Transcript 0:00 All right. Welcome back to the Middle Tech Podcast Spotlight series. You've got Evan Knowles and Logan Jones here. We're sitting down with Nick of Shadow Ventures. 0:08 Today, uh, we're gonna talk about, uh, Nick's background, where he comes from. He's from Kentucky. We get what we call a boomerang. You left for a little while and came back. Back, just like everyone else. 0:18 So [laughs] we're looking forward to diving into that decision and what you do at Shadow, and talking a bit about PropTech and real estate and kind of the built world, which is where you all focus. 0:27 So thanks for joining and making the trip to Lexington. Yeah. Appreciate you guys having me. Absolutely. What a cool, cool setup. Yeah, this is, this is an awesome space. Shout out to JP. We got the Kentucky. Yeah. 0:34 Shout out to JP for that one. I gotta ask at the top here, so you went to the University of Florida, right? I did. You have a score prediction for our- I don't know where this is going [laughs]... 0:41 for our football team this year? Ooh. [laughs] You know, honestly, I, um... It's been a, you know, it's been a tough, tough last couple years for, for UF. 0:51 Was it last year when we lost for the first time in like 30 years to you guys? That was three years ago, I think. Was that three years ago? Yeah. Okay. That was two, two, three years ago. 0:56 See, I just- That was a, that was a big night in Lexington. I'm showing you how, how poor my knowledge is, but that was a pretty devastating night in my, my life. 1:03 That was like my one trump card over all the Kentucky fans here. [laughs] So f- fun fact, I get, I get asked a lot. 1:10 So born r- born and raised in Louisville, and um, I don't know that you guys know this, but my, both my parents went to UL. Huge Louisville fan. Um, 1:21 went to, uh, had s- my grandparents had season tickets basically s- you know, when I was a little kid, and was a big part of my upbringing was like going to Freedom Hall for basketball games. Um, 1:33 and you know, you know, will forever be a fan for that, for that reason. But I get asked a lot like how I ended up at Florida and, um, one was like the obvious reasons, the weather. 1:43 Um, they actually had a pretty good business program. Um, big s- big school, wanted the full college experience. 1:49 Uh, but the other like subconscious factor was that they always did well against Kentucky, and I was always cheering against Kentucky- Oh, wow... growing up. 1:57 So like I had a positive brand affinity with the school and like, honestly, I don't know that I, uh, I would've ended up at Florida if that, um, if they hadn't just like outperformed Kentucky in- That's hilarious... 2:08 in many different attributes. So- Yeah, that, that- Yeah... crazy win streak that was finally broken. But like in, in, in- Thank God... basketball they were always really competitive. Yeah. 2:15 They, you know, they were a good Gator team and- We're just not. Yeah. Just not when it come to football school. Yeah, yeah. Anyway. 2:20 You know, football was like, uh, the, the easy, uh, the easy, easy way to bully UK when I was growing up was- [laughs] Right on. Totally... yeah, the Florida, the Florida streak. 2:28 [whoosh] Before highlighting our sponsors, we'd just like to state that the views and content shared on this platform do not necessarily reflect those of our show sponsors. 2:36 Middle Tech is presented by KY Innovation, the Kentucky Cabinet for Economic Development's Office of Entrepreneurship. 2:42 KY Innovation exists to support and develop Kentucky's startup ecosystem, and we are proud to be supported by an organization whose mission aligns so closely with ours. 2:51 If you're a founder building in Kentucky, you need to check out the resources that KY Innovation has to offer. You can find more information by clicking the link in our show notes or going to kyinnovation.com. 3:02 Middle Tech is sponsored by Bolt Marketing. Take your website to the next level with a website that's built to work. 3:07 At Bolt Marketing, they're revolutionizing websites for small businesses that are affordable, customizable, and hassle-free. 3:14 Whether you have a construction company, a boutique clothing store, or you own a hot yoga studio, they have options for you. 3:19 Click the link in our show notes to explore their marketing options that can transform your marketing and grow your business. 3:25 And as a personal note, Bolt Marketing built our website and they were awesome to work with throughout the entire process. We highly recommend working with them. Yeah. 3:32 Well, let's kick off by talking a little bit about your background. So you mentioned you went to Florida. Let's kind of pick it up after you graduated. What did you get into? And then let's take that into- Yeah, yeah... 3:41 Shadow Ventures. Yeah, so a little bit of a, a circuitous, circuitous background I th- which I think is like probably true for a lot of VCs. 3:51 Um, I actually studied finance in s- uh, finance in school and went to work, um, for a bank post, uh, post my UF experience. I worked, um, for Raymond James based in St. Pete/Tampa area. Um, and I was essentially... 4:05 I was telling this, uh, story to an investor yesterday. I was essentially a 22-year-old kid, um, post-2008 when the regulatory environment was pretty intense, um, calling financial advisors. 4:18 I worked on the financial service side, um, in compliance and was kinda analyzing. My job was to analyze their trades and to flag them when something was, uh, when their behavior was not appropriate. 4:31 Basically, when they were turning over mutual funds quickly, um, to generate fees, when they were making, uh, trades that were not suitable for the risk preferences with, um, for, for, s- uh, specific clients. 4:44 And it was an interesting time because none of that had been scrutinized, like over the course of the previous probably couple decades. 4:52 And so it was the first time that these like really successful financial people were getting told like, "Hey, you can't do that anymore," like how they generated a lot of income over the years. 5:01 Um, and I was a 20-year-old kid scared shitless to like pick up the phone and tell this really successful person like, "Hey, you need to listen to me. You can't do this or you're gonna get fired." Um, and so [lip smack] 5:13 was a really-- I mean, it was a really challenging job as you, as you can imagine. Um, but I, I realized early on I wasn't going to be great at, um, 5:25 I wasn't going to be great at, uh, at crunching numbers on a s- on a spreadsheet and looking at dashboards and, and, and being a true like day-to-day financial analyst. Um, I was good at going deep in certain topics. 5:38 Like, I liked the equity research component when I got exposed to it. Um, that's a little bit of, you know, a little bit of, of a part of the job now. Um, but I knew that I needed something. 5:49 I liked finance, but I needed something a little bit more qualitative, um, something more creative that, um, was probably more on the business operating and, and, um, and even the, the revenue generation side was exciting to me. 6:02 [lip smack] Um- And both of my parents and my dad is a home builder. 6:07 Um, I grew up on a job site more or less like, you know, my first jobs are always cleaning his, his job sites up and working with the subs and all of that. 6:14 And, um, I ended up leaving the, the bank after a couple years and, um, went to work for the family business and cut my teeth in as an adult in construction. And 6:26 what I learned, um, or what I observed when I went back to work for the business was there is literally zero technology being used on these job sites. And I was working on residential jobs here in Kentucky. 6:38 I mean, my dad's in Louisville, right? So, you know, um, he was building mostly high-end, uh, built to suit homes. 6:45 It wasn't like, you know, the, the Pulte Home factory or the, the Lennar or the Toll Brothers factory where like efficiency was actually really important. Uh, he was building more custom high-end homes. 6:55 So a little bit of a different thing, but I saw enough, like I, I knew there's something, there's something wrong with, uh, the adoption in construction specifically. 7:06 And so I kinda became the quasi-innovation guy, and I wasn't a very technical person at the time. And, um, you know, I, I-- it is something that I, I still think is not like being technical is not my top skill set. 7:20 Um, but I became interested enough to, to wanna learn about technology and, uh, specifically the behavioral patterns of like, why, why was this S-curve moving so slow in terms of adoption? Um, and so that path 7:37 led me to finding a resource based in Chicago. [lip smack] It's called Built Worlds, and Built Worlds was essentially a new age media company that was devoted to like finding that exact answer. 7:50 Like how do we educate the real estate and construction industries in particular, and get them to be more willing, um, get them to view technology as a less friction-filled cost, um, 8:07 cost-filled endeavor that actually could give them a meaningful competitive advantage in their business. And that was because, because that was, that was how I was using tech for my, for my dad. 8:17 I was using it to help our selling process, help back office efficiency. 8:22 Um, I mean, I'm talking like even basic stuff at the time, like really bas-basic software, but at first it was like, let's just get stuff in spreadsheets 'cause like this stuff exists on pen and paper, and like I have no way of... 8:33 If I'm pricing a project, I have no way of like drawing from past experiences 'cause I don't-- I'm not sifting through like folders, um, to look for this data. Like, and by the way, like is that data even accurate? 8:43 Like this is like one subcontractor's perspective, um, on, on pricing. So like, you know, it's a very relationship-driven business. You-- There's a lot of trust involved. 8:53 And the interesting thing about adding tech is like you actually start to get really objective feedback on may-maybe things that you weren't paying attention to before when you're looking at a full dashboard of your costs, your est- you know, your estimated, um, project expenses, and then ultimately what the revenue would be. 9:09 So it was a time, it was a moment in time in the construction space where like that actually, that stuff really mattered because things weren't moving in volume. 9:17 So like your one or two projects that you had going for, you know, a custom builder, um, per year or, you know, a five to 10, 10, 10 to 15, those projects and their profitability really mattered. 9:31 And people, people were coming off of an experience where they had to eat, um, lots that they owned and sell them for half the price that they bought them. 9:39 And like, so, uh, no one's, the, the, they were not-- their pockets were not lined with cash. Um, so it was a... Looking back, it was a, um, it was a time, like that timing really mattered for me to go down that journey. 9:54 Um, but n- long story short, I, I ended up at, uh, at Built Worlds, um, talking with the founder of the company, who was also a son of a construction firm, and really appreciate his vision. 10:07 It was like, let's educate this market on why tech is fantastic and like bring them into the 21st century, and that was kinda my whole mission. 10:14 So I went to help him out and, uh, joined the company to lead sales and marketing. Um, primarily a marketing-focused gig. I had to enter the startup world with, you know, a, a fo- a focus. 10:25 Um, I didn't have a ton of experience then, but, um, I had proven that I could figure out the marketing stuff, um, and eventually grew to like, yeah, w- um, we did research content, kinda owned that. 10:36 That was within my camp. Um, journalistic content events, uh, we monetized via events, so programming those events out and bringing in speakers. Um, 10:46 and so I met, uh, bringing this back to Shadow Ventures, I met my now partner, KP Reddy, uh, who's the founder of Shadow Ventures. 10:55 He, um, was the first keynote at our venture-oriented conference at Built Worlds, and he just spoke on the topic of serial entrepreneurship and interesting, um, startups within the, uh, the, the built environment, um, landscape. 11:08 And, um, we can, you know, dig into our thesis a little bit if you want, um, given that that's like a key component to what we're doing at, at the- Yeah...Venture Capital firm. Yeah. Yeah. 11:18 No, you all have definitely focused heavily on prop tech, just real estate in general, but especially the built world. Um, and it's, it's definitely a fascinating space. 11:27 You know, as somebody that's been building in prop tech, just like it sounds like construction, you know, it's heavily lagging as far as technology adoption for a lot of reasons. Very fragmented, um, demographics. 11:38 You know, there's a lot of things that affect, you know, innovation adoption within the industry. So, you know, I imagine that's a unique thesis. There's definitely a lot of niche, not-- I wouldn't say a lot. 11:47 There's definitely niche VCs within the prop tech and, and kinda software space for residential, but you guys are focused, um, more heavily on just the built environment, correct? So yeah, so dive into that thesis. Yeah. 12:01 So the built environment, um For u- for us, that definition is anything that's affecting, um, the value chain in designing, constructing, and then maintaining the world's physical infrastructure. 12:14 So buildings, um, primary- through the lens of primarily buildings. 12:18 Um, but also physical infrastructure, bridges, roads, um, s- more civil-oriented things, even along the lines of energy, utilities, air, um, you know, air, air- airport, uh, rail. Those are things that we touch, too. 12:29 But, um, technologies that are supporting, um, the, the designing and, and building, uh, primarily of, uh, of, of all those markets is kinda what we look at. 12:40 Um, so it ends up being-- Like, a lot of people think we're sector-focused. Like, we're not just a construction tech VC. We're not just a pure pro- pure play proptech VC. 12:47 And those are, you know, uh, there's a lot of firms that focus just on those markets. 12:52 Um, so we view ourselves as thematically focused, which is, you know, the theme of, um, how do we support better buildings and, you know, a better, a better phy-physical environment, um, for humans across the world? 13:04 So it's definitely a big- a bigger ambitious market. And, you know, r- like, rough scale on that market is it's, like, represents 20% of GDP, um, per year. 13:14 It's, like, production for those markets, so, uh, pretty massive, uh, footprint and obviously really critical. Um, like, people, uh, these are the places that we live, work, and play in. 13:25 Um, if these things aren't built correctly, obviously there's, there's a lot of risk. Um, there's been bridge collapses we've seen. There's been, um, [lips smack] 13:33 um, building collapses from, you know, poor structural engineering and, uh, I think everyone knows the risk of not building correctly. 13:42 And so, um, the reality is that market, because of the risk involved, because of the size and scope of, and the cost of these projects, it's a really, really nuanced investment landscape. Because the startup, um, 13:58 building technology for these industries, it's mission critical technology, right? 14:03 It's not like, hey, if we mess up, you know, an, uh, a number in a, in a, in a, in a SaaS, you know, CRM, um, you know, mess up our reporting for a week, that's not super critical. Like, we can fix that. 14:16 It's a bug in the software. If we mess up the, uh, the math on a structural grade, um, skyscraper, people, a lot of people die. So, um, there's not as much... There's like a li- like, we have a, a much heavier MVP, 14:30 um, building lift when you're a founder in our, our space. Um, and Evan, you're a founder in, in the proptech space. I think you kinda know, um, a little bit of what I'm referring to. 14:43 Um, but the, the seriousness of, like, these are people's homes, these are people's offices, uh, this, these are the roads that we drive on, you know, and trust that we're gonna be able to make it home safely. 14:52 And, um, so anyway, I just wanna convey the size and the importance of the market. And, um, relatively speaking, there's not a ton of oth- other VCs out there that are covering this, this beat, if you will, um, 15:06 in the way that we are. And we're typically, uh, we like to, uh, be-- we like to play in deeper, uh, in deeper technology. Like, we've done pure play software, um, but we've also done hardware. 15:18 We've done a couple robotics deals. Um, we're, you know, we're-- we've done a couple material science deals and, uh, we're trying to solve, like, really hard problems and, uh, like, my description kind of alludes to why. 15:29 Um, [lips smack] but that's a little bit of the focus is, like, we wanna be pure play technology VC and, um, be the s- be the specialist that, hey, if you're a founder building in this market, like, I need this guy on my cap table, um, this team on my cap table, because these guys know the market. 15:43 They can get me customers. 15:45 They know that they, they're gonna, they're gonna f- they're gonna save me a lot of time if I'm building a product in this space, and I, I, uh, like, mistakes I might make along the way, um, not only from a go-to-market perspective, but also, like, a technical architecture and product perspective, too. 15:58 Um, 'cause there's a lot of idiosyncrasies with building- Yeah... stuff in the market. Especially, you know, I, I ran into all of that, you know, with Simba. 16:05 It's, proptech, uh, is not necessarily a space, and I'm sure the built world is exactly the same. It's not necessarily a space you can come in and, you know, barge your way in with a product, you know? Yeah. 16:15 It doesn't matter how innovative it is, there's a lot of gatekeepers within, I'm sure, both industries because it's just such a, like you said, mission critical. 16:21 And when things are mission critical, there's a lot of approvals and hoops to jump through in order to get to market. 16:27 And so that, that's one thing that, you know, I've learned that I'm sure, you know, looking back, uh, would've liked to have more. 16:34 You know, we, we brought in consultants, but probably would've liked to have more people on the cap table that, you know, had a very vested interest from way earlier on in our life cycle to help us through those things. 16:44 Um, but where are you all at with the fund? So how many funds have you raised and, and kinda what's the team? We're on our second fund at, at, um, [lips smack] 16:52 senior associate level and, and grew to be a partner in this fund. So, um, in, in our second fund, and so that, that's, uh, that's been an exciting thing to kinda make that transition into a GP role in the fund. Um, 17:04 but I think, you know, in terms of where we're at, [lips smack] um, we've deployed, um, just over $22 million in capital since 2019. Um, started making investments then. 17:14 Our most notable investment is a 3D-printed housing company in Austin called Icon. 17:20 Um, th- they were valued in 2022 at over two-- Like, we're just around the $2 billion mark and- I think I saw them at a conference with a live demo at a, it was an Autodesk conference. It was pretty cool. 17:30 It was a, a similar technology, but they were 3D printing a home with the concrete going around. Yeah, that's it. Yeah. So yeah, they, they 3D print homes and, um, they've had, uh, they've had a ton of success. 17:41 I think, like, it's a, it's a really good-- If you're looking for, like, an example of what we do and the types of deals that get us excited, um, Icon's a perfect example. Like, really ambitious, uh, idea. 17:52 I mean, the original thesis was, like, we wanna build a home for half the time and for, uh, in half the time for half the cost. 17:59 And like, so s- essentially solving a lot of the affordable housing, um, issues was the original thesis and, um- But the time it takes to build, um, is also a, a, a, you know, huge downside to, uh, to, to housing. 18:14 And so, like the ability to 3D print concrete and, and get that, get that thing up a lot faster. 18:19 Um, they've had to work on a lot of the, uh, the permitting aspects and code requirements, uh, more recently, and they've been successful in, um, in, in, in getting some of those over the line. 18:29 So yeah, we're, um, we're super bullish on, on, on them. And I think a lot of other... 18:34 Like, housing is definitely, um, bringing more housing to the world is definitely a key mission and a, and a, an investment bucket that we look at. It's, um, 18:42 you know, it's definitely a b- a big thematic focus is how do we, um, how do we fix a lot of the... Like, I think the estimation is 3 billion people will be without housing in 2030. 18:54 So, like there's the affordable housing element, and then there's like, um, even more in your world, the, uh, you know, the, the, the increased, uh, cost, uh, and c- cost of living and, and owning a home. 19:07 Um, we've seen a lot of different opportunities to, like start building equity earlier and, and, uh, uh, f- even for, for renters, like those are, you know, some interesting concepts. 19:17 But I think breaking down the whole problem set of like what is working in housing globally here in the US, what's not working, um, when you start actually looking at that picture, it's not like the grant-- It's not the most ex- exciting, and it's a pretty bleak, uh, scenario for a lot of people who aspire to be homeowners. 19:34 Yep. And so, like that would be a funding, um, area for us is trying to fix some of those problems. 19:40 I am curious, so kinda going back to the building in the real world, and the stakes are, are very high when you're building a company that's, you know, building a house that people are living in, for example, or building a bridge, whatever it is. 19:53 Um, I'm curious how that changes how you guys invest your money, do due diligence, support the entrepreneurs that are building the companies. 20:00 Can you speak to that a little bit in terms of, you know, how are you supporting the companies that are actually you're, you're getting the money to? Yeah. Well, I think, 20:10 you know, there's a couple schools of thought in venture, [lip smack] um, that as a founder, if, you know, if any founders are listening here, um, I think it's important, uh, 20:19 to, to interview your VCs for this and even, you know, some of the early investors, if they're angels on the cap table, um, wanting to understand their, their take on this. 20:28 And so, so one of the beliefs is that VCs shouldn't interfere much with investing and like you're betting on the founder, and they need to f- be able to figure it out, and like you kinda wanna get out of their way. Um, 20:42 the other theory is like if a founder needs help, um, the VC should be able to step in and provide and assist, um, in an advisory capacity. Our view even extends further than that. 20:54 Like, we wanna be an extension of the team. Uh, like we wanna be the f- like one of the first calls if something goes wrong in the business and they don't know who else... 21:02 Like found- being a founder can be lonely, and like it's tough to, if you, if you don't have an equal co-founder, um, which is a scenario that we see a lot, like who do you call? 21:12 Um, so troubleshooting those issues, but, but almost too from like a pure, pure extension of the team. 21:18 We wanna help them through the biggest hurdles, emo- emotional, tactical, s- you know, strategic, uh, whatever it could be on a day-to-day basis, like we're definitely, um, we're definitely, uh, there in that camp. 21:30 Like I was just t- I-- One of the reasons I was a couple minutes late, I was talking to a founder in the car about, um, a round that they're putting together, and there were just like a couple things we saw and, and docs that were sent over that were just like, "Hey, here's, 21:43 here's some basic ways to think about this that, um, I think you should revise in your new series of documents, because I wouldn't be excited about this as, as an investor." 21:53 So like the basic financial advice, um, but also, you know, more broadly in terms of how we help after, like immediately post-investment. So our model, because we're thematically focused, 22:05 most of our investors probably have some skin in the game in our markets, right? So, um, 22:12 they're real estate developers, they're real estate owners, they're construction firms, they're, uh, they're engineering, uh, en- engineering services companies, um, uh, a few, few architects. 22:23 Um, and the goal is, hey, we've, we've built a pretty large strategic limited partner base for our fund. 22:31 Um, I think like we're probably 70 to 80%, uh, of, of, uh, funds raised at this point are from those types of people, uh, and the, and those companies direct- directly investing off their balance sheet. 22:41 And they're, they're signing up to pilot the companies we're investing in. And like we kinda get that implicit agreement when they work with us as like, "Hey, 22:50 you know, the- there's a, there's like a little bit of a two-way street here." Um, they're a limited partner. They can kinda do what they want, but it's an important part of our process. 22:58 Like we are trying to catalyze, uh, technology adoption in the space. Like our mission is much, is much bigger than just blindly writing checks and hoping for the best, um, being passive with it. 23:08 Like we, we, we know how valuable it is to get early customer agreements if you're a new founder. And so whether that agreement is six or seven figures, it's ideal. 23:18 If it's, you know, if it's, if it's five or six figures just to start, it's still a really credible logo. 23:24 Um, these are large companies that are investing with us, a lot of brand, um, uh, you know, a lot, lot of brand association with and social proof with those logos. 23:33 And so if we can help with that respect of like, hey, this has been verified and validated by credible companies, and then if they like the pilot experience, and assuming things go well, and we try to interface there and make sure that expectations are set and they're delivering on the deadlines and all that, um, then, you know, it's, it leads to a six or seven-figure deal, and that is transformative moving into the next financing round, right? 23:57 Like it, that can essentially make or break the business, and oftentimes it's one or two companies moving forward on those bigger early deals, um, that actually make all the difference. Like we had a 24:08 We had a c- a company in the portfolio, um, land a, uh, a s- a seven-figure deal in the last, like, you know. 24:16 It was their, it was basically their first big deal and it happened in the la- in the last month, and it's completely transformative for their business. Like, changes the outlook significantly. 24:25 And it's one of those things where in, in our world, you can kinda go from zero to one in that respect, where it's like if you're selling a product that, that, that's that expensive, it's like, again, a mission critical product, B2B-oriented product, enterprise sale, 24:40 um, it takes a while. Like, it takes a second to build up to that place, and you can get really discouraged when you don't see traction. 24:48 Um, so we're kind of there interfering, you know, p- playing interference and helping them kinda navigate, um, those early sales, the timelines for those sales, helping sell when we can. 24:58 Um, so it's much broader than just like, hey, basic investment advice and yeah, passive. Yeah. 25:03 I love that model 'cause, uh, you know, especially as a early stage startup, figuring out distribution and sales, just from my experience working at a startup, that's one of the most difficult things to do. 25:13 And not only that, but find incredible logos that are gonna [chuckles] be able to really transform the business like that. That is a really cool model to say, "Okay, we're gonna take money from them that are... 25:21 They're wanting to invest in innovation- Yeah... and also sign o- sign on for saying, 'Okay, we're gonna try out and pilot some of these- Sure... people you're investing in.'" 25:27 I think that's an awesome way to, uh, to be putting money into those companies. 25:31 Well, off the back of that, you know, one of the problems that I've read about and, and have seen play out in proptech and is if you get strategics involved too early, um, of course, it's great to have the revenue and large deals. 25:45 Uh, depending on who the strategic is, it could narrow TAM potentially. How have you guys av- avoided, you know, misaligned, um, either incentives by having strategics- Yeah... 25:57 and being a middleman for those strategics and investing in companies? That's a common worry within middle tech is, or not middle tech, within proptech, is, you know, there's... 26:06 I'm sure in the build world it's different, but I'm sure you can run into that scenario as well. Yeah. But how do you all think about that? No, it's totally real. Um, the answer is we're the exact, 26:14 we are the exact answer to those strategic problems. What I figured, yep. They inve- the i- the flow is an L- an LP is a strategic firm. Um, large corporate, usually a brand name. 26:26 They invest in our fund, and no one knows they're invested in our fund outside of the founders, right? If that L- same LP went direct- Yeah... to your point- They'd be on their cap table... 26:38 and you see a huge real estate name or you see a huge construction name and you're selling to their competitors- Yeah... that are directly competitive and, and with them and hate them, 26:48 and, or even they play nicely, but, like, the idea of, you know, someone having the technol- like, startup technology venture upside 26:59 that, you know, uh, they put a couple million bucks in and they can get a billion dollar return, um, or higher in the event of a, of a true outlier, like, that's, that should be scary to a competitive corporate. Yeah. 27:11 Um, and so what you're speaking to, I think, is a really important dynamic, um, for strategic inve- I mean, strategic investors know, n- you know, they, they, they're aware of that. 27:23 Um, and C- CVC is corporate venture capital, like, this is something they've always dealt with, is it's like it can be difficult to get access to, to the best deals, um, because of that dynamic. Because... 27:35 And we, and we've seen this firsthand, by the way. Like, we've been co-investors with pure strategic, um, like direct on the cap table, like, "Hey, I know your name." 27:44 Every potential new investor, uh, or customer might be aware that you're a huge investor, and customers get skittish when they, when they learn about it. It's real. Yeah. 27:54 Um, and I'm not saying that it can't work and the, and it's, and it's not a model that, um, shouldn't be pursued, but I think more so the, the thought here for founders would be like be aware of the risks because I think a lot of founders see, you know, whatever dollar signs that they would be willing to invest, and they, they think it's like a, you know, no-brainer. 28:15 They're pretty low maintenance. Like, there's positive reasons to working with the strategics. 28:20 Um, and one of the, one of the ways that strategics get around that potential dilemma is they, like, are very hands-off and they're like the l- the lowest maintenance investor that you'll see. Um, 28:31 and they're kinda saying like, "Hey, we're not gonna look at data, information." Um, like, they try to downplay their, their entire invol- involvement. Well, we all know, like, they're actually involved. Yeah. Yeah. 28:41 But, um, I think the strategic investing... 28:44 Like, so anyway, our, part of our, our value to strategic investors who want to get exposed to venture capital, who want to get ex- Uh, the, and the main reason they're, they're excited to get exposed and they would wanna set up a CVC or wanna work with Shadow Ventures is because they want to learn. 29:03 They're not looking, uh, like, they're trying to feed the core business. They're not looking to make a new profit center with their venture capital endeavor. 29:11 There's been like one-- I mean, I was talking to, uh, my partner KP about this. There's been like one successful CVC in the history of the business. Like, that tells you all you need to know. 29:19 And they're, and they're still around. Yeah. Because it is, it can be incredibly valuable to a multi-billion dollar business to learn one strategic insight 29:29 about one particular company or apply one piece of knowledge that you learn from a, a, a f- a, a strategic category that was created early, 29:38 and take off w- and take off with that knowledge and, and use it to your advantage. Yeah. JLL is one that comes to mind- Yeah... um, in that, in that industry. 29:45 And, and I know you were talking about themes earlier and af- affordable housing. You know, I know that climate's another one. Um, so last question here kind of on, on Shadow and your specific strategy. 29:56 You know, how do you think about climate investing? 29:58 'Cause that's one, uh, very important topic to discuss is, you know, a, a startup environment is how do we solve these big problems, especially as we start to see more and more events and, you know, disasters happen and the frequency is... 30:13 becoming more and more, um, apparent. But also, unfortunately, uh, it's been politicized, and people are using data to misinform people. 30:25 Um, how, how do you guys navigate that space and make sure that you're making intelligent investments that, you know, aren't, whether good or bad, politicized? Yeah. Um, 30:37 I think that exact-- So I, the way that I personally, um, and so I'll, I'll caveat this. These are, like, my personal opinions and not the opinions of, um, the company. Yeah. [laughs] Um, 30:49 but my personal opinion is, like, everything you just described in that dynamic of, like, the politiza- politization of carbon and climate and, you know, whether or not, like, wanna have the debate of, like, how important is some of the carbon data that's being, being reported, how, um, how mission-critical is, like, reducing carbon. 31:09 Like, that's a actual conversation people are having. Um, it's an emotional conversation, 31:17 and so, like, the way that I see, view this as an investor is, like, there's dislocation there because it's an emotional conversation. No one's thinking clearly. 31:25 And so, like, when you actually-- Like, so, so the answer is to be objective and scientific about it and to form your own opinions and to not be emotional about the stance, um, that you're investing in. 31:38 And I'll, I'll, I'll share a personal experience. I've kinda gone... I've seen both sides, right? 31:44 Like you, you allude to, to, you know, some of the f- the carbon fraud and accounting fraud that occurs and the greenwashing and all that. That's real. Like, that happens. 31:53 There's also, like, really practical solutions that are, like, undoubtedly good for the environment, um, on a, you know, um, from an, a, like a, a, a 32:03 climate, a climate tech perspective, and, like, one of those would be, like, material science, right? Building with better materials that are less carbon-intensive, um, is, like, a very active way to, 32:14 um, invest and, uh, in-invest, in-invest in, in, in more, you know, in more green, uh, in more green technology if you're a, if you're a building owner, um, uh, or if you're a developer. And, 32:28 and so that would be what's called embo- you know, embodied, uh, embodied carbon. Embodied, it's embodied into the building. And so you look at that compared to carbon accounting tools. 32:38 What's a better way to, like, actually impact the environment? And it's like, well, um, I think it's, the answer's pretty obvious. 32:45 But that, um, the way that I-- The thing that I get excited about with that particular topic is the emotional, um, variance with it, and I know people will miss some good opportunities because it is, uh, it is an emotional topic. 33:00 And I think pe- You know, and, like, there, there are a lot of climate tech funds out there, and I think they'll get excited about... 33:04 There's a potential they get excited about things that aren't actually having a real impact. Yeah. Um, and I wanna, with our thesis, I wanna be really grounded in reality 33:15 and data on what is actually going to move the needle. Um, and I think, again, for us, it's like the, you know, material science and embodied carbon, and then we have a couple investments that, um, 33:28 would actually help, uh, buildings control, um, their, their energy e-expenditures. If, you know, for instance, you're working with a really old building, objectively, like, fact, old buildings are terrible with- Yeah... 33:43 energy efficiency. Like, you're wasting a ton of energy. And so, um, anyone who's ever lived in an old building or worked in one or, like, looked at the cost of them, like, uh, it's expensive in the winter. 33:53 It's expensive, you know, when AC's blasting, and it's expensive when you're running your boiler. Um, and so if there's a way to, um, modernize that, that already existing building, like, I think 34:07 70% of the existing building stock will, um, will need retrofitting in the next 10, 10 years. One of the ways that a lot of people will look to retrofit is electrification and, 34:19 um, and even, you know, putting electrification as, like, a s- a potential solution aside, how can I just, like, reduce my energy cost, and how can I make this building more comfortable for my residents? 34:31 Um, old buildings are just also, there's a lot of volatility with the temperature, and it's like, you know, it can be really uncomfortable in the summer and uncomfortable in the winter to live in. 34:39 So, um, improving the overall customer experience is also a, a thing. But yeah, um, I'm excited about climate. 34:47 I think there's a lot of practical applications out there, but I also, from an investment perspective, I'm, like, licking my chops because I know people are gonna miss it 'cause they're gonna get emotional about it. 34:56 Yeah. No, we definitely have experienced the state of Kentucky has, you know, lack of objective data and, you know, making decisions high on em- on emotions with, you know, AppHarvest. 35:05 I think that that was a clear example of, you know, went to market with a very emotional call to action and food sustainability and food, um, security and, you know, all of the climate disasters and lack of water, and I think there's a lot of emotion attached to that. 35:20 And so when they went to market, that objective data wasn't, wasn't there, and so by the time they IPO'd and did the SPAC, you know, a lot of people were left holding the bag. 35:27 So I think, you know, we acutely feel, you know, the, the climate side of the investment landscape right now and kinda what that's been going through and watching that. 35:34 Um, but speaking of Kentucky, you know, you're here in Kentucky. We mentioned at the beginning you're a boomerang. Um, what brought you back to Kentucky? 35:41 Talk about that, and then how have you felt now that you're back about the startup ecosystem as much as you've been able to get involved? Yeah. I'll drink, I'll take a sip of my, uh, hillbilly tea while I answer that. 35:51 [laughs] I thought that was kombucha maybe is-- Or is that, is that what it is? Um, it's actually a very s- uh, it's a special concoction. It's not what, what most people think. It's not bourbon. Not moonshine? 35:59 Not bourbon or moonshine? Um, not moonshine or bourbon. [laughs] Um, it's, uh, actually just a ton of, ton of herbs. Um, but yeah, I call it my hillbi- hillbilly tea. Um, 36:09 yeah, so to answer, so, um, Evan, your question, you wanna get into more specifically what I think about the landscape in Kentucky? Well, yeah. What brought you back, and then so far- Yeah... 36:18 you know, impressions now that you're back of, of what's happening here. Yeah. Um- What brought me back was wanting to be closer to family. Um, that was the primary decision. 36:28 I have a, um, a baby now that I'm responsible for, so that changes your priorities a bit, um, definitely more than I anticipated. I was-- Again, I was in Chicago. 36:39 Lived abroad for a little while, um, when I was younger, and, uh, yeah, ended up in Chicago and, um, then most recently in Boulder during... I was there for the pandemic and thought I would be there longer. 36:50 But, um, yeah, after having a baby, your priorities change and you realize the value of grandparents and all those things. But hon-but honestly, like, more specifically 37:00 why we landed here, 'cause, you know, her parents are not here, um, Kentucky has a lot to offer. 37:06 It's like a really-- I, I think it's a, it's a great place to live if you value the things that Kentucky brings, which in, in my opinion, like the, the investment case for Kentucky, if you will, is, um, high affordability, really friendly people, 37:23 great community, accessibility. It's not overpopulated. If you like your space, if you like land, if you like calmness, um, I think maybe it's some of the cheapest land in the country, like, exists in the state. Um, 37:39 and you know, I obviously grew up here. You get used to the-- When you get used to the Southern pace, um, it's something I think you aspire to get back to. Like, I've lived in faster pace environments than, uh, 37:56 than probably I was, like, uh, than, than I was bred to, to live in, if you will. And I think, like, you've-- Like, there's a reason you find your way back. 38:04 Like, it, it, uh, it's the fam-family stuff aside, there is, like, an attractiveness to, you know, a slower pace. And you know, I-I'll, I'll say this from, like, a, from a, from an ambitious person perspective. 38:17 So I've always viewed myself... Whether, whether I am or not, I've always viewed myself as an ambitious person. Um, I've chased things. I work in a pretty, um, ambitious industry in venture capital. 38:29 Uh, we have big goals at our firm. I have big goals for myself. And one of the questions I had to ask myself was, like, "Does Kentuck- can Kentucky, um, supply me with the things I need for my ambition?" 38:42 And I don't think I-- Earlier in my life, I think the answer would've been no. Um, 38:49 and honestly, there's been a couple things that have changed in the world that I think have enabled, uh, some of, some of those answers to be a yes for me now, which is like, you know, remote work is now, uh, a much, um, more acceptable thing. 39:02 Um, talent recruiting. So, like, when we look to grow our firm, for instance, uh, when we look to make investments, like, we can look globally. We don't, like, we don't have to be confined to a geography. 39:14 And I actually think it's like, from a venture perspective, it's pretty limiting to, um, 39:19 you know, to be just looking at a particular geography, and I think that's why you're seeing, like, some of the, uh, some other big tech communities blow up. 39:26 And, uh, you know, Miami is, like, the obvious, um, place where I think there's been a lot of growth. Austin. Um, but one place, adjacent place, like, pulling this back to Kentucky is, is Nashville. 39:38 So, like, Nashville is like-- has always been, I think, especially over the last decade, a model for growth for, um, for Louisville and, uh, I think any big city in Kentucky. Um, and I'm not saying we have to go there. 39:52 Like, there's some of the attributes that I mentioned about Kentucky that I think are great, and maybe some people don't want a overly, an overly populated city with ri- you know, egregious hou- uh, you know, housing expenses. 40:03 But I don't know. I, I w- I, I want, I want more growth in the state, like I think a lot of us do. And, uh, I think that, 40:12 again, there's been an enablement with the new, with new working trends, with hybrid work, remote work, um, that a- is gonna allow a lot 40:21 more people, um, ambitious people to live in Kentucky than previously they would've been able to capture. So, like, a larger market size, uh, for the city of Louisville and the state, um, Louisville and Lexington. And 40:33 so I, I think, you know, observation in terms of my... You know, back to what I was saying about the ambition, um, I think that culturally, 40:48 um, you have to work to find really ambitious people in Kentucky. It's... They're not-- There are a lot of hardworking people, but people who really want to... 40:57 Like, you know, in the technology world, we're looking to build monopolies. I'm looking to fund monopolies. We're looking to real- build a really large venture firm and, um, you know, these... 41:06 We're looking to fund billion-dollar, $10 billion businesses. And, like, to have the type of person that is chasing that, uh, 41:14 usually historically you'll find that in the Bay Area or New York or, you know, some of your ty-type A-oriented cities where, like, where ambitious- uh, ambition's in the water. 41:23 Um, so that was a fear of mine moving back, and I don't think I have... Uh, I think being integrated into the tech community here, I, I don't think I have that fear as much anymore. 41:33 Um, there are-- It's not, uh, like you ha- you have to look a little bit, but it's not hard to find. Like, you can network into circles of ambitious people. 41:41 And, like, I met a founder today based in Louisville, and I was, like, really impressed. I, um, I, I have relatively low expectations and, uh, generally speaking and, um, was like, "Wow, this guy's 41:54 built, he's built a great business." Uh, really ambitious guy, fantastic background. He used to live in a, you know, a major city in the US, and is, like, setting up his company here. Has over 40 people now. 42:04 Um, and so seeing, you know, some of that, the, the traction of, like, the... 42:09 And, and, you know, for, for founders to wanna actually set up shop here and build, um, really ambitious companies here has, like, quelled that fear for me, and I'm definitely optimistic about, um, 42:22 the reason for more talent to wanna end up here. And That we have a good model to follow with, uh, with, with Nashville, for instance. 42:30 Like, um, there were a couple, I think in the last month, venture firms that announced they were setting up offices in Nashville, like large venture firms. Um, and the question is why? 42:39 It's like, well, it's an at- it's now an attractive place to live. 42:43 Um, and the ambitious-- Uh, there's, there's enough talent locally, um, for them to support opening offices in the, in the area, not just funding companies in the area. Their partners wanna live there. 42:53 Their founders wanna live there. So, um, yeah, I think there's, like, a lot of reason to be excited. Yeah, I think I really relate to what you're saying about the ambition thing. 43:03 It is-- Y- it's much more intentional to go out and find it. 43:07 It's definitely there, and I think the reason I love living here and the reason I have a lot of conviction to living here now is largely through Middle Tech and working at a startup myself and trying to create, you know, the media and the stories and the connections in the community around people that value that ambition. 43:26 And I mean, going back, we've, we've been doing this podcast for four years now. 43:30 Being able to kinda aggregate all those stories I think means a lot to me to be able to, to go to somebody who might be a boomerang who had those same kind of thoughts- Mm-hmm... 43:39 or who is thinking about moving here and has not lived here. 43:42 You know, I think it's one of those things that's like you reach a critical mass, and then it's like you, you're, you're better at storytelling about what your area's all about. 43:50 And I'm hoping that's what happens in Kentucky, is that we give mainly students from the University of Kentucky, University of Louisville, Centre, uh, Bellarmine, a reason to wanna stay here. 44:00 I think that's kind of the, one of the big levers that we can pull as a state, is how do we give more of our students a reason to stay here? 44:07 Like for me, I graduated with really no idea of what I wanted to do, and I had to go out and find the ambitious people and kind of figure out what that opportunity was for me within the tech scene. 44:15 And I think if we can provide more opportunities for that for our students, I think that's where things really start to get interesting. 44:22 Um, but to your point, I mean, Nashville, three hours away, uh, I think figuring out how we can collaborate more between those, those two cities. 44:29 And we're actually going to a conference, uh, with UK Innovate tomorrow to talk about collaboration between UK- Yeah... between Kentucky and Tennessee. 44:38 Um, so anyway, to, to, to conclude that thought there, um, totally aligned with what you're saying around coming back to Kentucky and, and what your hesitations were. 44:46 Um, but to end things off here, tell us a little bit about where we can, uh, learn more about you or Shadow Ventures if anybody listening here wants to, uh, to look into you guys more. 44:57 Yeah, so our, um, great place to start, learn about our portfolio is on, um, our website, shadow.vc, as in venture capital. 45:06 Um, you can learn more about me, um, through cl- you know, we have our team page on, on the site. Um, I think the, the links to my LinkedIn and, and Twitter account are, um, within that profile page on our website. 45:20 Um, but on, on-- I sometimes tweet. I've actually not been super active on Twitter, but I'm @pnickdurham on Twitter. Um, sometimes share, share thoughts there. 45:31 Um, but yeah, LinkedIn, feel free to, you know, reach out on LinkedIn if you wanna have a conversation. 45:35 And, um, yeah, again, l- you know, looking to meet like-minded, ambitious people in town, so please reach out if you're interested. 45:42 [upbeat music]