Transcript 0:00 What's going on everybody? You got Evan Knowles here with Logan Jones. We're sitting here in the Awesome Inc. podcast studio. 0:07 Uh, this is the intro for a series we just did with John Wilmoth and Christian Miller of Poplar Ventures. 0:14 Um, so Middle Tech was founded, just to give you a little bit of background here, Middle Tech was founded to help educate, inspire, um, and entertain this region of the United States as it relates to technology and startups and entrepreneurship. 0:26 Uh, we found that there was a big void in the market here. Um, and one of the things that a lot of founders, um, people in the ecosystem 0:33 ask us, and just we've seen a hole in knowledge in this region, is around, you know, venture capital. How do I raise money? It's my first time raising money. 0:41 Might be their second time raising money, but they're in later stages. Might be a Series A this time. Um, and so we wanna help answer those questions, so, uh, we sat down with, uh, John and Christian. 0:50 Yeah, and, uh, a lot of the questions that we found that, uh, these first-time founders have, um, they're getting the answers to these questions by consuming content that might be made for, uh, coastal firms, or made by coastal firms, or made for companies that are raising, uh, from those coastal firms. 1:06 So we wanted to partner with Poplar Ventures, which is a Louisville-based, uh, venture capital firm. 1:10 John, uh, Wilmoth and Christian Miller, who we're both really close with, and we consider them to be one of the premier venture capital firms in the state and in this area of the country. 1:18 Uh, we wanted to partner with them, uh, to kind of fill that void and bring it back to Middle America, and show what it's like to raise capital here. Um, so that's why we made this three-part series. 1:27 Uh, it's gonna go over all of the process of, of raising capital here in Middle America. Um, and it's gonna be very, very localized. 1:33 It's gonna be from the perspective of a venture capital firm that operates right in our, in our backyard there in Louisville, Kentucky. Um, so John and Christian are gonna talk us through that entire journey. 1:42 Um, and we just really hope this helps entrepreneurs, uh, in this area go into, uh, the process of raising capital with a lot of confidence. Um, so we hope you guys enjoy. 1:51 Um, and we're looki- looking forward to hearing you guys' feedback, uh, as you guys consume this content. 1:57 [upbeat music] All right, John, Christian, thanks for joining us, guys. 2:24 We're really happy to be here. Out of the Handle offices here in Norton Commons. So this is the second time- Glad to be back, yeah... we've recorded out of here. Uh, it's very... 2:33 We're very grateful for, um, Kyle Green to be providing these, these offices here. So let's dive just straight into the episode here. 2:42 Uh, first question, I want you guys to reintroduce yourself, 'cause John, we had you on several months ago. Uh, it seems like right before COVID. Right in the middle. I think it was right in the middle of COVID, I think. 2:51 Was it in the middle of COVID? Yeah, the very beginning. We were still a little hesitant to shake hands, I remember that. [laughs] That's right. I, I slightly... It seems like it's all a blur. I know. It's been crazy. 3:01 But, uh, so you introduced Poplar on that episode, but let's kind of re- revisit that, and reintroduce it again, and talk about, um, you know, how it got started and what you guys are doing now. Sure. 3:10 So, uh, Poplar Ventures is a early growth stage venture capital firm focused on software technology companies in Middle America. Um, we've raised $22 million in a fund. 3:22 Uh, we're gonna make probably in the range of six to 10 investments in that fund, four of which we've already made. 3:27 Um, we're looking for, uh, companies that are probably at a one to three to five million revenue, recurring revenue stage. Uh, so companies that have already gotten a little bit of traction. 3:40 Uh, typically not, you know, we will do... We will look earlier, we will invest earlier, but we typically are not trying to invest in companies that are pre-revenue or have very little revenue. 3:51 So we're, again, we're looking for a little bit more traction in terms of their particular product introduced to the market, and then, and that they're, they're at a stage where they're, they can now accelerate their growth. 4:01 So that's the primary focus. Um, you know, I, my personal background, uh, and why I kind of got to Poplar Ventures, you know, I had been doing, uh... My background was with Nextel Communications. 4:14 I spent 17 years in the wireless industry doing corporate development activity, also doing corporate VC work, uh, for Nextel. 4:23 Uh, and I think the experience that I had at Nextel was part of, you know, I think it's, it's, it is one of the value adds that we can bring to the table for, for our entrepreneurs. 4:32 Um, having started with a company that was a few million in revenue, grew it to, you know, 15 billion in revenue or whatever the number was when we ultimately merged with Sprint. 4:41 Um, saw a lot of change, obviously, over that period of time. A lot of, you know, kind of multiple iterations of management teams. Uh, a lot of activity in terms of M&A activity within the industry. 4:54 A tremendous amount of growth in the industry, just in terms of just the organic side of the business. 5:01 Um, so a lot of learnings out of that, that I, that I feel like, um, has positioned me pretty well to be able to help early stage growth businesses to help them, 'cause I, I, 'cause I've been there really, really early, and I've also seen them grow through those other stages. 5:16 So I, I feel like I have a fairly good balance of being able to, uh, bring that experience to the entrepreneur. Um- Yeah, the operating experience. Yeah, absolutely. And, and I think that, um, 5:29 you know, clearly, you know, my, my background, I started in banking right before Nextel, so my b- my functional expertise is clearly finance, and, and, um, you know, I would say corporate development or, you know, strategic deals. 5:43 Uh, that's clearly my functional expertise, but that operating experience that I got at Nextel, I think gives me a pretty good balance. 5:50 Um, and, and I think if you ask, if you asked any of the, uh, entrepreneurs that I've worked with over the years, um, of the companies that, that we've invested in in the past, I think you'll... 6:02 I think they'll give you a pretty good sense that I am You know, I'm hands-on in the sense that I wanna be involved, I wanna be, uh, there to help and be participatory in what they're doing with the business. 6:14 But I'm not so hands-on that I wanna run their business. It's their job [laughs]. 6:18 It's, it's the entrepreneur's job to run the business, but I want to be value add, and I'm, and I'm interested in being involved in the business, and that's kind of the approach that, that, that we're trying to take. 6:29 Yeah. And, uh, the Poplar team has grown since we last talked. Yeah. So I'd like Christian to go ahead and introduce yourself. Yeah. Can I... If I could just say- Yeah... 6:35 first of all, that I'm very happy to have Christian with me- [laughs]... because- I'm sure... because, uh- I'm sure... uh, you know, I launched this fund on my own. It, you know, I... 6:43 For 18 months, I basically have been kind of doing every, every possible part of the fund, which is not... There's some parts of it that aren't exactly fun. Yeah, that sounds about right. 6:52 Um, but, you know, it's very helpful to have somebody like Christian that has got good background, good experience, can help me kind of manage a lot more, increase the velocity of what we're doing. Awesome. 7:03 So yeah, Christian, if you wanna give us your background and, uh, what your official title is at, at Poplar. Yeah. Yeah. So, um, glad to be here. 7:11 Good to be back in the state of Kentucky and working with John, uh, at Poplar and doing a lot of fun stuff. So, uh, let's see. 7:18 You know, started my undergrad here in, uh, Louisville at Bellarmine University, econ, business, double majored, math minor. 7:24 Um, so that's kind of the semi boomerang effect is kind of what I say, which is the hot trend right now. Um, and then after that, uh, went up to Purdue to get my MBA, kind of first started my investment career there. 7:36 So, um, very fortunate to get a graduate assistantship with John Haning there. 7:41 And we, uh, kind of co-launched Purdue Ventures, uh, which was about $40 million under management under Purdue University, basically investing in Purdue-based startups. 7:51 So that was my first kind of real taste of venture investing and where I got to learn some of the very early on ropes of, uh, how to go about it and think about it. 8:00 Um, so did that for two years while I was getting my MBA, and then left from there to go up to Detroit, Michigan, to, um, 8:08 be with TRP Capital Partners, which is a lower middle market, uh, LBO fund, so later stage buyouts, complete transactions, uh, only focused in the transportation industry. Uh, the latest fund was about 200 million. 8:22 Very similar to kind of what I'm doing at Poplar, was supporting about four or five partners, um, and, and doing a lot of stuff. And my last investment there was actually a growth investment. We did a $30 million, um, 8:36 probably about a Series B round, and helped them grow. Sat on the board there. 8:42 And, um, my wife and I had our first child about a year ago, and so my wife gave me that natural kind of pressure, we wanna get closer to family. She's from Kentucky, um, very fortunate from that perspective. 8:52 And so, you know, John, uh, happened to be in the market, and we had a few calls, and came joined Poplar as a- Actually, Logan is the, is the reason you're here Oh, yeah. That's true. I forgot. 9:01 Yeah, Logan's the- A Middle Tech connection. Yeah, Middle Tech tied it all together and created this, uh, this relationship. Yeah. Music to our ears to hear that. [laughs] The one benefits of m- uh, many of Middle Tech. 9:13 Heck yeah. For sure. So let's start diving into Poplar's approach to deal sourcing here. 9:19 Um, so kind of walk us through what it looks like when you guys first hone in, uh, on a company that you think you might wanna invest in. 9:25 So let's just start from the top, uh, and then we'll work our way into that and dive deeper into the weeds. Yeah. 9:29 I think, I think the top, you know, for those listening, you know, like we said in the intro, we're trying to provide, you know, a perspective that gives you, that, that'll give you an idea of, you know, how venture firms go about, you know, investing in, in your company as an entrepreneur. 9:43 Um, and typically VCs start with a thesis. You know, that's kind of the, the first place maybe we should start. Um, talk about your all's thesis and, and what that is. Yeah. 9:52 So I think John really touched on kind of the core criteria of what we look for, you know, software based companies, probably Series A round. 10:01 You know, I think kind of one of our core ethos at Poplar is creating partnerships and really driving home partnerships with founders and management teams. 10:08 And so obviously we're always looking for an actionable deal that's, you know, ready to go, current in the market, fits all of our criteria from a revenue, uh, middle America software based company, traction, strong founder team or management team. 10:23 Uh, but the other side of that too is, you know, finding companies early on where you can, you know, help build a relationship there and maybe help them grow to the right point. 10:34 Uh, you know, I think the cool part about, uh, the four platform investments John made before I got here is he had a relationship with all of the founders or CEOs well in advance of ever actually putting capital to work, which helps, you know, from a due diligence perspective, but also once you get in, 'cause John said it, you know, best today, it's, it really is like a marriage, you know, in these early on investments, 'cause it's about 10-year probably investment cycle. 10:56 So knowing who you're getting in bed with is really critical. Um, and so from Poplar's perspective, you know, we are out there trying to find deals that are early on. 11:05 So, you know, what I would say to entrepreneurs listening is just because a VC shop doesn't necessarily fit who you are today doesn't mean you shouldn't be reaching out and building those relationships, 'cause you never know when you're gonna be raising capital. 11:17 You never know when you're gonna need to use that network to help raise capital. So, um, you know, that's a big focus of mine is finding probably companies in that seed. So maybe they have about 500,000 of ARR. 11:29 They have some corporate customers. They have traction. They still just need a little bit more time to get to that right point before it's right for us to make an investment. 11:37 And so I really focus on those, um, which is really driven by networking. I would say most of our deals really come through networking. 11:45 Now, it could be a new relationship and that, you know, it's flourishing, and your network's always expanding. 11:51 Um, so for entrepreneurs out there trying to get connected with VC shops, warm intros are really critical, I think, um, so leveraging your network in any way you can. Um, and then it... 12:03 But it doesn't hurt to cold outreach. I mean, we'll look at any deal that comes to us. 12:06 So I mean, if you are on a website, I mean, don't be, j- you know, go out there and still make the introduction for yourself if you think that VC shop is the right shop for you. Yeah. 12:15 And then make sure you're going to in-person events too. Absolutely. You know, all the great accelerators around here and story- Once COVID normalizes and all. [laughs] Of course. Of course. 12:22 Uh, there's virtual events now too. Yeah. [laughs] You know, they're trying to throw together some virtual events. Yeah, that's true. Virtual events actually have been great. I will say 12:28 You know, I've probably looked at 100-plus companies in the past two months. 12:32 Almost half have probably come from virtual-based events, you know, in Chicago, Nashville, um, multiple different places that would've been hard to cover in such a short time period. Yeah. Makes sense. 12:44 Um, so go out, you know, as an entrepreneur. Go to many, as many networking events, and, um, meet and greets as you can, 'cause that's where you're gonna meet potential future funders. Um, talk about... 12:55 Give, give a bit more of an idea of what, um, a warm intro or what a ca- a, you know, a cold call or a cold email would look like. 13:02 How would you like to be reached out to as an ent- as, as a venture capitalist, how would you wanna see an entrepreneur reach out to you in that first touch base? What, what does that look like? Yeah, I think, um, 13:14 again, I think as Christian said, warm intros are better than- Yeah... than, than cold. But it, that doesn't mean that you should be afraid of doing a cold intro. 13:24 Um, you know, I, I was, I was advising the Vote Award, you know, companies, uh, a couple weeks ago, and one of the things I was explaining to them is that you have to, you, they... 13:36 If you're an entrepreneur, you need to treat it like a, um, um... It's, i- it's A, both a sales process, uh, in terms of trying to raise capital for your business, and it is also a relationship process, right? 13:49 So you need to, you need to treat it that way. So you need to basically be thinking about they're not, this is not just sending out a cold email, um, and I hope I get a response. 14:02 It is, I'm trying to build a relationship, and sometimes if you're giving me a cold email, you know you're not at the right stage that I would typically invest, and it's okay. 14:11 I mean, I don't, I don't mind seeing the, seeing what's out there and understanding the business and learning a little bit more about it, and that quite frankly sets me up, you know, as Christian said, I, I... 14:22 Almost every one of the investments I've made [laughs] in the past have been situations where I've known the entrepreneur for quite a while. 14:29 So getting to know them ahead of time so that when, when, and when that right opportunity comes up, where they're at the stage where I, where, where we're wanting to invest, and, and we already have built that relationship makes a big difference. 14:41 So I would say focus on the relationship, and focus on it from, from a standpoint of a sales process. 14:48 If it's, if it's gonna be a cold email, I, all I really care about is that you're able to articulate what you're doing, honestly. It's not more complicated than that. 14:57 [laughs] So, and, and if, and if you can't do it in an email, that probably tells me something, right? 15:01 You ought to be able to explain your business and what you're doing and why you're doing it in, in a very short email. And just, just do that, uh, and, and reach out and say, "Hey, I'd like to have a conversation." 15:14 You know, I will... You know, if it's, if it's not software technology, um, you know, I, you know, I'm gonna tend not to s- probably focus as much time on that. 15:24 But if it's a software technology business, uh, you know, and, and you're giving me a good description of what you're trying to do, then I'm probably gonna respond. 15:33 Uh, and, you know, I might even be willing to take a phone call even though I know it's not gonna lead to anything imminent, because it could lead to something down the road. Yeah. 15:41 So I like the emphasis that we've had on here on building that initial relationship. 15:44 So once we get that, uh, that relationship established, I wanna, I wanna talk a little bit about what due diligence actually looks like, uh, when it comes to investing in a company. 15:53 What does it take to get to a term sheet, uh, with a company you guys have looked into, and now you're starting to dive into the team and the business model and everything else? 16:01 So what is, what is the first few steps that you guys take to start conducting due di- due diligence? Yeah. 16:08 Um, so I would say usually probably if, if the deal came through me and said, "John," usually I'll have a first intro meeting with the CEO or founder groups, kind of really vet the deal, make sure, you know, I think it's something that John should take a look at and, or we should take a look at very seriously, um, and begin that process of due diligence. 16:27 And then, so likely the next step would then be a, a meeting with John, so they pass all the criteria, make sure there's traction. 16:34 Um, so, you know, in your pitch decks, uh, when you're having that first meeting, you know, I, I really tell, uh, entrepreneurs, like, keep it short. 16:43 You know, usually it is a 30-minute, but get to the kind of meat of the bone, right? Um, you know, what you're doing, why is it a problem, talk about the market, give me a summary of the traction. 16:54 And you know, I would say we only invest in SAS companies. We don't understand all the markets by any means, but we do get a gist of it. 17:01 So, you know, versus spending 25 minutes on the, you know, the market, and you know, what the big problem is, tell me about it in a very concise manner. 17:08 Get to the point, but then also really some of why it's you we should go with, you know? And you know, what's your background, why have you been... How can you solve this better than anybody else? 17:17 Um, so I think that's huge in that kind of first initial pitch. Um, then from there, uh, really kind of follows a very concise diligence process, where, uh, we'll get access to a data room. 17:29 So, you know, another kind of maybe, uh, tip I can give entrepreneurs here is if you're serious about going out and raising capital, have that data room prepared, or at least, you know, core files you know that you're gonna need in that process. 17:42 Usually around kind of historical financials, um, you know, a summary income statement for year to date or whatever that time period is. Last 12 months can be kind of up to you. 17:52 Um, something that's a KPI tracker, so something that's really gonna highlight your key performance indicators, particularly for SAS. 17:58 So you know, looking at churn, revenue retention, customer acquisition, uh, how many logos or customers you actually have, and then kind of how that MRR or ARR has scaled over time. 18:10 Having stuff like that available and ready to go is gonna make your lives a lot more simpler. 18:15 Uh, es- especially once you get multiple VCs involved in the process, who are asking you for all these one-off different little kind of documents that they want to see as part of their diligence process. 18:24 Uh, 'cause I mean, a capital raising process is probably the most daunting thing for an entrepreneur, and The things you can do in advance to make it easier, I think are critical. Um, 18:34 and then so, you know, really, uh, from there it's gonna be focusing on kind of what are critical for us to get comfortable with an investment. So it could be market, understanding the market, the size. 18:46 Can this be a billion-dollar opportunity, or is this just a $100 million opportunity, right? 18:51 That, that's kind of going to how we're running our, our risk scenarios and, you know, our waterfalls at the end, um, because that's gonna make a big difference of what we think the exercise is here. 19:01 Um, you know, focusing on the team, you know, something I preach, and it's pretty important to me from an investment thesis standpoint, is there a strong founder market fit, right? 19:09 So if this is an ag-based software business, do the founders have an agricultural background, or have they been in, you know, real estate, you know, downtown New York sales for the past 15 years, and all of a sudden they just had an idea for an ag company and try and get after it, you know? 19:22 I don't... To me, that would... I would scratch my head about putting money behind these individuals. Not to say that those couldn't be successful, they definitely could, but for me, that's kind of a big, uh, thesis. 19:32 And then just looking at traction and when, you know, customers, and early on investments, I think the critical piece is customers. 19:40 You know, really understanding who's gonna be buying in, who are you going after, do you have the opportunity to scale up, or are you going top-down? Um, and then, you know, what is the pricing point around those? 19:51 And so that can take different shapes throughout a diligence process, whether, you know, you're actually, um, meeting with management. 19:58 You know, today we're doing all virtual meetings, um, you know, running financial models or talking with people in the industry, our network, our advisors, to try and get more comfortable with the deal. 20:09 Um, you know, John, I don't know if you'd add anything. Probably that process of what leads up to a term sheet, but I think, you know, those are kind of the core areas. Yeah. Yeah. No, I think you hit it. 20:17 A que- a question I had was you had mentioned that you wanna see experience, like domain experience from a founder. 20:22 What about some personality traits are you looking at with founders, and what are some, you know, key indicators that this person is prepared to go through this journey? 20:31 Or what are some indicators that maybe they're not prepared to be an entrepreneur? What are some things you look at there? Yeah, I, I don't know. 20:38 I don't know if it, I don't know if it's traits necessarily, but, you know, you're... 20:44 I, I, I'm usually trying to evaluate, when I'm asking the questions, some, a lot, some of the questions are very straightforward in terms I need to understand market opportunity, I need to understand what the product is and who your customer is and all those types of things. 20:56 But in, in a lot of respects, I'm, I'm trying to understand how that entrepreneur thinks and how they are... You know, if I ask them, you know, broader questions around the market opportunity, 21:06 that, you know, if you describe that market opportunity, that, that gives you some sense of have they thought this through or not. And, you know, half the battle for early stage businesses are, i- is 21:19 finding the folks that, A, number one, have that product, you know, the, the founder market fit. 21:24 They, they actually understand what they're doing in terms of the market opportunity, and then secondly, they actually understand how to build a company and how to identify a customer scale, a, a, a, you know, operating processes that allow them to build the business. 21:39 So it's, it's... That's what I'm looking for. I'm looking for just your, the grasp on the business. And, and honestly, you either have that one or you don't. Yeah. Right? I mean- Yeah... 21:50 there's no, there's nothing I can tell an entrepreneur [laughs] that would say, you know, be charming or whatever. [laughs] It doesn't matter. 21:57 You have to be able to explain your business, and you got, you gotta be able to [laughs] you know, walk through the, tho- those key aspects, otherwise I'm, I'm gonna lose interest pretty fast. Yep. 22:07 So you guys, once you do this due diligence, you dive into the financial profile of business, the business model, the go-to-market strategy, the founders, and the team in general. 22:16 You come to basically understand what kind of terms you might wanna enter into this business with. 22:21 Talk about, you know, what that, uh, looks like, um, valuation expectations and, and things like that right before, um, you know, you, you basically use this to inform what the term sheet looks like that you hand them. 22:32 So talk about that, that process. Yeah, so, um, 22:39 basically you're taking all those meetings that I just referenced and all the different elements about getting comfortable with the founding team and traits like that and trying to consolidate that into what you think this business is worth. 22:53 Um, and so, you know, valuation obviously is probably one of the key pieces of the term sheet, and, you know, what most of the founders are focused on. Not to say that that it should be the sole focus, but it usually is. 23:06 And so, um, I would say from Poplar's perspective, we look at all the public comps, we look at any relative M&A comparables in the private market that we are able to tie some type of valuation multiple. 23:19 Usually in our, our space, valuation is gonna be tied to ARR, so annual recurring revenue and some kind of multiple along those lines. 23:28 Um, and so basically trying to figure out what do we think an appropriate multiple is this, but then referencing, you know, outside comps. 23:36 So, you know, some people may say, "Okay, I'm gonna look at the comps and think, okay, here's a multiple that's in the marketplace. It should apply here." 23:43 I think Poplar, we were very, uh, conscious on, you know, what do we actually think this business is worth, right? 23:49 And does, does the public and private M&A landscape from a comparables perspective support that valuation? 23:56 Um, and so I, I think that's kind of our approach, and then you're gonna look at different deal structures, you know. So 24:03 there are all different types of early on, uh, investment rounds that can be raised, a convertible note, a SAFE, you know, or just a straight priced equity round. 24:11 We do straight priced equity rounds, or that's at least where our focus is, and so, um, usually we're putting some type of terms around that equity, that pricing. 24:20 So the valuation obviously is one of those, then there's the preferred structure that we usually do. 24:25 So some k- type of liquidation preference, some type of interest rate, uh, preferred return is what it's called, associated with that, and then management rights as well as other elements. 24:37 Um, so thinking through all those, usually with the founder team, you know, sometimes discussing that openly with them or then at least submitting a term sheet and having an open dialogue that, you know, sometimes turns into a negotiation. 24:49 Yeah. And I g- I... The one, the one thing I would And maybe not following on on that, but the one thing I would emphasize for an entrepreneur is don't generalize when you're trying to build these relationships. 25:02 You know, the... We, we hear a lot about the Silicon Valley VC versus a Midwest VC versus some other VC, right? The reality is you have to go build the relationship with a particular investor. 25:16 And so what you ought to be thinking about is, is, is there a good fit in terms of that investor, you know, knows my space? Is there a good fit in terms of do I get along with that particular investor? 25:29 Is there a good fit in terms of can they actually help me, you know, kind of get to the next stage? T- you know, those are the things that you need to be thinking about, and it's not so much about, you know, w- [laughs] 25:42 how does the... how does this VC act different than that VC, 'cause that's... those are general comments. And honestly, it depends on your business. It d- you know, if you have a business that is a... 25:52 going after a multi-billion dollar market opportunity, and it's a, you know, it's a land grab situation, and you've got a very good idea, and you need $50 million right out of the gate, guess what? We ain't helping you. 26:05 Yeah. [laughs] I, I mean, I can, I can, I can lead you to the right people that you do need to be talking to, but maybe you need to be in Silicon Valley. 26:12 On the other hand, if you have a business that basically can still be a very large business, but maybe you have to be a... 26:17 maybe it has to be one where you have to go prove product market fit first, and then you kinda, kind of work your way there. You can be cap- you can prove that you can be capital efficient. 26:26 You know, those are the businesses we like. So just make sure when you're having the dialogue with the investor, you're thinking about those things, right? Yeah. 26:35 Think about the fit, because that is much more important than worrying about where they're from or, or kind of what stage they typically like to invest in, 'cause it, you know, I think Christian said earlier, when you get involved, or you guys said it, when you get involved with somebody, it's a long-term thing in a venture business. 26:52 Yeah. It's not like I, I'm buying a stock in the stock market, I can sell it tomorrow, right? Yeah. I'm, I'm involved, you know, for, you know, 10 years. 27:01 At least that's been my mentality is I'm gonna be in this for 10 years. So when I'm... I am... I'm, I'm very focused on that fit. Yeah. 27:08 I'm trying to find- When you guys are, when you guys are trying to value these companies and create these valuations and the terms, are you looking at public data as far as, you know, the comps or the comparables to other software players in their, in their market? 27:22 Are you looking at things like Crunchbase? If I'm a founder and I wanna be on the same wavelength as you guys and come into the conversation informed, or at least look like I am, where can I go look for information? 27:33 I'd say Crunchbase is probably- Yeah... the go-to. Yeah. Uh, it's free for the most part. 27:37 Um, and it probably has all the data you need, both from a public and private standpoint of what type of transactions or even capital raising. 27:45 And even if you're not, and here's the other element too, even if you're not looking at it from, you know, a valuation comp perspective, but looking at who in your market's also raising money, right? 27:55 That also shows what type of expectations you should have. 27:58 So if you see a lot of people raising money in a specific segment, that means there's a lot of market demand from an investment side within that space, and so likely would force valuations up. 28:09 You could imply that, right? Um, on the other hand, if there's been no investments in your space, and that doesn't mean that the valuations couldn't be high, but I think it's just another indicator, right? 28:20 So, uh, just another way to think about valuation, about your fit in the marketplace, and how maybe investors are thinking about your business. 28:27 Yeah, I think that's an interesting segue into the next part of this, talking and comparing, uh, VC in, you know, places like Silicon Valley versus here in the, in the Midwe- or in Middle America, as we like to call it. 28:37 Um, and that's not something I don't think I've, I've really thought about, that, you know, a, the... 28:41 a company might have a different valuation if they're in this part of the country versus if they're in one where that industry is just a little bit hotter. 28:47 So let's try to debunk some of the myths around, uh, Midwest and Middle America VC versus what it's like out, out in Silicon Valley. 28:54 What are some of the, uh, misconceptions around venture capital in this part of the country? Ugh. [laughs] Where to start? Yeah, where to start? No. Um, honestly, I don't, I don't think that, um, 29:10 I don't think there's that many differences, honestly. 29:12 I mean, I think most investors are after the same thing, which is they're trying to find a ver- a, you know, a company that's going after a big market opportunity, that can grow fast, um, and, you know, can scale the business. 29:23 So from that perspective, they're not particularly different. 29:27 The big differences, I think I said earlier, is, you know, the, the s- the, the, the scale and amount of capital that you're willing to put into the business at the up- at the, at the outset or early in the process, um, or over those first, you know, three to five years. 29:46 If the scale of that's gonna be very big, it tends to be much bigger in Silicon Valley, right? They're making big, big bets. 29:53 Um, and so that team basically has the ability to go hire a lot of people very quickly, and they're basically going out and trying to win that market. 30:04 Um, so a lot of capital, build the team, go prove the market, go win the market. Um, again, there's different ways you can go about it. We're, we're not set up for that, quite frankly. Yeah. This is not 30:19 a, you know, billion-dollar fund. 30:21 So we're set up to s- try to identify those companies that we think are good companies, that can be big companies, and we're trying to identify the ones that, um, where there is good fit, where, where we think we can bring value, and they feel like we can bring value to the table. 30:38 So there's a, there's a good fit with the entrepreneur and the investor. And, and then, and then basically being able to participate in a way that, that grows with the company, right? 30:50 So, and grows in a, in a, you know, a reasonable way. So the valuation piece to me is, um- It's, it's just valuation is so, especially if you're early, you're really early, it's, it's art, it's not science. 31:05 So the one thing I always say to entrepreneurs is, if you can, I know it's difficult, take the emotion out of it. It is a financing transaction, right? 31:15 You have made a decision to go build a business, and you need money in order to be able to help you go build that business. 31:23 You have-- obviously, if you didn't have, you never needed money, if you could get customers paying you right off the bat, don't raise money. Just, just build it off of what you have from the customers. 31:30 But if you need the capital to grow the business, you're making a conscious decision that says, "I need it." Right? "I need that capital to build my business, so I'm willing to make that trade-off." 31:40 If you're willing to make the trade-off, then, then recognize that it's a discussion, right? It-- ultimately, the pricing is a, it's a, it's no different than any other market. 31:49 The public markets are easier because you get instant pricing. 31:52 In a private market, the only way you get that pricing is by having those conversations and having an investor show up and being willing to invest in the business. So best advice to the entrepreneur, get it competitive. 32:04 Make a competitive process, right? Get more than one investor interested in your business. You'll get, you'll get to the, what, what the clearing price is for that partic- for your particular company. 32:14 Um, but it's, it's more art at the earliest stage. As you get further on, you got operating metrics, then it's a lot easier to look at the public comps. 32:23 Obviously, you're gonna take discounts off public comps because nobody in the private market is gonna invest at those valuations. 32:28 But at least you have comps that you can look at that everybody can kind of get their heads around. But at the earlier stage, again, take the emotion out of it. It's not, it's not personal. It's a business decision. 32:42 You decided you needed capital to grow your business. As investors, we're focused on trying to find good companies, but we also have a fiduciary duty to our investors to get a fair price. 32:53 And I, and I don't think any investor has ever, ever really goes in and trying to screw an entrepreneur. I don't think that that is the intent. It has to be balanced so that both parties feel like that they have upside. 33:06 Both parties have to feel like that they're motivated to, to be successful. That's the best scenario. And so it's a process. And I'll be honest with you, it's probably the, it's the part I hate the most 33:18 because it, it forces, it forces [chuckles] an investor to basically say to you, "Your baby's not pretty." Right? I, I-- or, or maybe they say, "Your baby's really pretty." 33:31 But I've also never heard an entrepreneur say, "Oh, you paid too much." Right? Never, never heard them say that, right? Yeah. Another thing I, you know, I kind of chime in here. 33:44 So I would say also that from a coast and Middle America investment perspective, it doesn't have to be mutually exclusive. 33:51 So, you know, for example, if there's a Louisville-based startup here and needs to go out and raise $50 million, um, they're definitely gonna have to go out to the coast to do it. 33:59 But if they saw value in Poplar, you know, for instance, that doesn't mean that they just say, "Okay, well, see you later, Poplar. I'm just gonna go raise coastal money." And it could be any Middle America-based VC. 34:08 But if you saw value, you know, again, to the relationship element here, if you, if you're based here in Middle America, and you see value in a relationship with a Middle American-based VC group or for, you know, the different elements at which they can provide value, don't just cut ties and say, "Okay, well, I got to go to the coast because that's where I'm gonna get the big check." 34:27 Don't-- I wouldn't recommend doing that. I would say consider all avenues. But I think there is, you know, a common message of it, it has to be either/or, right? 34:36 And I think, you know, it, it would-- it's always good for an entrepreneur, and as John keeps saying, consider all options, and don't just cut ties because of where it's based. All right. 34:46 So that wraps up, you know, this first episode of this series here. 34:50 I think we had a great discussion on, you know, what Poplar Ventures is, where they're coming from, uh, what they look for in deals, how they source their deals as an entrepreneur, you know, how you should be speaking with venture capitalist firms. 35:02 I think we did a good job, you know, summarizing all that. This next episode, uh, we'll go right off the back of what we were just talking about, which is valuations. We'll dive much more into that with the term sheet. 35:11 So the investment, uh, is what we're calling this next episode. Um, we'll dive into that. Uh, so stay tuned. 35:20 [upbeat music]