably slowly, uh, distancing themselves from each other. Mm-hmm. Because, you know, when you get acquired, 8:42 you have to give up, you know, your independence. You have to give up a lot of your decision-making, um, over time, and I'm sure that was happening, and I'm sure the political stuff didn't help. 8:50 I'm sure that kind of pushed everything over the edge. Yeah. But overall, you know, long term, Oculus is gonna be a huge part of their strategy, whether, you know, the original founder's there or not. 9:04 I don't think it necessarily- Yeah... gonna change anything about Oculus, you know? Uh- So they, they just did, you, you mentioned they just introduced a new product. 9:11 They just had the, their, like, annual keynote basically. Yeah. 9:15 And it was Mark Zuckerberg and a couple other executives at Facebook that were up there giving the presentation and introducing the new products, where in the past it has always been the Oculus founders. 9:27 Um, and so that was a very visual representation of kind of this trend of bringing everything more in-house. Yeah. I mean, I, I, it's weird to see that. It's, it- Mm-hmm... kind of, you know, sits weird with me to 9:42 see a great, you know, company get acquired and then the founders get pushed out, and it's happened, you know, we're gonna get into it, but it, it happens with every company Facebook acquires. Yeah. 9:50 And it just doesn't seem right. Um- Mm-hmm... there needs to be some kind of synergy there and, you know, teamwork, and it just doesn't seem like Mark Zuckerberg or his, you know, executive team's willing to do that. 10:02 Yeah. I have a, I have a point to make on that, but I'm gonna save it for the end. Yeah. Um, yeah. So that, that's Oculus VR, still kind of under wraps. Not as under wraps as, 10:15 uh, and that was their third lar- largest acquisition of all time. Their fourth largest acquisition of all time is probably even more under wraps. It's this company called, uh, LiveRail. 10:24 They do, like, video advertising, so if you own a website and you have videos on it, you can run pre-roll ads, and you can make money. Um, and you can have really good targeting, just like you would on Facebook. 10:35 So the idea is that Facebook was gonna acquire them and build out this thing that they now have called the Audience Network, which is exactly that. You can target like you do with ads on Facebook but anywhere online. 10:47 Um, so LiveRail was supposed to come that, become that, but apparently there was some problem with an integration or something, um, and they've just kind of been real quiet about it. 10:55 And slowly over the last few years, the last four years, um, a bunch of the staff has left. Both of the co-founders are now gone. Um, and there's really been no news of what's going on with that technology. 11:06 But if you go to their website, it, uh, it redirects to the Facebook Audience Network, but we know that that came from a different acquisition, that piece of technology that has become the Audience Network. So 11:19 that- Yeah... I think that failed maybe as a business move, but it also failed in a way to make the whole staff exit the company. Yeah, that's really interesting. I don't know much about that. 11:29 Yeah, and that's intentional. I was doing the research- Yeah, I'm sure... under this, and they, there's, like, nothing out there. Hmm. Yeah, interesting. Um, yeah. 11:36 So those are the two kind of more low-key, um, acquisitions and, and big blowups in the Facebook world. Um, but these next two are, are the really big ones. So l- let's get into WhatsApp. 11:47 Do you wanna talk about that a little bit? Yeah. So I'll, I'd like to start with, like, kind of the growth of WhatsApp- Yeah... and what they started as, um, which was just wild. Um, 11:59 I, you know, I, I do a lot of research on a lot of companies, and Instagram and WhatsApp, their growth from the time they were started- To when they got acquired was just wild. 12:09 You know, at one point, uh, WhatsApp was getting, I think, a million new users a day, which was just- That's insane... crazy. Yeah. And by the time they got acquired, they, you know, already had the majority. 12:22 They were so far ahead of Facebook Messenger that Facebook basically had no choice but to acquire them. Uh- Mm. I read one stat that they processed more messages than the entire US text message technology- That's nuts... 12:34 that the carriers operate. Yeah. We did. Which is insane. There's more WhatsApp messages than there are text messages. Yeah. And that's what, you know, messaging's going towards. 12:43 It's moving away from, you know, a lot of the carriers towards these messaging platforms like WhatsApp- Mm-hmm... WeChat- Yeah... and services like that. 12:51 So it's a good move by Facebook to acquire them while they were still the size they were, 'cause now they're 1.5 billion- Mm-hmm... uh, users, and I think when they acquired them, they were around 350 or 450. 13:03 That's, that's just an insane, insane amount of users. [laughs] Like- No, yeah... that's a huge percentage of the world population. 13:12 Well, and, and, you know, when we had done our research, we, we have in our notes here that, you know, the founder, uh, was an immigrant from Ukraine. Mm-hmm. 13:20 Uh, and, you know, was trying to create a communications platform 'cause he knew how it felt, you know, to have to communicate, uh, from the US to, you know, Russia and Ukraine. Yeah. So that's, that's part of the... 13:33 I mean, let's get into it a little bit. 13:34 So basically, the disagreement there on a super high level was that there was just a, it seems like a fundamental disagreement between Mark Zuckerberg and the founder, uh, I, I'm gonna mispronounce his last name, Jan Koum. 13:48 Koum, I'm just gonna say Jan. Um, Jan and Mark Zuckerberg had, like, a, a fundamental disagreement in what was important to them. Mark Zuckerberg's a CEO of a public company. He's running a business. 13:59 He needs to make revenue. He needs to retain users. Jan was an immigrant from Ukraine, and he was trying to communicate to family back in Ukraine. 14:08 Um, and there's a lot of geopolitical issues with that region of the world, and he was afraid that the communications might have been bugged by Russia, um, they are not private, all these, all these issues. 14:20 And so privacy and encryption was his number one thing, and he cr- he set out to create a company that would be completely private and completely encrypted, and he ended up accomplishing that. Um, 14:34 and he actually accomplished the encryption after they were already acquired by Facebook. They were acquired in 2014 for $19 billion, um, which is absolutely insane. Um- Yeah. 14:45 I mean, he was just starting a company for the pure user experience of communication, uh, through Messenger. Yeah. And, and the, the feeling of safety and of- Absolutely... ease to communicate across the world. 14:57 Um, but so he, you know, they sold to Facebook, and he moved his team into the Menlo Park campus. Um, and they were working and, and slowly, um, 15:08 Mark just wanted to start doing more business moves and be able to take the user profiles from WhatsApp and integrate them with their greater user profiles to be able to target data, um, to target ads based on all that data. 15:20 He wanted... There's rumors he wanted to read the messages so you could target based on what you're saying in your messages, all that kind of stuff. 15:27 Um, and that obviously was fundamentally opposed to why the company was created, so things kind of bubbled up between the two of them. Yeah, this was after Facebook promised, you know, to never do that. Mm-hmm. 15:40 They promised to always keep the company independent, make sure that privacy and encryption were core to the business, and, you know, eventually, like we, we've been saying all this, this entire podcast, that that trust dissolved over time as more asks were being made. 15:55 I think the first ask was, uh, to collect the phone numbers of all the users of WhatsApp- Yeah... and then to collect their, uh, device IDs and, uh, you know, track what kind of devices were being used. Mm-hmm. Yeah. 16:07 And I think they did end up doing that while he was still at the company, and that was for security purposes, but then it just kept going, um, further than that. 16:16 And he, he left, and he actually left 950 million on the table, um, from unvested stock, which is crazy. He, he was that opposed to where the company was going that he would leave almost a billion dollars on the table. 16:30 Um- And then the other co-founder of WhatsApp came out very publicly and, you know, was saying, uh, you know, he's... There was this whole movement after the Cambridge Analytica, uh, you know, scandal that, 16:47 uh, you know, get off Facebook, delete Facebook, and- Mm-hmm... the other co-founder of WhatsApp came out very publicly and said, uh... and actually deleted his Facebook account. Yeah. 16:55 So that was, you know, definitely a, a strong move on his part. Uh, he even insulted, you know, the Facebook executives, uh, on his way out, so it was pretty, pretty messy. Yeah. 17:06 Um, you know, leave all that money on the table, come out very publicly against, against the, the company that made you a billionaire. Um, and I, I think that's probably the most v- not visual, what's the word? 17:20 The strongest example of, of this culture that seems to be happening over at Facebook. Um, the promise of independence can't balance with the business needs, 17:32 and that when you have such a, a core cultural difference, that just can't work out. Yeah. Well, let's get into, uh, any- anything else you wanna cover there before we get into Instagram? 17:41 'Cause Instagram was a very similar trajectory, but it didn't, it didn't end as messy, but it, it definitely has more amplifications of, of where Facebook's going, I think. Yeah. Let's get into it. Go ahead. Yeah. 17:55 Well, just like we've done WhatsApp, I think we should start with kind of how Instagram got started. Yeah. Um, and, you know, just like WhatsApp, Instagram had an insane amount of growth right when it started. Mm-hmm. 18:06 I think after 24 hours they had a million users. I don't even know how it's possible. That was, that was the WhatsApp growth. They had- Was it? Yeah, Instagram had- I thought it was Instagram. That way. 18:19 That was when they launched Android. When they launched the... 'Cause it was iOS exclusive at first. Mm. Um, when they launched the Android app, they got a million Android users in 24 hours. Um, 18:31 but they, they launched as Instagram in like October of, uh, 2010, and by December of 2010 they had a million users. So in two months organically they got a million. That is so stupid. Wow. It's insane. 18:48 That's absolutely insane. Um- And I think that's such a lean team. Uh, when I listened to their podcast and that. I think when they got acquired, they ha- they had barely had any employees. 18:59 Maybe it was, I thought it was like 15 maybe. Yeah. Yeah, they were extremely lean. Um, 19:06 but they were actually, before they, they were Instagram, they were this app called Bourbon actually, which is a cool tie to Kentucky, but it was just like a, a social planning and, and social like identification app. 19:19 Where, where should I go do, what's a cool thing to do? 19:22 Um, and part of that app was you could take a picture of what you were doing, um, and you could put a filter on it, and you could post it and say, "Oh look, I'm doing this, and also here's a picture of it." 19:32 At the time, smartphones were just becoming extremely popular. Everybody loved the novelty of having a camera, but the cameras weren't that good, so you had to filter these pictures to make them look better. 19:43 So it was kind of the perfect storm, and they realized everybody was using these pictures, and it was actually the most popular part of the app versus any of the other social features. 19:53 So they just said, "We're just gonna start focusing on photos." Yeah. And then they relaunched as Instagram. Yeah, the founders met at Stanford. Mm-hmm. Of course. But all along they were very well-connected. Uh- Yeah... 20:05 Jack Dorsey was actually one of their, one of their best friends. Jack Dorsey was an investor early on in the company. Mm-hmm. 20:11 Um, it's just interesting, you know, all, that whole group of Jack Dorsey and, and Kevin and Mike just knew each other and, uh, I, I just thought that was really interesting. Yeah. 20:22 I mean, I feel like Silicon Valley is so much smaller than it seems. Yeah. I feel like everybody kinda- Yeah... is connected to everybody. They all go to the same schools. Yeah. Yeah. Um, but yeah. 20:35 So they, they launched in 2010, uh, late 2010, and then in April of 2012 they sold to Facebook for $1 billion. Um, so not, you know, nearly the, the biggest acquisition that they... 20:52 Yeah, it's the third biggest acquisition Facebook's done, but probably the most successful over time. 20:57 Um- Yeah, I think it came out that they're now worth $100 billion if they wouldn't have been acquired based on their monthly active users and- Yeah... um, their growth rate. Mm-hmm. Which is... I mean, that's 100X. 21:08 I mean, that's, that's insane. Yeah, in six years. That's crazy. Um, but where, where am I here in these notes? 21:16 Yeah, so, so they got acquired and just like all these companies, the story was, you know, they're gonna remain independent, they're gonna keep their own team, but they'll be able to utilize the Facebook machine. 21:28 You know, they wouldn't have to worry about recruiting, they wouldn't have to worry about server capacity. They wouldn't have had to do the boring business stuff. 21:35 They could just build a great product and they could build their product. That was the story at the time. Yeah. And over time it turned out not to be the case. 21:45 [laughs] And, uh, they just kept getting asked and then pushed towards, you know, monetizing the, the product. Mm-hmm. Yeah. And I think a lot of that came and was accelerated because of Snapchat. Yeah. 21:59 Snapchat came out. Facebook had actually tried to buy Snapchat for, for $3 billion. Yeah. Which I, yeah, would've been interesting how that worked out. They probably would've bought them and just spun it into Instagram. 22:08 I don't know. Maybe. Or- I don't know... I could see Instagram not being nearly as popular today if Snapchat was bought by Facebook and can they have basically competing platforms. 22:20 But I guess they wouldn't compete at that time because they didn't do stories, so. Yeah. Um, but anyway. But anyway, yeah. Yeah, that's off topic. 22:27 But, um, you know, it started, from what I was reading, it started with like some content issues. 22:34 You know, a lot of younger people were moving towards Instagram, and there was so much more photo sharing on Instagram than there was on Facebook anymore. 22:42 And Mark Zuckerberg, beyond just the, the monetary parts of wanting to put ads where the content was, Facebook's his baby. You know, he created that and he wanted to have content on Facebook. 22:52 So there was a lot of disagreements of how content that's posted on Instagram should be shared to Facebook, how it should be identified on Facebook as being from Instagram. 23:03 Um, you know, when you post on, on Instagram, you see like the share to Facebook thing. Um, that was a big argument. And then when it shows up on Facebook, it used to say Instagram, if you remember that. Now it doesn't. 23:15 That was a big argument. With stories more recently, you could share your Instagram story now to your Facebook story. Um, it's the same, same concept, and it doesn't even say that it's an Instagram story. 23:28 Um, so that's kind of how things started to bubble up between them. Um, and then there was a big personnel shift, um, and it, it... 23:37 The consolidation I think just became too much for these amazing, amazing product entrepreneurs who weren't in control of their product anymore. Well, they took off, uh... 23:45 Yeah, so I think the, the change in the executive group was they took the VP of product of Instagram and put him in charge of the blockchain arm of Facebook. Then they moved, um, 23:58 they moved a Facebook executive that was, you know, Mark Zuckerberg's right-hand man- Mm-hmm... 24:03 into Instagram's team, and that just kind of, you know, fueled everything going on, and eventually got to the point where Kevin and, and Mike left. Yeah. There was this really cool article I was reading. 24:14 It was called, um- The Facebook, uh, or not Facebook. [laughs] See, I'm doing it now too. The, the Instagram entrepreneurs have always had great timing. You know, they created this photo app when everybody got a camera. 24:26 They got acquired when they needed support. You know, they, they have g- good timing. 24:32 And it was arguing that while all these issues might be a problem at Facebook, they also just have good timing and know when it's time to move on, and maybe it's just the inevitable. 24:43 Instagram's not gonna be cool in a long time because that's how social media works. 24:48 While I think that's interesting, and that's probably part of it because they're such big entrepreneurs and they're such good product people, I think when you have a baby like that, s- 24:59 you, you don't just leave it 'cause it's not gonna be cool in a little bit. Yeah. No, that was definitely pent-up frustration and- Mm-hmm... lack of creative reign. You know, they weren't allowed to... 25:09 I'm sure over time their creativity was, you know, stomped down and- Mm-hmm... they're creative people. They're entrepreneurs, and entrepreneurs don't like being told what to do, you know? 25:19 They just like to be creative and, and build stuff. And, you know, if Mark Zuckerberg is the head honcho there and, you know, he's the face of the company, then there's not room for others. 25:27 There's just simply not, you know? Yeah. You don't know anybody else who works under Elon Musk, do you? So- Yeah... eventually over time, they just got frustrated and said, "You know, we're too good for this. 25:37 We're gonna move on to something else, and, uh, we're tired of being told what to do." Yeah. So, that's just what happened. So, that's the point I talked about earlier that I wanted to bring up. 25:46 Um, I think you, you said it really well. Um, you don't know anybody who works under Elon. You know, Tesla, SpaceX, SolarCity, that's Elon Musk. The Boring Company. You think of those companies as just Elon Musk. 25:59 I think Facebook, we think of that as Mark Zuckerberg a little bit less, um, but we still do. The thing is, Facebook is in the news every single day. Facebook is introducing a new product every single day. 26:14 Um, and Mark Zuckerberg is one guy. He's one relatively young, first-time CEO guy. And while he did create this thing, is it odd, is it good or bad or neutral that we think of Facebook as Mark Zuckerberg? 26:31 This whole time we were talking about it, instead of saying the Facebook team, we said Mark Zuckerberg. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, I think over the long run that's gonna be a negative. 26:41 I mean, Sheryl, uh, you know, Sandberg- Mm-hmm... everybody knows her just because of, you know, her background, uh, and coming and, you know, adding a lot of operational talent to Facebook. Mm-hmm. 26:51 But at the end of the day, still Mark Zuckerberg is the guy. Um- Yeah... and I don't... I, I think that over the long run could be negative, you know? 27:00 Um, it, it, it's tough for one person to take on all of that- Yeah... media attention and burden, especially for a company as big as Facebook. I mean, if you look at Google, 27:12 you look at Google, they made some great hires, you know, in Eric Schmidt. Mm-hmm. Uh, but today, Larry Page is nowhere to be found. Mm-hmm. I mean, nobody knows where he is. Or, uh, no, is it Larry Page? It's, um... 27:28 One of the co-founders? Yeah, the other one. I actually don't know the other guy. Uh, Sergey, Sergey Brin. I think it, it's- Yeah... one of them has disappeared. We literally don't know what he's doing. 27:37 And again, that's probably because he's one of the figureheads of the biggest companies in the world. Mm-hmm. And it just became too much, and I think over time, you know, Mark Zuckerberg's still really young. 27:48 Who knows if that's gonna happen to him or not, but just having that burden as being the top guy is probably lean- leans towards negativity. Yeah. And I think it leans towards 28:01 crazy situations like we talked about with Elon at the beginning of the show, um, when there's that much attention and that much pressure on one person. 28:08 And while he's not tweeting about 420, he's getting in very public disagreements with the guy he paid $20 billion to. Um, and I think shit just gets messy once that consolidated. Yeah. 28:23 And listen, I mean, Google, they restructured. And eventually, you know, who knows if Facebook's gonna need to do the same thing. Mm-hmm. Amazon surely at one point's gonna do the same thing. 28:36 I'm starting to think of Amazon as Jeff Bezos. I didn't before. Oh, I, I do. Jeff Be- yeah. I think, I think the narrative recently has become more Jeff Bezos, Jeff Bezos. I don't think it used to be like that. 28:50 I don't know obviously how it was operated as a company, but I think more and more he's getting more attention now. Yeah. No, I, I definitely think of them as, uh, just Jeff Bezos. Yeah. 29:03 But yeah, I mean, over time we'll see if Mark Zuckerberg can, you know, take all of that pressure. 29:08 Um, but so far I think he's, you know, through all the scandals, I mean, there's definitely been some, some major, uh, criticism and negative, uh, events for Facebook, but, you know, from the time he started it to now, you know, he's done a great job. 29:22 All right, so that, that's what happened last year with Facebook. Uh, a lot of executives leaving, biggest of them probably being Kevin, the, the founder- For sure... of Instagram. 29:31 Uh, but this, this week, or this past week actually, uh, one of their top... They're, they... 29:36 From what I've been reading and watching, uh, this is a top four executive within Facebook, maybe top three after, um, Mark and, um, why am I forgetting her name? Sheryl. Right. Sheryl Sandberg. Yeah. Yeah. Um, 29:52 so this is a major executive, Chris, Chris Cox. Uh, he was the chief product officer. Uh, so he was overseeing all of their products. He invented the news feed. Uh, he created the news feed. 30:05 And so this was a really influential person within Facebook. Uh- Yeah... and so far all of his work has been around making it very social, uh, making it, 30:13 uh, open to a lot of people, spreading news, uh, and getting, um, you know, all those ad dollars in the door by creating this, this big platform of, um- You know, people connecting, whether they knew the other person they're connecting with or not. 30:28 And this past, uh, you know, month, Facebook has announced that they wanted to pivot towards a much more encrypted and, uh, privacy-focused, uh, platform. Mm-hmm. So, so Chris Cox, uh, didn't, I guess, didn't like that. 30:44 You know, all of his work to date has been around connecting, uh, billions of people around the world, uh, in, in, in large masses, uh, whether that's the newsfeed, um, or taking over, uh, you know, the product of Instagram and WhatsApp and, and you know, all these different apps that, uh, Facebook has acquired over the years and built themselves. 31:05 Uh, so switching to more privacy and encryption is obviously against what he's been building all these years. 31:11 Um, and I actually read that in 2016, him and Mark had had a discussion that, you know, he was kind of feeling burnt out and, you know, was looking for other things to do outside of Facebook. 31:21 But ultimately at that time decided, you know, there's nothing more influential than Facebook. 31:26 Um, so I guess, you know, this was the last straw for him, and he, he decided it was the last, um, you know, his last week at Facebook. Yeah. 31:35 I, uh, I think that, that kind of brings up a, a really good discussion piece because obviously, you know, the, the whole controversy with Facebook recently has just been about that privacy and, um, Mark released a, a big post and, and kind of saying that fundamentally Facebook wanted to change to be focused on, on privacy, which was a huge announcement for, for such a major company. 31:54 And if you're having executives leave because of some type of disagreement or, or philosophical non-alignment around that, I, I think that that just shows how, how rampant the, the, not anti-privacy, but open information culture was that, you know, very high power, high paid technology people are gonna leave a company like Facebook because of a renewed focus on privacy. 32:18 That, that says a lot about what the attitude used to be. Yeah. Yeah, and I, I honestly don't ever see that changing. I mean, even though he's said, like, "We're switching more towards privacy and encryption"- Mm-hmm... 32:29 I just can't imagine that coming true, like that happening. Um, I actually, I actually like what... I think there's a lot of things Facebook needs to do to improve- Yeah... 32:40 and create more privacy, but I don't think going more towards messaging, so, uh, they wanna go more towards end-to-end messaging and connecting all the apps through a, a common messaging platform. Mm-hmm. 32:51 Um, I don't think messaging is, is a good solve for their privacy issues. 32:55 I think what Facebook does best is connect millions and billions of people around the world in, in one place, and if you start creating these small groups between just friends or small communities, I think that almost defeats the purpose of, of what Facebook's really ultimately trying to do, which is, you know, spread transparency and information around the world so people can have access to it in a really social way. 33:19 Yeah. And so once you start getting small groups and encryption going, um, I, I don't see that aligning with what Facebook was built previously on. Yeah. 33:29 I, I agree with that in the sense of, you know, Facebook was built on connecting people. 33:33 I remember when you used to log in, it would have a little graphic of the globe, and it would have the little people icons and little lines that connect them all over the globe. 33:41 So obviously the idea is you're, you're connecting the world that way. 33:45 But I think, I mean, personally with my use, if I wanna know a news story that's going on or I wanna know, um, people's opinions about things, I wanna, I wanna see what's happening on a game or at an event, whatever, I'm gonna go to Twitter, and I, I'm gonna see what, you know, hundreds of thousands of, of people are, are chiming in about things, people I don't even know and will never meet. 34:04 Facebook is, you know, my, my aunts posting pictures and, and stuff like that, and it's, it's more of a, a personal connection. And I think that's just naturally, you know, those two have diverged in that way over time. 34:18 Does it make business sense then for Facebook to, to double down and then focus on those close connections even though that might not be what they were originally intending to do? I'm not sure. 34:29 Well, I think that's yet to be seen. Uh- Yeah... you know, a lot of their ad, ads come from pre-roll and the newsfeed. Yeah. Uh, so pre-roll is, is basically the, the ads that play before a video. 34:41 Um, and so that's where a lot of Facebook's revenue comes from. 34:43 So if they start switching to, to Messenger, uh, and make their focus on privacy and encryption through messaging, then I mean, yeah, the, the stock's been falling because shareholders are, you know, nervous about that obviously. 34:56 Yeah, yeah. I mean, that goes against what they thought they were investing in. Absolutely. Yeah. How do you think this impacts, uh, Instagram? 35:04 'Cause Instagram I think still has that, that discoverability that, that Twitter does as well to, to talk to random people. Um, I actually, 35:15 I think it could work with Instagram better than, you know, the Facebook platform as a whole. I think Instagram's actually a good place for, for this, uh- Okay... 35:24 because I actually don't discover a whole lot on Instagram outside of, um, the people I follow. Mm-hmm. There's just not really a good trending section, 'cause it- Yeah... 35:36 at the end of the day it's just pictures and videos and it... And you were right. When you wanna learn something that's going on that's trending as far as news goes- Mm-hmm... um, Twitter is the place to go. For sure. 35:46 But I think Instagram's just a really great personal app. At least the way I use it at least. You know, I'm sure people use it, uh, differently than I do, but for me, I just follow a really select few people. 35:56 Um, I think I only follow, like, 300 something people, which, uh, compared to some of my other friends, it's a lot less. Yeah. Um, so I, I use Instagram in a really kinda close, close quarters way. 36:07 So I would not mind encryption on that. But as far as Facebook goes, I do consume a lot of news and, um, stuff outside of my immediate family and friends on Facebook. So 36:20 I, I, I do think Instagram's a little bit different story. Yeah, that's interesting. 36:25 I think, I think I use it similarly to how you do, but I know a lot of people, um, and not to generalize, but, but I think girls especially use that discover page, and they can kinda like see trends and, and style and photography and, and fashion, all that kind of stuff. 36:40 Um, I know a lot of people do that. Yeah. It definitely lends itself to that really well. But for me- Mm-hmm... you know, I'm more interested in, you know, business news and technology news. Yeah. 36:49 And a lot of times pictures and videos just, just don't do that, that kind of content justice. So you know, Twitter and, um, you know, Facebook, the, 36:59 the, the Facebook everybody knows, the platform, uh, is where I consume that kind of content. Um- Yeah... but yeah, for me Instagram's just, uh, it's pictures and videos of, of my friends. 37:10 You know, it'll be interesting to see if, if the, the other platforms that Facebook has, you know, Instagram and WhatsApp and- [clears throat]... 37:16 and the handful more are, are impacted by this focus as well, not just Facebook itself. Yeah. Well, and, and they own two of the biggest messaging platforms in the entire world in WhatsApp and Facebook Messenger. Yeah. 37:30 So I'm wondering if they're gonna keep those separate or combine the two. And Instagram Messenger's also huge. 37:37 Uh, they probably have, you know, there's definitely a billion, oh, well over a billion users on Instagram at this point. Mm-hmm. So I'd venture... You know, that's a billion people using that Messenger. Yeah. 37:45 So they have three Messenger platforms that have a billion people on them. Mm-hmm. 37:49 So I'm wondering if they could figure out a way to just connect those into one, and I think that's what he's talking about, where there's an end-to-end messaging encrypted platform. 37:58 And Facebook, you know, News Feed and Facebook platform and Instagram are just kind of add-ons to that horizontal vers- uh, you know, uh, messaging platform. Yeah. 38:09 So this pivot'll be really interesting, if it does end up ha- happening, uh, seeing how it plays out. For sure. So, um, one kind of big question here to put you on the spot. 38:20 The, the, Chris Cox, the, that executive that left Facebook, he was the chief product officer, like you said. 38:26 So obviously there's probably a lot more details about what's to come with the product that we don't know that caused him to leave. 38:34 If you could project out a year and then maybe even to five years, what do you think are, are some massive differences with the Facebook product, um, based on what this announcement was? Yeah. 38:45 Um, so I think there's this overall trend in technology where, um, businesses and content will come to you versus you go out and search for it. Um- Yeah... 38:58 that's actually one of the reasons I was so excited about joining, uh, the company I'm at now, Avail. 39:03 And it's part of this, part of this larger trend where content comes to you, because, um, with messaging apps, with voice, uh, with all these search tools that are greatly enhancing the way we interact with content, I think that's where Facebook's gonna have to move, is, uh, 39:21 you basically create and curate content a- and it just comes to you. So on Messenger, if you have certain companies that you interact with the most, you'll have just a messaging bot in the form of that company. 39:33 Um, so if, if let's say, um, I consume a lot of TechCrunch, then TechCrunch will probably start to create really great, uh, messaging chat bots. Uh, and in that- Yeah... 39:47 I think that's where, uh, Facebook will have to move. As AI improves and as voice improves, um, I think that's where a lot of tech companies are gonna start to move. 39:55 And so what I can see happening is Facebook will create this horizontal messaging platform, and then Instagram and, uh, the Facebook platform where all their content lives will just kind of feed this Messenger 40:10 app wi- with content. Um, and so that's kinda how I see it, is just kind of this, this, uh, messaging platform that kind of str- you know, strings together all of their platforms, and content will come to you. 40:22 So you start following, uh, in a really kind of intimate way your favorite businesses, your favorite people, and, uh, you'll get updates much like you do, uh, with text messages. 40:33 Um, stories, you know, stories are, are very, uh, local to Messenger. Yep. Um, and so I think that's where they're headed, uh, is, is much more of, of content coming to you versus you going out and finding it. 40:46 Um, and I think that's, you know, that, that fits well within a messaging platform where, um, you know, he kind of alluded to Facebook going. Yeah. 40:54 And I, I, I think along those lines, that, that's very similar to what my answer would be, whether it's messaging or you mentioned, uh, you know, text alerts or, or what ha- you know, what, whatever it is. 41:04 I think, um, related to the content coming to you is just the, the seamless integration, uh, of content, and not just from publishers but, but from your friends and your family and, and people that you wanna discover. 41:17 You know, you think back to the early days of Facebook, you had to go onto your desktop computer and log in and, and see what people were saying over the past day since the last time you checked. 41:27 Now everything's on your phone and, and you can get things more up to the minute, um, and it, it's just right there on your app, and, you know, maybe you'll even get a push notification. 41:35 I think just the, the further integration of content, um, is, is where all that's going. 41:41 And so that probably does get easier to make it private as well, um, when it just kinda is seamlessly integrated with other things that you're already interacting with, um, and that, that you ha- you know have that security already. 41:55 Yeah. I mean, technology will always move in a direction where everything becomes more seamless and, and easy. Mm-hmm. 42:00 So, you know, like I said, with, with voice and chat bots, as those improve, that will be where thing, where things head. 42:07 If, if you have a problem with something you bought from Home Depot, you're not gonna go online and search out for Home Depot. Yeah. 42:14 What you're gonna do is you're gonna open up your SMS or you're gonna open up Facebook Messenger, and it knows you probably purchased something from Home Depot, and you can just type in Home Depot on your messaging platform and it'll pull up, uh, a chat conversation with Home Depot. 42:29 You tell them your problem, and if a chat bot's able to answer it right there and then you'll immediately get an answer. If not, it'll immediately connect you to somebody on customer service. 42:38 And so it's just that integration of businesses and brands into your messaging platforms is where I think everything will begin to head. Um, and you know, we talked about Yext on this platform, or on this podcast. 42:51 That's what Yext is enabling, is all these businesses being able to connect with people no matter where they are through voice, um, and through chat bots. 43:00 So I think, I think there's a lot of things, um, pointing towards what Facebook's talking about, messaging and encryption, but at the end of the day Facebook was started for a totally different reason. 43:10 So it'll be interesting to see whether or not they pull that off. 43:15 [upbeat music]